this is medical problem. the one associates with the terrorists/thiefs/naxala generally gets sympathetic to their cause and sees gud in their arguments. Dr Kaul also is a victim of that disease. A sense of false security also can be seen creeping into his analysis.
He should immediately stop his business and return to Mumbai..and treate those injured by Kasab.
Re: captive syndrome.
by cool dude on Oct 12, 2010 07:36 AM
this is called patriotism .. we not read interview but we comment coz its about separatist.. his view about his personalty not about his stand against india.. geelani if thinks kashmir finding problem in india.. why not we give kashmir to fartystan and let them suffer.. but straight way tell on that bloody oldy that leh laddakh,jammu and siachin is integral part of india and will remain .. so u go with kashmir and have junglee honemoon with fartystan
Re: Re: Re: captive syndrome.
by cool dude on Oct 12, 2010 07:53 AM
come on its not gonna happen to us.. instead we lost somany lives and monetory loss for such piece.. we not belive in heaven on earth and all.. anyway we will get all those after some years ..as such fartystan existance having doubt..
Re: captive syndrome.
by Sandeep on Oct 12, 2010 08:29 AM
So Mr. Gilani now needs an image makeover. What better way than to hire a hindu and personal "Kashmiri Pandit" doctor to do the laundry. Does Gilani really expect now an increase in his personal status, and that people will start looking up at him ?
After reading so many of these opinions I am glad there is hardly any support to this doctor who needs a doctor. Even if media is trying to float some boats here, the people are not getting swayed. I have seen it happen several times because nowadays war is fought not just on streets, but in people's mind - "PSYWAR" What is this doctor's enlightened argument? He respects gilani because he is stubborn ? Instead of seeing reason and just cause, he is taking advantage of govt's generous appeasing policies. Would he be as stubborn if he had been in China ?
So many evil minded people in the past had been stubborn and did not yield to reason and appeasement. That does not make them respectable. Hitler was also obstinate and stubborn and stuck to his stance causing mindless killing of innocents. No amount of appeasement could alter his course.
Another argument giving is about spartan living. I have seen some other reader also point out - Aurangzeb was also living life without any luxuries, but that does not make is fanaticism justifiable.
Mr. Gilani openly advocates that muslims cannot live as minority. So he is free to go to pakistan and become a majority an
Re: Re: captive syndrome.
by Sandeep on Oct 12, 2010 08:30 AM
and try to cultivate his kashmiri identity there. Lets see how long he survives.
What are the kashmiris asking the freedom from ? They have political freedom to choose there leaders, religious freedom, financial freedom. Their demand for a separate state on basis of their religious identity is not justified. Those who do not want to stay in India have the freedom to leave the country.
Indians have to get serious when it comes to national integrity. The efforts to break down India have been going on since Independence. During Mrs. Gandhi's time she made concerted effort to increase awareness in people through messages of national integration. In Manmohan's govt. it seems to be fashionable to talk about autonomy. Separatists are living in fool's paradise and spoiling there own future. Unless the population in Kashmir resolutely drives these separatists out they are blocking their own progress.
I think people like Sameer Kaul have a perspective that we must respect. However, we cannot let anti-social elements causing unrest take control of situation and prompt us to take any unwise decision. The extremists have no end to their needs, once you give Kashmir away, they want something else next. You cannot let that to happen. China is aggresively portraying Arunachal Pradesh as its own territory. We need to stand strong and flush out infiltrators. We need to partner with and learn from our Israeli friends and understand what it means to be on offensive. We must start being proactive instead of reactive before its too late.
Abe kashmiri, becuase this duplicious nature only kashmiris are living on streets. ppl like you are responsible for that. I am also very simple and satisfied person of conviction and principles and read vedas everyday but if my priciple is to kill jehadis (not muslim) How would you describe me.
Liberal, tolerant and inclusive ideologies cannot survive the onslaught of Jehadism. Indian secularism has itself been dealt a body-blow by our own Chaddiwalas and homegrown Jehadis. The damage that has been done will take decades to repair, if ever.
Kashmir stands no chance if India moves away from it. Hardline Islamists will move in overnight - no more article 370 protecting Kashmiris from settlement of Pashtuns, Pak. Punjabis, etc. It'll become just another Afghanistan.
Re: Kashmir is on it's way to Talibanism
by deetee on Oct 12, 2010 04:46 AM
whenthehomegrownandexternaljehadis comefor youonly chaddiwalaswillprotect you!! otherwiseyouwill eitherloseyourlifeorforeskin
Re: Re: Kashmir is on it's way to Talibanism
by Bharatiar on Oct 12, 2010 10:26 AM
If we must depend on private militia to protect ourselves, then I'd say that India is ineffective as a state. What's the point of a country that cannot protect it's citizens from aggression? And what's to say that the Chaddis themselves will not turn against me?
What Hindus should do is not to tear apart the foundations of India, but to strengthen them. And THEN we'll have the moral right to demand sternly from everyone else that they do the same too.
By attacking the moral foundations of our country, the Chaddis are weakening it.
Kashmiri pandits are an inseparable part of Kashmir. We want to live together and have always been urging for their return. We will continue to do so. Even Geelani Shib supports theam to return Kashmir.Indian can never give them any permanent security.Kashmiri pandits will safe only in kashmir.Everyone knows in last 20 years Indian did anything for them.As everyone knows lot kashmiri pundits return their home did they face any problem they enjoy safe life in kashmir.Kashmir is not a religious problem, it is a political dispute and unless the people are given their right our just struggle will continue.
Re: Geelani Shib is fighting for kashmiri people.
by Bharatiar on Oct 12, 2010 01:39 AM
Kashmir struggle *is* religious in nature, at least as per Geelani.
From Geelani's interview:
"Ever since my release from prison on August 7, 2004, I have been spreading my message across Kashmir. I have a three-point target. First is to impose an Islamic nizam (jurisprudence) in Kashmir. Islam should govern our lives, be it in our political thought, socio-economic plans, culture or the ongoing movement.
The creed of socialism and secularism should not touch our lives and we must be totally governed by the Koran and the Sunnat (precedents from Prophet Mohammad's life).
Secondly, I have been propagating that we must fight against anti-Islamic forces. These forces come in our way under the garb of nationalists, secularists, racists, linguistic chauvinists, and so on.
Thirdly, I have been telling the youth to work for the right to self-determination which is granted to them by the United Nations. I have been drawing huge support from the youth for this as a result of which you see lakhs of people on the roads today."
It'll not be long before US missiles will rain on Kashmir if the likes of Geelani comes to power.
A doctor has to treat all,enemy or friend.oath of hippocratas.Dr.koul is a human being in true sense.pride of kashmir.geelani should review his rigid political stand.
