@Reply to whole world ---------- after reading all forums ,debates etc let me make it clear ---------------- SUPPORT: ===---==== ALL INDIAN POLITICAL PARTIES SUPPORT 51 PERCENT INVESTMENT FDI IN RETAIL ======================================== DO NOT SUPPORT: ============= 51 PERCENT FDI OWNERSHIP IN RETAIL ON PAN INDIA BASIS =========================== First see the diff between the above two and then comment ============================= Also TATAs buying - CHORUS or Jaguar(FOrd) is company to company transaction ,not initiated by Indian govt to UK Govt ==== same way --------- Indians buying COAL plant from Hancock coal is also Company - company Transaction not Govt initiated at all
also AUSTRALIA benefist selling COAL ,as it gets hard cash as well into its economy
COAL is still considered polluting source of POWER generation fuel and Indians will get the pollution in air (Indian skies) ---------
Re: Re: @REPLY TO WHOLE WORLD
by rama anne on Dec 08, 2011 11:14 AM
OPPOSITION parties say ----- ownserhip in FDI retail will be decided at a later time (satge 2 )after taking stock of the situation
If nothing else, it will get rid of the leeches the myriad middlemen who suck the blood of the farmers as well as the consumers. Enough of selling third rate goods at inflated prices. Consumers need choice. Anyway, these middlemen, so called traders are all BJP supporters. They need to stop this blood sucking and look for real jobs.
Re: Real Reason
by rama anne on Dec 08, 2011 10:57 AM
@Reply to aus ant ------------------ a few clarifications ------------------- I think all political parties including BJP -THEY SUPPORT 51 PERCENT INVESTMENT IN RETAIL read again the above line what they are saying is THEY DO NOT SUPPORT 51 PERCENT FDI OWNERSHIP
Those who have participated in recent strike should now sell only desi products leaving MNC items !!! At least the kirana stores should show the desi one first and keep HUL,ITC,ets in back side racks ... hey.... hey....
Re: FDI IN RETAIL TRADE
by rama anne on Dec 08, 2011 11:05 AM
@KASHINATH PAUL ----------------- INDIAN POLITICAL PARTIES SUPPORT ------ 51 PERCENT FDI INVESTMENTS IN RETAIL =============== DO NOT SUPPORT 51 PERCENT OWNERSHIP IN FDI RETAIL
First see the difference ------------ FDI in retail is PAN INDIA basis as well
PATELS owning motels is PRIVATE AFFAIR not initiated by INDIAN GOVT to USA
With FDI the middlemen are not removed but in reality their number actually increases. Behind the scene all these Middlemen are related to the Retailers
They just take new forms–
Quality controller, Standardiser, Certification agency, Packaging consultant etc – operate and live with farmer’s income.
This the Retailer earns even more abd costs keep rising
Due to the sheer size and buying power, big retail generally forces farmers to reduce prices.
(Have any builder ever given good price to the Farmers whose land they buy)
In England, Tesco paid 4 per cent less to farmers then local shops. Low supermarket prices in Scotland have forced irate farmers to form a coalition called ‘Fair Deal Food’ to seek better price for their farm produce
Are these retail kings indians with their headoffices in India. No theya er either Indian born foreigners or Person of Indian origins. They are not indian nationals. Their businesses have nothing to do with India. FDI is totally different scenario. Naive Rediff.
Re: Apples vs Oranges
by Anil Kumar on Dec 07, 2011 01:18 AM
Absolutely correct. Rediff just wants to throw some news at the reader's face. They dont know what they are writing.
Re: Do you know what you are talking about?
by shubha srinath on Dec 06, 2011 07:54 PM
I completely agree with you. Who ever has written that is out of his brains
Please take a note by readers that this miss presentation by rediffmail that Indians are doing well in Abroad, First of all in London itself more than 25000 Indian retail shop owner are jobless and money less because of Super Markets . Secondly very few Indians are having super market most of them are small retail business which required small capital. Not a single billionaire or millionaire which is shown in the above list started with big supermarket they straggle hard and then they achieve this level. Now these so called Americans and britishers realized that unless and until we take buying and selling in our hands we can’t control the world economy so they plan to put super market in India and will start selling imported product from America and Europe which is exported by India in a form of Raw material to America and Europe. Our politicians want to send us old British Colonial days to buy a salt we will have to pay this American and Europeans. Please I want to request you to all Indians not to allow this people to enter in retail market.
