There is a glaring contradiction in Geelani's career..he was an elected member of state legislative assembly for 17 years...he participated in 4 elections that were rigged...if he has always been pro pakistan what was he doing in the J&K Legislative assembly for 17 years??? One of the qualities people look for in a leader is his ability to protect them and secure there future...u are right Geelani has always reacted to situation which is why he couldn't get the popular support in Kashmir...the other reason of course is his hardline interpretation of Islam...his personal nature is almost irrelevent...
I laugh at this doc. Geelani Sahab may be extremely good person no doubt. But what he is doing is extremely diabolic. I agree on the inefficiency of Indian state though. Please remember aurangzeb was also very upright person and led a spartan life. Its only when it came to shedding the blood of infidels he got generous. So This is a Boolshti that is being spread by Dr Kaul. Has he talked with him about the separatist ideology?? Untill and unless he comments on that its all gas and smoke. Jinnah was also a secular used by islamist to create a separate country. Why it happens again and again that a simple and straightforward and a kind herated person creates a new country out of india time and again. I guess Mr Sameer would do well to explain that. Please stop fooling yourself. You are doing a back stabbing to those 300000 pandits who were coerced into leaving the valley and becoming a refugee in their own country. Shame on You Mr Kaul.
Re: Re: Re: Ha Ha Ha
by Rahul Sr on Oct 11, 2010 11:19 PM
Good points! A rose tinted article portraying a seasoned anti-national as a god like figure and using the attention grabbing title of "Kashmiri Pandit" to hog the headlines. I appreciate you keen observation about the marxist angle.
Dr Kaul has truly given a totally different picture of GILANI - as opposed to media creation.The interview once again proves that Indian Govt., is non-sensitive & senseless in its approach to peoples problem, especially to kashmiris feelings.It is unfortunate that totally corrupt politician are at the hem,deciding fate of our country, We should blame the people for electing such vagabonds.
Re: Re: Gilani
by Krishnan on Oct 11, 2010 10:43 PM
Yes. Pakistan claimed insolvency on World Bank loan which India is repaying promptly. In the name of Muslim nation it is begging to all Arab countries and cheating US like a prodigal son. Sven times smaller than India in size but cannot grow like Korea or Malasia. Half of your statement is true ISI is giving money to Indian Muslims though Chidambaram claims no local sleepr cells in terrorism. May be he and some congremen are the Hindus in ISI's payroll
Called C M Patel who kept him alive just so that he could accomplish his sordid mission of partioning the country and creating that hell hole on earth called pakistan.
Yes, in 1944 itself Jinnah was a physical wreck, with holes the size of Golf Balls in his lungs. His Doctor diagonized cancer in addition to the TB he already had and told him that he had 1 year to live.
But prescribed a strict regimen of Ayurvedic medicines and exercise which kept the most malevolent person in Indian history alive for 4 more years so that he could partition the country.
The Doctor M C Patel did another great dis-service to the Nation by not mentioning this important fact to the Congress leadership which could have easily played very hard to bargain with on the question of a seperate Sulla state had they known that Jinnah was on his last leg. They could have even delayed independence by a few years so that we could have had a UNITED INDIA !
However, the treacherous M C Patel gave regular interviews stating that Jinnah was in excellent health and deceived everyone.
When will we INDIANS stop being trecherous to our own cause citing silly moral reasons.
The FIRST and foremost duty of EVERY UPRIGHT INDIAN MAN is to be FANATICALLY and OBSESSIVELY LOYAL to the INDIAN STATE and ITS PEOPLE. Nothing less will suffice !
Re: How many readers here know that Jinnah had a Hindu Doctor
by m mani on Oct 11, 2010 10:09 PM
NO, you are wrong, THE FIRST & FOREMOST DUTY OF EVERY INDIAN IS TO BE BRUTALLY HONEST ON EVERYTHING HE DOES OR INVOLVED IN OR HAS KNOWLEDGE ABOUT IT.
Re: Re: How many readers here know that Jinnah had a Hindu Doctor
by Vishnu Sharma on Oct 11, 2010 11:00 PM
You are a Marxist thug like the personal Doctor of Geelani.
Traitors like you will destroy an entire nation to satisfy your false moral compunctions.
Scum like you will be extinct in the NEW INDIA that is emerging with second that passes.
If I was Geelani's Dr I would have terminated his life using one method or the other.
Re: Re: Third rate article
by Vishnu Sharma on Oct 11, 2010 11:02 PM
Because the JNU Graduated Marxist scum Krishnakumar Padmanabhan thinks it is important to sing praises of a person who wants to break our nation using the voice of his Doctor.
i like the communal spin on the story. It's not just the politicians who thrive on sensationalizing/spinning everything through the prism of communal lense
