All poor farmers in Singur are victims of Mamata's dirty game. CPM played once this kind of dirty game, got back everything and now this lady must get back also.
Re: Dirty game
by sujit sengupta on Jun 22, 2012 01:59 PM
Biplab Babu yes...the CPM played the dirty game and the lefts left..now the farmers will get back their lands once the Tatas loose at the SC.
Re: Re: Re: Dirty game
by sujit sengupta on Jun 22, 2012 02:08 PM
day draem...??the drwm is now coming true dear...because the howling of "we are 235..and they are just 30"....is actually dreaming now how come they have come donw to 60...
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Dirty game
by amit rakshit on Jun 22, 2012 02:23 PM
CPM has been thrown to Bay of Bengal...and Didi will be thrown to Sahara Desert.
Re: Re: Dirty game
by Koushik Sinha on Jun 22, 2012 02:55 PM
Sujit, I sincerely hope so! One suggestion to you - as a person concerned about the state of WB - can you spend all the energy - that you are demonstrating on Rediff to counter all valid/invalid messages regarding Mamata and Singur - on trying to convince her to come up with an economic and industrial policy for WB that will help industrialization in WB? Thanks!
Re: Re: Re: Dirty game
by Biplab on Jun 22, 2012 02:58 PM
Mamata can not come out with any vision or mission, how her chela Sujit will come up, he is just beating Mamata's drum, may be he is paid.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Dirty game
by Koushik Sinha on Jun 22, 2012 03:03 PM
Biplab, I have no issue with someone being a chela or paid message-poster of either TMC or Congress or CPIM. Bu I have a problem with people not using their brains to rationally judge a topic/fact/statement!
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Dirty game
by paper india on Jun 22, 2012 03:32 PM
I agree with Biplab. Bengal is full of NPA's, non-performers but full of hot air who can talk and talk no ends but cannot deliver. It pains me to write this, being a Kolkata boy, but the fact remains.
In last six years game who are losers and who are gainers? Losers are Bengale people, a small section of poor farmers in Singur Gainer is only one that is none but Mamata Banerjee.
Re: Re: Who are losers and gainer
by Biplab on Jun 22, 2012 02:06 PM
Safety life? Ha Ha. Bengle people will laugh. Budhdhdu did not lose, Bengal did lose
Re: Re: Re: Re: Who are losers and gainer
by amit rakshit on Jun 22, 2012 02:24 PM
CPM has been thrown to Bay of Bengal...and Didi will be thrown to Sahara Desert.
Re: Mamatha as CM
by sujit sengupta on Jun 22, 2012 02:02 PM
The ultimate aim for her was to recover the state from the gunpoint of the Komreds...(which they did in Netai)...
and when was some Mr Tiwari become a Railway minister sir..?/I think to comment also..you should have some minimumm knowldge..
Re: Re: Re: Re: Mamatha as CM
by sujit sengupta on Jun 22, 2012 02:11 PM
But who was this Mr Tiwari..who has become a railminister even...??Mukul Yoy's name doesn't even come near "tiwari".
1) Quickly arrange alternate employment / self employment to at least one, but preferably two members per family that lost land at Singur encompassing the entire 1100 Acres of land. Even if 2000 families are involved, we are talking of 4000 jobs, which IMHO is not much. Just gainful employment, anywhere in WB, suitable to peoples' abilities, whether an engineer's job or finance a roadside tea shop it does not matter, just permanent employement. Task a competent person with this ONE SINGLE KRA for the next one year. Even 50% success rate will turn the tide in your favor, nationally.
3) Repeatedly publicize, till it is drilled into everyone's head, that NO ONE drove Tatas out of WB. They left of their OWN VOLITION, in a huff, when they were 'only' given 600 Acres of land as opposed to their demanded 1100 Acres.
4) Challenge in court the legal validity of the confidentiality of the agreement signed between Tata & CPM for Singur. If possible let everyone know the terms & conditions therein.
5) Go after Tatas' hammer & tongs in the Supreme Court, appoint the best legal minds in Bengal, to fight for Bengal Pro Bono. Ensure this is not Tata Vs Mamata, but rather Tata Vs poor Bengalis, with nothing but their education and self respect to stand up to a capitalist who will stop at nothing.
A man who would call India a Bannana republic because his conversations with a fixer, like Nira Radia were published.
Re: As an astute strategist, here's my recommendation to Mamata
by sujit sengupta on Jun 22, 2012 01:50 PM
rightly said....Govt was alreday decided to move to SC if the verdict goes against them (so they will)..and by this time everytone knows what Tata said..."I shall not move from here even at Gunpoint"...and then eventually left the place....he was not bothered when an innocent girl is burnt inside his factory premises...but leaves when the gates are blocked.Every one knows about the "secret trade" by now..
Re: Re: As an astute strategist, here's my recommendation to Mama
by Biplab on Jun 22, 2012 01:53 PM
In SC Govt. will lose definitely. Before doing this act she knew what will be the outcome, but she wanted to do politics for her own interest, she is playing lives of poor farmers. CPM got back what they had done, this lady will get back one day what she is doing or did, that day is not far.
Re: Re: Re: As an astute strategist, here's my recommendation to
by sujit sengupta on Jun 22, 2012 02:14 PM
one more astrologer...well...let me put a forecast also.. in SC the Tatas will loose the case definately because in SC the Tatas are alreday having one more case alreday about the secret deal they did with the Komreds.
Re: As an astute strategist, here's my recommendation to Mamata
by Observer on Jun 22, 2012 03:53 PM
Argumentative Indian!
Your arguments reek of Communist era, when capitalists were chastised and chased out of Bengal in the name of exploitation. You want Bengal to continue do that? See what has happened to Bengal now. Bengal is lagging behind in industries behind other states by decades. Aspiring Bengali youth mostly had to leave Bengal in search of education or jobs. Ratan Tata is not Tata Motors alone. Tata Motors is a big automobile company and needs large tracts of land to develop a large scale project like Nano. You cannot play with the size of a project by saying that you have to do whatever in 600 acres instead the 1100 acres agreed earlier. If the size does not fit the project plan, any industrialist will have to back out. Any such back out will obviously have financial implications - contract exit clauses to be invoked. Let these exit clause be made public and WB government either obey the contract clauses or contest the same in court. Nothing to be personal here. Bengal has already lost the project and many Bengalis have lost jobs or prospective jobs.
I'd rather like a 'little corrupt man' who is a great visionary than an honest(in terms of money only) but lying and a woman with no vision for the future (like our Dumb Didi!) as our CM or PM!
Re: What a waste!!
by sujit sengupta on Jun 22, 2012 01:42 PM
Due to her Vision only..the skeletons being reconvered from inderground.Due to her vison only politicals murder has almost come to zero in JOngolmohol and the hills.Due to her vision only Kishenji could be killed though he could meet the repoters earlier but administration never found him.
Re: Re: Re: What a waste!!
by sujit sengupta on Jun 22, 2012 01:51 PM
KKR Victory Parade was the outburst ogf atleast 1.5 lakhs fellow men who actually felt KKR to be their team.(This parade was organised with a days time and seeing 1.5lakhs peole...some people really started to feel jelous)
Re: Re: Re: Re: What a waste!!
by sumit mukherjee on Jun 25, 2012 04:49 PM
KKR victory parade was complete waste of public money, not to mention a display of crassness by the CM herself. Crores of public funds spent on lauding the achievements of a privately held company's cricket team.
Re: Re: What a waste!!
by Biplab on Jun 22, 2012 01:51 PM
Mamata has vision? This is the joke of 21st century. Kishenji wanted to see Mamata as CM. All junglemahal TMC men went to Kishenji team, but after Mamata's victory all these people came back to TMC, gave actual information about Kishenji, the he got killed. Due to her vision? Don't talk rubbish. This thing you can tell poor illetarate people, not here.
Re: Re: Re: What a waste!!
by sujit sengupta on Jun 22, 2012 01:52 PM
Biplab Babu...just give me two data...howm many mureders happened dutring 2010 compared to 2012 in Jongolmohiol..and how many bandhs happened in the hills during 2010 comared to 2011-12..if you cannot then it will be proved who talks rubbish.
Re: Re: Re: Re: What a waste!!
by Biplab on Jun 22, 2012 02:02 PM
Very few sir, I know everything, but why? Earlier who got killed? How many TMC suppporters got killed? Answer is no one. All Maoists, TMC people joined together and was killing opposite party workers, school teachers, students. Can you remember? With the help of these Maoists they got most of the seats in that area, then they trew Kishenji by killing him. Everybody knows this. Sujit babu you also know this
Re: Re: Re: Re: What a waste!!
by swapnadip on Jun 22, 2012 02:34 PM
Senguptaji, when there will be no FIRs registered against murders, how will one record murders?? First, allow FIRs to be registered and see how the polygraph between Murders and time increase exponentially!!
Mamata is simply incorrigible. She won't the lesson from the history. Her populist policy is sure to lead Bengal ten years backward. Bengal needs a true change. Mamata failed miserably and doesn't like to listen nor to rectifiy her mistake. Her ego will sure enough to cause great burden on the poor.
Re: Singur! ! !
by sujit sengupta on Jun 22, 2012 01:30 PM
Really...??Tatas lost in the HC single bench..thats the reaons they moved to division bench...so then at that point of time Tata's Bluff and the secret trade domne was caught...
Mamata should stop her dirty game. She threw Tata out only for her own interest and she got power out of it. She never though about Ma Mati Manus. Always she plays use and through game. She must selfanalyse that how many auto companies are there in Sanand now, how many jobs are created there. She must go to Sanand and ask local people how they are benefited out of Tata factory. She must go to Chennai, Gurgano, Pune. She is in power more than one year. No anchor investor has come to Bengal in this period. But still she is lying telling that her Govt. got 1 lakh Cr investment. Actually she is showing investments came in previous regime. She should stop all these nonsense. She must remember that Bengle people tolerated CPM for 34 years, it won't repeat again.
