though Cauvery is the daughter of Karnataka, shez the bride of Tamilnadu... let her flow and live life in HER soil... let's respect the Law of Nature...
RE:Holy Cauvery
by nagaraj on Feb 05, 2007 05:42 PM Permalink
Please destroy the dam at Mettur and respect the law of nature, let us not hold cauvery at Mettur, let her reach the final destiny..Ocean Probably that clearly explains the law of nature
RE:RE:Holy Cauvery
by on Feb 06, 2007 05:56 PM Permalink
whats u r point ? Dont be rubbish and speak what is needed .. its because of you people that all others getting affected.So kindly stop your innocence .
RE:RE:Holy Cauvery
by manohar pillai on Feb 05, 2007 05:53 PM Permalink
Dear Nagraj, If u r saying by removing dam at mettur only will avoid hurdles to that holy river, shouldnt u think that the other may demand dismantling all dams (there are more than 10 dams across Cauvery in Karnataka from the its originating place). As we are involved in construction of dams, we cant think of destruction to any structure. China has improved a lot by linking of rivers I dont think there are not much narrow minded persons who objected that proposal. Tell me, if there is proposal between u and UP to link Ganga with Cauvery, should nt u accept that offer. It clearly shows difference between Narrow minded person to a broad thinker
RE:RE:RE:Holy Cauvery
by raj on Feb 05, 2007 07:45 PM Permalink
Mr Pillai, Please understand my response was to "Law of Nature" as quoted by the writer, he wants a free flow of water to TN as Law of nature(bride of tamilnadu and what not), Iam extrapolating the views of the writer by saying that, then dont stop water in Mettur too.
Certainly your comments have given me the perspectives of narrow minded person..
RE:RE:RE:RE:Holy Cauvery
by manohar pillai on Feb 05, 2007 06:10 PM Permalink
Hey there is one idea instead of dismantling any dams why can we collect money to built more dams across Cauvery in both TN and Karnataka This will not only solve problem to both the states, and also gives the following benefits 1. Supply water to irigation lands at regular intervals. 2. Increase the Ground water table level 3. Avoid problems of fighting between brothers and sisters. what do u say??
RE:RE:RE:RE:Holy Cauvery
by Swaminathan V on Feb 05, 2007 06:10 PM Permalink
Basically Karnataka people are very soft and broad minded people. This agression got created by the opportunistic politicians who wants to gain politocal mileage for their survival. Dear Kannadigas, please uderstnad the politicians, In this verdict, there is no injustice to both Tamil Nadu and Karnatka and none of them are going to be affected. Only politicians will be affected and they want to create probelm for their survivals. They will provoke the innocent people and farmers. Dont get carried away.Let us unite.
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Holy Cauvery
by on Feb 05, 2007 06:29 PM Permalink
Even educated people, Software engineers have got this agression. It is very bad on society. People are not willing to Think and they just get carried away by the media and the politicians. Let us keep cool and think positively
Our only request to the politicians, on behalf of Indians, including Karnataka & Tamilnadu, is to handle the situation reponsibly with lot of maturity. Do not politicise the issue for your own sake and disturb the peace and become a reason for community clash.
ATleast, we expect this from you at this juncture.
The allocation of 270 tmc of water to Karnataka against 419 tmc to Tamilnadu is not ustifiable. Release of water as per monthwise stipulations will always be difficult since it depends on so many factors like availability, water requirements for drinking, agriculture and other needs of the command areas.
Verdict should not be based on historical agreements, but instead should have been based on scientific data regarding command area and optimal water requirements of each state. It will be very difficult to meet the drinking water needs of Bangalore and other cities within this allocation.
In a normal year, even excess water than stipulated above is being released by karnataka to Tamilnadu. But during deficiency, Tamilnadu should not claim water as a matter of their right and should not make political noises, instead they should adopt give and take policy and should settle such issues by mutual discussions only amongst the farmers of two states without involving any politicians.
RE:Cauvery Tribunal Verdict
by Senthil Prakash on Feb 05, 2007 06:36 PM Permalink
Dear Friend, Please think twice before you write anything on a public message board. Do you mean the death cry of thousands of farmers as noise? Do you mean that TN has to adopt to sharing during deficiency?
Hi My dears, In my experience this was one of the historical verdicts made by Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal.
I think this is good learning to Indian peoples and Politician because this is correct time to integrate all rivers at any cost...karanataka government and people should respect this verdict.
Also I request to my respectful Chief Minister Mr.Karunanidhi should take necessary step to protect Tamil people who%u2019s living in Karnataka.
All Tamiladu people and politician should join hand with chief minister and avoid unnecessary politics in this Cauvery Issue.
RE:Good verdict and good learning to Indian Peoples !!
by SHIVA SP on Feb 06, 2007 12:22 PM Permalink
when you people have done the necessary dirty politics to get your desired verdict.......you are talking about unnecessary politics its a shame....TN is greedy supported by stupid judges in a political lobby...KA is severely victimised...KA will not accept this bullshit
RE:Good verdict and good learning to Indian Peoples !!
by raji koshy on Feb 06, 2007 01:33 PM Permalink
when verdits are made as per political millage, i dont have water for myself, and you want me to share with the neighbor - does this not look funny
Please note that verdict does not say that Karnataka should release 419 TMC to TN. It only says that TN should get 419 TMC out of total of 740 TMC available in Cauvery. For TN to get 419 TMC, Karnataka needs to release only 192 TMC. TN gets rest of water from Cauvery water capturing area in TN itself. This is 13 TMC less than tribunals' interim award of 205 TMC.
Out of 192 TMC that TN gets from Karnataka, it has to release 30 TMC to Kerala and 7 TMC to Pondicherry.
So, unlike the media projects, verdict is not against Karnataka. It is more or less in line with interim verdict only.
Infact karnataka get more share than TN. Understand the reality..
RE:know completly before ur comment, read hind for complete news please
by Neha on Feb 05, 2007 05:23 PM Permalink
That's a good analysis..but both the states need not to worry, our scientists are in process of reasearching in coverting Sea water to fresh water, If that thing works out, I hope TN can supply water for Karnataka
RE:know completly before ur comment, read hind for complete news please
by mahendra ganesan on Feb 05, 2007 05:20 PM Permalink
This post is already posted here by many N number of times
this river kaveri is mother for karnataka and tamilnadu. there is equal share for both.as per land and water requirements. anyhow we are brothers fightings
RE:river kaveri
by murthy gowda on Feb 05, 2007 05:34 PM Permalink
Yes, We are not suppose to fight each others. let People of TN & Karnataka deside on this. Because Political parts are allways danger. don't give chnnce to play around.
RE:RE:river kaveri
by KVS SAMBAMURTHY on Feb 05, 2007 05:44 PM Permalink
well said mr.murthy gowda. let us not give chance to politicians to play with people of both states. sambamurthy
RE:RE:RE:river kaveri
by guru ramaiah on Feb 07, 2007 02:24 PM Permalink
please leave the matter to our farmers they can solve kaveri problem, They are very inteligents compare to these judges & politicians.
Please note that verdict does not say that Karnataka should release 419 TMC to TN. It only says that TN should get 419 TMC out of total of 740 TMC available in Cauvery. For TN to get 419 TMC, Karnataka needs to release only 192 TMC. TN gets rest of water from Cauvery water capturing area in TN itself. This is 13 TMC less than tribunals' interim award of 205 TMC.
Out of 192 TMC that TN gets from Karnataka, it has to release 30 TMC to Kerala and 7 TMC to Pondicherry.
So, unlike the media projects, verdict is not against Karnataka. It is more or less in line with interim verdict only.
Infact karnataka get more share than TN. Understand the reality..
RE:READ THIS FIRST..............
by illusion of me on Feb 06, 2007 02:24 AM Permalink
so whatcha tellin me is, during a dry season, no matter what TN shud be getting 419tmcft? even if there isnt a grey cloud in sight on top of KAR? cauvery flows equally in both the states. TN has acatchment area of its own which is regualrly feeded by he monsoons. So apart from that TN demands another 192 tmcft regularly and if its catchment area does not have enough, fill it up with KAR's share, disregarding KAR's farmer's suicides. illogical and absurd.
if we pay for ur electricity...u pay for our water!!
r u sharing the revenues that you are getting from the madras port or for that matter tirupati devasthana. ur absurd logic of 'just because a river is born in the state, it does not give any rights to the state', is kind of skewed, considering tirupati devasthana.
RE:RE:RE:READ THIS FIRST..............
by aajeya r on Feb 06, 2007 01:16 PM Permalink
It is not your well beside Ur house to tell "it is everybody's water!"...will you share U for everybody
