Re: Re: Re: almost every year, thousands keeled in mecca in stone
by Anand on Nov 09, 2011 04:11 PM
If I am not wrong around 20 lakh people from around the world gather there every year; Secondly there is no need to compare the amount of deaths or stampede; only thing I want to say that our govt. should take measures which are visible and helpful for avoiding such incident in coming years.
Re: almost every year, thousands keeled in mecca in stone throw s
by lycoming on Nov 09, 2011 02:30 PM
Dear ,people also get keeled during hazz, but the number is not so high as you claimed !! Without comparing statistically to muslims we s ourselves should ibe disciplined at crowded places so as to not start stampede!!!Which we are lacking Stampedes can happen even in the western countries if the crowds are unruly!!
Re: Re: almost every year, thousands keeled in mecca in stone thr
by Monica on Nov 09, 2011 02:38 PM
check in guggle itself, in single year, there were lmost 1500 casualties! so , dont talk high or big mouth, have some knowledge before commenting on hyndu stampede! here, the satitics given for 10 years, take the record of mecca of 10 years, at least there were 3000 keeled in stampede only in single area, compared to several places in india! so, statistically, stampede in entire india taken less life than in one incident of mecca! so, i also feel, msulims shud better shutUP! here, he has written it to counter msulims criticism in this board who were accusing hyndu ritual or festivals, though ur points raised is correct,
Re: Re: Re: almost every year, thousands keeled in mecca in stone
by Anand on Nov 09, 2011 04:13 PM
That might have happened but what is the measure that was taken by govt. after that? Compare that with what our govt. has taken measure;
This is not a religious point making issue that we are trying to gain over each other; This is an administrative issue which we should bring to notice of our administrators.
Re: Re: Re: almost every year, thousands keeled in mecca in stone
by sooraj sv on Nov 09, 2011 05:26 PM
A life lost is lost, Please dont attach any religion tag to it
Re: Who's Responsible?
by lycoming on Nov 09, 2011 12:20 PM
Poor people are lured by indian government bt perforn pilgrimage which they cannot afford by giving subsidy ,the people in turn get keelled during frenzy of stooonethroiwing by stampded!
Re: A clear case of misuse of religion
by lycoming on Nov 09, 2011 12:17 PM
Who is taking advantage by making people risk their lives during stone throwing!!! I think indian government should be held responsible for giving subsidy !!
Re: Re: Language
by Arun on Nov 09, 2011 11:18 AM
Read all the comments in the forum and come back to talk to me if you are alive... Am already a ghost... :) :)
