The suggestion of author author is totally out of sync.He has ignored the Histoerical facts and played to the gallery. If Indian government decides, even with the consent of people in Kashmir valley, to divide the state-it will weaken the Indian argument in international arena. we have always held the view that state of Jammu & Kashmir as it existed on 15th August,1947 is a single entity, hence till the time so called "Azad Kashmir", Gilgit and Baltistan again unite and create the same boundaries as on 15th August,1947 we can not alter any boundary line of J&K.
Re: division of Jammu & Kashmir
by on Jun 25, 2018 04:55 PM
Nothing of the sort is going to happen.What the author written is a suggestion to be thought of seriously. Negative thinking will only destroy the purpose.
Re: division of Jammu & Kashmir
by Suresh on Jun 25, 2018 09:09 PM
Indian govt has all the right to alter its states in any form as required. In the current form we are not able to alter the land under POK. But that will be a perinial problem until our side of the Kash is resolved. We will do that and the people on the POK side will raise against Pak and join india.
The suggestion of author author is totally out of sync.He has ignored the Histoerical facts and played to the gallery. If Indian government decides, even with the consent of people in Kashmir valley, to divide the state-it will weaken the Indian argument in international arena. we have always held the view that state of Jammu & Kashmir as it existed on 15th August,1947 is a single entity, hence till the time so called "Azad Kashmir", Gilgit and Baltistan again unite and create the same boundaries as on 15th August,1947 we can not alter any boundary line of J&K.
Q. Was Ind economy 20% of World economy in 1700? A. Primitive economies of 1700 depended on populatn; then Ind had 20% & China 25% of world’s populatn, so their economies were 20% and 25%. All people in the world were poor--west, east, Chinese & Indians--with poverty evenly distributed. After 1700, west got industrialized and advanced fast. Q. Were 90% Indians literate in 1700 and had high per capita income? A. That is a flat lie. In fact 93% Indians were illiterate. Only Brahmin men, Vyshya men and some wealthy Kshatriya men were literate, and total literacy was below 7% in 1500 BC or 1800 AD. In 1740, Indians were much poorer than in 1940. Only with British rule literacy started rising. Q. Why 90% Indians think ancient Ind scriptures (of 4000 BC) have superior content vis-a-vis modern western sci & tech? A. Ind culture develops idiotic mind dominated by perpetual delusion. Indian scriptures are 10% facts and 90% figments of imagination. From lit angle, Ramayan, Mahabharat, etc are masterpieces. No doubt, HHinduism is highly secular & avg HHindus are not wicked like avg Mxlims. Q. Was there no caste-discrimination before in India? Was Mxslim ruler good? A. Caste system was at its ugly peak betwn 2000 BC & 1800 AD which started weakening after British entered. British liberated Indians by crushing Mxlim domination and ended their atrocities. MXLIM RULE THAT KILLED 600 MIL HINDUS (800-1800AD) WAS BIG HORRO
This is an excellent proposition given by colonel Anil A Athale and it is the wish of every Indian. The powers that matter should take a note of this Suggestion and implement it urgently. More over creation of smaller states in J&K and elsewhere also makes administration easy and they progress well. It will give boost to employment generation.
A big salute to the auther Col. Athale. Absolutely indepth & meticulous analysis from an ex-serviceman. My personal views, aparently post colonial rulers on either sides failed badly in resolving the problen, rather all of them made use of it at time for their political mileage. Instead an unhealthy enimity has been created between common people of both sides by power crazy & mediodrete so called leaders to proove vague nationalism. It is again common people and their sons & daughters on the frontlines are suffering and getting killed, while the leaders are partying together with favourite cousines on trips for so called attempts for resolution. Sincerely hope, this valueable suggestion alongwith cry of displaced Hindu Kashmiris will be heard by the decision makers in the right spirit to keep our citizen in the region safe and allow them to lead a peaceful life. Now this is the time for Indians to comeout boldly on international arena to rectify the blunder that was commited by the so called Leader after power transfer by colonial ruler.
Kashmir ruled by the Dogra dynasty was trifurcated into POK(Azad Kashmir), Indian Kashmir and Aksaichin seized by China in 1962 (and Hunza conceded by Pakistan to China). When the population of Jammu and Ladakh felt the heat of militancy they asked for the trifurcation of the state. The request was denied partly because it was seen as an admission of failure of secularism and also as a possible assertion by Pakistan to claim the Muslim majority valley. If the Modi government can shed the past baggage and trifurcate the state, it will be a first step towards ruling the separate areas as per the needs of each. It should be noted that the different stands taken by PDP and BJP on these separate areas was the cause of the collapse of the government.
A big salute to the auther Col. Athale. Absolutely indepth & meticulous analysis from an ex-serviceman. My personal views, aparently post colonial rulers on either sides failed badly in resolving the problen, rather all of them made use of it at time for their political mileage. Instead an unhealthy enimity has been created between common people of both sides by power crazy & mediodrete so called leaders to proove vague nationalism. It is again common people and their sons & daughters on the frontlines are suffering and getting killed, while the leaders are partying together with favourite cousines on trips for so called attempts for resolution. Sincerely hope, this valueable suggestion alongwith cry of displaced Hindu Kashmiris will be heard by the decision makers in the right spirit to keep our citizen in the region safe and allow them to lead a peaceful life. Now this is the time for Indians to comeout boldly on international arena to rectify the blunder that was commited by the so called Leader after power transfer by colonial ruler.
