Discussion Board

Handing over the Red Fort to the Dalmias bothers me


Total 49 messages Pages | 1 | 2 | 3   Older >
piri
One of the accusations that the RSS
by piri on May 09, 2018 01:32 AM  | Hide replies

lays at the door of the muxlim invaders of the Indian sub-continent during the middle ages is that they raxped innumerable hyndu women !

The RSS also propagates with equal verve that no one ever entered the Indian sub-continent through the north western corridor at any time in human history before the muxlims did in the 10th century C.E !

The RSS also has been taking great pains to emphasise that all those who lived in the Indian sub-continent (it is silent about the Mongolian features people of the north east) before the muxlim invasions had the same DNA !

The RSS has made the BJP govt appoint spin doctors such as Michel Danino as members of the ICHR to propagate these hypotheses and even make them party of school history text books !

Putting these three convictions of the RSS together, the inescapable conclusion is that the minority of North Indians who have extremely fair skin and acquiline central Asian features such as thin red lips, thin prominent nose, etc (who reside primarily in the states of Kashmir, Haryana, H.P and Punjab) are descendants of hyndu women who were raxped repeatedly by muxlim invaders during the middle ages !

To add punch to their convictions, the RSS also ought to propagate this inescapable corollary !

    Forward  |  Report abuse
samcarto
Re: One of the accusations that the RSS
by samcarto on May 09, 2018 09:53 AM
Do you have anything other than conspiracy theories? Stop mouthing rubbish and think about

Failure of communism in all the 53 countries where it took root.

Just west bengal's statistics

GDP: In 1980-81, WB accounted for 7.2% of the country’s GDP. 10 years later, it dropped to 6.1%. The per capita income which was 1.02 times the all India average in 1980–81 went down to 0.96 times in 2000-2001.

Labour militancy endorsed by the State: The value of industrial output as a share of the total industrial output in India declined from 9.8% in 1980-81 to 5% in 1997. The share of manufacturing in the state economy declined from 21% in 1980-81 to 13% in 2000-01. (source: A paper by Ajitava Raychaudhuri and Gautam Kumar Basu of Jadavpur University, Kolkata)

Bank deposits: Bank deposits in the state accounted for 11.4% of pan-India deposits and this fell to 7.3% by March 2000. That’s a proxy for the relative decline in wealth.(source: RBI statistics)

Social improvement: West Bengal’s ranked among the states was eighth in 1981 and the same in 2001. Over the same period, just to compare,Tamil Nadu, improved its rank from seventh to third. (source: Planning Commission’s Human Development Report (HDR), 2001) Ideology has done precious little for West Bengal’s masses.


   Forward   |   Report abuse
samcarto
Re: One of the accusations that the RSS
by samcarto on May 09, 2018 09:55 AM
Why all communist leaders who headed the revolution are mass murderers? Stalin with the biggest tally of killing more Russians than Hitler himself and Fidel Castro being the good boy who, edged by his buddy Che Guevara, killed only 17000 people in cuba.

Why is that there are NO WOMEN communist heads of state? Why was the first woman politburo member (Brinda karat) was inducted only in 2005 in your party almost 80 years after the communist party was born in India? Are women so incapable?? Can you name one international woman communist leader without checking google?

Why is that you guys are so unnerved by so called fascists like RSS when Fascism was born out of Communism? In his own words Mussolini said Fascism is nothing but communism with the right to private enterprise.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Sunil Vaidya
hi
by Sunil Vaidya on May 08, 2018 08:06 PM

modi is selling country...dalmia will earn good profits...people will have to pay more...

dalmiya being bjp rss member and one who is named as an accused in babri demolition case has full govt protection..so no problem...favoritism at its best...dalmiya purchases red fort...ambani purchases rafale...everyone happy with the corruption...india and indians losers...

    Forward  |  Report abuse
aman
Dalmiyas and Amabanis
by aman on May 08, 2018 03:37 PM

The modern day so called moghuls and some brokers working for their welfare. Theres a no much difference then and now and religion is just a symbolic tool to fool and subjugate the poor public.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
DrMadhuri Patil
Red fort
by DrMadhuri Patil on May 08, 2018 03:03 PM  | Hide replies

Okay then hand over it to Kanhaiyya,Sehla,Daniel Raja

    Forward  |  Report abuse
ishrat quadri
Re: Red fort
by ishrat quadri on May 08, 2018 04:25 PM
You fool.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Shivamogga
some comments
by Shivamogga on May 08, 2018 01:04 PM  | Hide replies

Have tried to comment on some key claims / comments by Punwani:
“…the exquisite Moti Masjid reflecting Aurangzeb's sobriety…”
Comments: Aurangazeb ….and sobriety?! LoL
“…it is simply redolent history”
Comments: that which stood as epitome of Indian subjugation to invading hordes is redolent …meaning effusive / sweet emotions for the author (sic)
“…It silently endorses physical attacks by its supporters on those who do not stand up for the national anthem in cinema halls…”
Comments: Author is ever eager to cry hoarse that the entire canvas (Modi Govt) is black for the few black spots occurring here and there
“…a monument symbolising our sovereignty”
Comments: I never thought subjugation and sovereignty are synonyms till I read this article!
“…no member of the party that makes up this government took part in the freedom struggle…”
Comments: BJP was formed in 1980. During freedom struggle, Congress was a Platform or National Movement than a typical election oriented party ….you can find leaders of Jan Sangh and RSS participating in freedom movement identifying with the then congress
“…There is no doubt that the Red Fort is a symbol of the Mughals, that fascinating dynasty that ruled us for near 200 years…”
Comments: If “fascination” is the emotion that oozes reminiscing Moghul dynasty, Im pained / sad to comment f

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
Shivamogga
Re: some comments
by Shivamogga on May 08, 2018 01:08 PM
“…Fort is part of the Mughals' magnificent legacy…”
Comments: If subjugation to invading foreign tribes, brutality of unimaginable magnitude and scale, annihilation, destruction and defilement can be celebrated as magnificent legacy ….I am numbed with author’s slavish mentality and drifting far away from a heritage blossomed over millennia
“…But one doubts that BJP members feel a surge of pride when they look at the Lal Qila, the Juma Masjid, the Qutb Minar, Humayun's Tomb, the Lodhi monuments…”
Comments: Does he really expects any Indian, not just BJP to have pride in Juma Masjid, Qutb Minar, the many other Mughal structures which were erected after ruining Hindu temples?! Disgusting
“…Will Shah Jahan be described as a 'videshi hamlaawar (foreign invader)?”
Comments: Any doubts?! Not aware of his cruel deeds on natives or of his barbarian anscestors?! No legacy applicable here?!
“…Finally, according to Sharma, the K'oran and the Bi'ble do not reflect the soul of India as do the Ramayan and the Gita, which should be made part of school syllabi…”
Comments: OMG! Not even the most unscrupulous eva'ngelists and pros'elytizers of either R’OL or R’OP are claiming their books form “SOUL” of India. But author thinks so and wants that to be made part of school syllabus?! Mission'aries and J’s can rest and have Punwanis do the job.


   Forward   |   Report abuse
piri
Re: some comments
by piri on May 09, 2018 01:35 AM

You did not read this article, did you ?

Do read it fully !

The Dalmias will not be accountable for any damage that may be caused to the monument while they handle its responsibility !

The article further says that should the Dalmias cause any damage to the monument in pursuit of their self promotional activities, it cant be ensured by the ASI that they will be made to pay for the repairs/restoration !

And.......why does the country need private profiteers to provide signages, cleanliness, public conveniences, drinking water, illumination in historical monuments, more particularly in historical monuments which are visited by large number of tourists and so have a high income from tourism ??

Why ?

   Forward   |   Report abuse
jitendra kumar
Just for maintainence
by jitendra kumar on May 08, 2018 12:55 PM  | Hide replies


So Funny, just by handing over the maintainence people are feeling so much, then just think what would have been the emotions of ours when our ageold centres of knowledge , places of worships were destroyed mercilessly.

So its better people not to comment on this issue



    Forward  |  Report abuse
Shivamogga
Re: Just for maintainence
by Shivamogga on May 08, 2018 01:35 PM
exactly ....u've hit the nail on the head.

The "Live" temples captured by Govt are stinking and in a pathetic state inspite of their huge revenues ....and the "Tombs" are manicured and cuddled like cloud nine babies

Time for change ....change for fairness and justice has come

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Ajeet  Yadav
Wrong massage
by Ajeet Yadav on May 08, 2018 12:52 PM

Please don't give wrong massage to people by writing such Artical before this who was handling red fort and what they did to preserve its building and what maintenance they did.


    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 49 messages Pages: | 1 | 2 | 3   Older >
Write a message