I find thedicussio fruitless. The girls in India will come to professional courses and many of them may marry andraise family. There is nothing wrong as the education isinsurance ofthegirl. Talking of AICTE regulation it is foolish for Govt to control when a better curriculum can beoffered by any one. It shd be on merit if therfe are changes. When I introduced in Fore, Eastern management no one taught it in thecountry. I had to make it an additional item.We should know sthe reality of the cousntry andits culture and teach what is needed.We should also teach what cororate world needs. How may elite shcool teachers or directors have managed corporations and shown results? Neither the Minisstry nor the elite shools know the way. We need to Ponder.Prof N.K.Singh
According to Rashmi - 1. The girls in tier2/3 colleges are very intelligent. They are not dumb. They are amibitious and have a very strong desire to excel in career. 2. A girl is better off working on a salary of 8-10k per month with all kind of stress, harassments, smoking, pre and post-marital relations, than work as a housewife where she will take care of a family and bring up good, healthy and emotionally strong citizens.
The fact- 1. Most of the girls in tier2/3 colleges themselves are there for timepass, to escape from household responsibilities, to enjoy life, and last to get a degree. 2. A girl can contribute to our society in a far better way by being a good housewife. And she will still be leading a family and by no means will become inferior to men.
Its time for Indian educated women to grow up, see the reality that they are causing equal problems if not more, in society presently. A women in west will volutnirily become housewife to make sure the children and family is well take care of. And they will even marry and support a less earning or jobless person. Can any indian girl do this?
Re: A very good example of extreme and foolish feminism....
by yugandhar gokhale on Jan 08, 2011 07:03 PM
You may want to think again about your 'fact' number two. There is no fixed rule that a girl can contribute better to the society by being a housewife. There's trouble everywhere. If workplace can be full of harassment and stress, so can the household. The issue is that the girls in india should have the courage, capability and freedom to take decisions on their own. Instead of marrying because their fathers or brothers want that to happen and then they're just towed around like a buffalo by the husband.
A person contributes better to the society by being active, participating and maximising his / her potential in whichever field.
As a matter of fact i also do not entirely agree with your 'fact' number one. Girls do come to colleges for studies but all don't come for timepass. The ones who really do excel in studies have to give it all up for what you call 'household responsibilities'.
It is time to grow up, not for indian women, but for us guys, and to consider women as our equals and not our property. Maybe from where you come, girls are still taught that they're 'paraya dhan' and $h1t .. because it's good 'culture'. If you endorse these views, you're seriously delusional in this age. Think it over.
Re: A very good example of extreme and foolish feminism....
by DK on Jan 08, 2011 07:05 PM
excellent alternate opinion.......rashmi madam if you read the reviews of your articles then you should definitely consider this as well
It is not all the in laws and husbands who prevent M.B.A. WOMAN FROM GETTING employed. In many cases it is they themselves who decide to be unemployed, i know many woman in my family circle who are wasting and not only that these woman do all to prevent their husbands from becoming entrepreneurs. In many B-schools there is no proper library facilities it self and and majority of the faculty members don't have business experience. Most of these schools maintain the idea that education is only for a risk free life and they discourage entrepreneurship at all. Fresh new admitted candidates must be subjected to a orientation program helping them to get an idea about business life. Now exams, they are not conducted for the purpose of testing the knowledge acquired by the student, but only to test their memory power. to add cap to all these the students don't don't have thirst for knowledge they just want degrees so that they can get good dowry.
Re: Womens are more stronger
by Gaurav Kishore on Jan 08, 2011 03:09 PM
Its true man but reality is other way means that education is for eligibility tag. It’s a fact that graduate girls from good colleges tend to be more smarter than these MBAs.
Educate a girls three generation will benefit & educate a guy only he will do himself good.
Recently I visited an B Grade University campus as industrial expert.MBA 1st year students were so poor in knowledge that one cannot believe. One student was not even knowing about Abbre. of ATM, debit/credit card etc. When I asked his graduation background, he said that he did B Sc. (IT) from the distance education centre and now got admission in MBA.Other avcademic staff were saying that its common with first year students.
Re: Facts of life
by AMUTAN NS on Jan 08, 2011 03:54 PM
i wholly agree with you and the crux of the problem is with the students mentality. Many students are taking to M.B.A only to skip time and earn a fashionable title and write it behind their names. Even at the time of joining the program itself, they are somehow well conceived that all these theories are useless and having no practical. Not a single student bothers to put to practical application what they are taught(myself being an exception )and the availability of bazaar notes is a deplorable fact. Government must ban the publication of these bazaar notes. In the written test essay type question answers must be avoided. When i wrote Financial management exam the questions were like this write an essay on financial analysis, cost ratio.; There was no opportunity for me to demonstrate my ability to prepare and scrutinize balance sheets and cost and statement of changes in financial position. Yes M.B.A QUESTION PAPERS MUST BE IN A WAY TO HELP THE STUDENT his analytical skills by using the knowledge he has gained, by studying the course
Re: Where
by Arun Kant on Jan 07, 2011 04:19 PM
These are not her words, she is referring to 'a real claim made by a real B-school in the national capital'. Perhaps in an advert
i read few of the comments, from "MBA-A tool to get 'good Match'" to 'language? i think the arical is meer personal observation. but agreee to the fact that An IIM Gra. and salesman are the types of MBA in this country
