There is no doubt that a majority of the people seek a change. And at this moment there is no other alternative than Mamta. But there's an underlying danger in supporting Mamta. She herself may be hard working and has proved herself in the past as effective and result-oriented as a Railway minister. But the same may not be said about her colleagues and supporters. But given the condition WB is in today, it would probably make sense to reject the LF for the time being. People like Biman Bose, Subhash Chakrabarty, Binay Konar, Gautam Deb, Anisur Rahman, Biswanath Chowdhury, Jogesh Barman, Manabendra Mukherjee, Mrinal Banerjee all have been proved to be incompetent and useless.
Therefore it may actually prove to be beneficial for WB to support Mamta in next assembly election.
Re: Is it Mamta? Doubtful!
by rajiv mukherji on May 13, 2009 05:50 PM
I would love to Tolerete CPM for another 25 years but Cant tolerate Mamata for a single day... A Brainless (Of course she has a Destructive mind), useless and nasty creature......
WB and Bengali's want a change but Mamta is no replacement. She is still not reliable and mature enough to rule a state and that is the reason WB wont see a change. Cong- TMC combine may be able to make some good show but as far as change in state govt. is concerned wait till a formidable and reliable person emerges in WB as an option to CPIM or else it will be red flag till then
Re: Till Mamta, no change
by Sundaram on May 13, 2009 03:28 PM
WB's gain with Mamata as CM may still be UPA's "gain" of keeping her out of the UPA cabinet !!
Re: Mamata's collegue caught taking bribe
by Sundaram on May 13, 2009 03:27 PM
WB's gain with Mamata as CM may still be UPA's gain(of being able to keep her out diplomatically !).
all the political parties including the the great dummy leader for congress /bjp, are using communists' slogans/policies for poor people.therefore,communist policies are the main plank for seeking votes.therefore,communists are a part of indian democracy.they are much better than many moneybag based politicians.left front will not come back to power,if madarsa scheme succeeds to destabise WB.may i know who are financing the chane brigade?the answer will explain every doubt.we need change ...but in trade union and education policies of left front.we donot want any leadership change.
I am yet to see Mamta work as a cool team player in any PM's cabinet. I think, her mind-set works best when she is busy agitating against some thing or the other. She is not meant for doing any calm, conducive, and constructive work with a vision. So even if she wins WB and becomes CM, God's mercy is still required in plenty by people of WB.
Re: Mamta is too mercurial...
by mailme alladin on May 13, 2009 02:46 PM
How can you say that. She promised to turn north bengal to Switzerland and Kolkata to London. She must be cool to promise these,
Re: Re: Mamta is too mercurial...
by Sundaram on May 13, 2009 03:23 PM
Promising is a momentary job, it is the implementation from cencept to reality, that takes time and enormous amount of patience. Does she have it ?
Re: Re: Mamta is too mercurial...
by Iam He on May 13, 2009 03:43 PM
Do you and ur didi Mamta has ever gone out of India? Do you people know the living cost of London? This is a hard slap by the didi to the lower-middle class people of Kolkata. I have never seen such blunt headed man / woman.
Dear Bengalies kick out now CPM and CPIM and Mamata and remove Bengali immage of Labour. This is the time and give vote to BJP or national party good candidate only.
Today Bengali are known as good labour in other state mainly construction field. eveen if Bengali is higly educated he is seen as labour or coolee in IT or any other Industries. Every one tell them BAMPANTHI. This is the level you have got after independence so do not be angry come forward and change this Govt now.
Re: Re: Vote for BJP
by yele on May 13, 2009 03:28 PM
means Bengali will never cahnge ?? Why Bengali can not take lead ?? why BJp should reject first ? if you people do not send her to Parliyament than ofcourse BJP or everbody will kick her out.?? So if you have decided to be with Third world state like Bihar ,UP , Bengal which is shame for India than what we can do , we can suggest you only, Yes we need collie and labour too ?? so even if you people do not get change we will not force after all India is democratic.
Left Leaders headed by Budhadeb at any day far better then Mamata.... so Bengal don't want to change Budha ..but we want to change Left Party and concentrate on development not on Party cader..stop all Part Activity in Bengal ..no politics..let people vote whom ever they want on the polling day... We need Budhadeb, Nirupam sen a administrator , CM not a CPM leader...........and Mamata , thank please stay way from Govt..u r fit for opposition only
Re: Bengal need a change the way Left Party works , not the leade
by navindian on May 13, 2009 02:42 PM
Mamata doesn't look to be the change that bengalis want to see..
Re: Bengal need a change the way Left Party works , not the leade
by yele on May 13, 2009 02:46 PM
Dear Bengalies kick out now CPM and CPIM and Mamata and remove Bengali immage of Labour. This is the time and give vote to BJP or national party good candidate only.
Today Bengali are known as good labour in other state mainly construction field. eveen if Bengali is higly educated he is seen as labour or coolee in IT or any other Industries. Every one tell them BAMPANTHI. This is the level you have got after independence so do not be angry come forward and change this Govt now.
Re: Re: Bengal need a change the way Left Party works , not the l
by joydip bhattacharya on May 13, 2009 02:57 PM
not sure from where u have got this data that educated Bengalis r working a coolies ..but try to see different industries arround u and u will see in many places Bengalis are leading ... those bengalis are well educated are not doing too badly outside Bengal... just see ur tv sets and see different news channel , I can bet u u will see most Bengalis there ..not necessarily they r reporting from Bengal...
Re: Re: Re: Bengal need a change the way Left Party works , not t
by yele on May 13, 2009 03:23 PM
This is what Bengali feels and they project themselves as very intelligent. Even if they are in leading place but what about immage ??
Re: Re: Re: Re: Bengal need a change the way Left Party works , n
by Onkar Mukherjee on May 13, 2009 03:32 PM
tht was hillarious yele. hehe cant stop laughing.
Re: Re: Bengal need a change the way Left Party works , not the l
by joydip bhattacharya on May 13, 2009 02:57 PM
not sure from where u have got this data that educated Bengalis r working a coolies ..but try to see different industries arround u and u will see in many places Bengalis are leading ... those bengalis are well educated are not doing too badly outside Bengal... just see ur tv sets and see different news channel , I can bet u u will see most Bengalis there ..not necessarily they r reporting from Bengal...
Re: Bengal need a change the way Left Party works , not the leade
by B Lal on May 13, 2009 02:42 PM
Two options 1. Choose the demon or 2. Choose the devil.
Re: to defeat Commies in Bangla
by yele on May 13, 2009 02:43 PM
Dear Bengalies kick out now CPM and CPIM and Mamata and remove Bengali immage of Labour. This is the time and give vote to BJP or national party good candidate only.
Today Bengali are known as good labour in other state mainly construction field. eveen if Bengali is higly educated he is seen as labour or coolee in IT or any other Industries. Every one tell them BAMPANTHI. This is the level you have got after independence so do not be angry come forward and change this Govt now.
Re: to defeat Commies in Bangla
by Desert Fox on May 13, 2009 02:41 PM
Well I take back one of the things. low/backward caste leaders won't help. 63% population belongs to FC in bengal.
This is drastically different from UP/Bihar where Laloos, Mayas rule.
Re: to defeat Commies in Bangla
by yele on May 13, 2009 02:44 PM
Dear Bengalies kick out now CPM and CPIM and Mamata and remove Bengali immage of Labour. This is the time and give vote to BJP or national party good candidate only.
Today Bengali are known as good labour in other state mainly construction field. eveen if Bengali is higly educated he is seen as labour or coolee in IT or any other Industries. Every one tell them BAMPANTHI. This is the level you have got after independence so do not be angry come forward and change this Govt now.
Re: to defeat Commies in Bangla
by Desert Fox on May 13, 2009 02:41 PM
Well I take back one of the things. low/backward caste leaders won't help. 63% population belongs to FC in bengal.
This is drastically different from UP/Bihar where Laloos, Mayas rule.
It is high time for Bengal for a change. 32 years is too much. In the next assembly election, Congress-TMC must be voted to power. Their 5 year rule will expose them. It will be like BJP allince in the centre. All the time they were blaming Congress for their bad rule since independance and finally NDA voted to power. In their tenure they proved that they are good for nothing and UPA came back again.
Re: Change
by rupak banerjee on May 13, 2009 04:58 PM
if congress can rule the country for most of the time after independence,how does 32 years be a threat?.. left front is not C P M alone.BLIND VENGENCE AND ARROGANT ANTI LEFT{or for that matter anti bjp or anti congress} is not a healthy attitude for political governance of this country.100 or 200 years old theory needs change.we donot undervalue our ancient sastras which are still the values of our life .YELE resembles a friend of mine who stopped using left hand and left side of road to record his anti left leanings. RIDICULOUS.all indian political leaders should pay royalty to MARX for using his written theory FOR BEGGING VOTES.
