Re: Expect more
by atul on Mar 30, 2010 05:17 PM
are u a bloo*dy britisher? y do u always talk like idio*ts northies/southies u r what? anties? crime is crime where ever it happens its not that all people are the same every where u cannot blame the whole community for a crime commited by some one from there comm grow up man dont talk like kids
The rule was not made without proper reasons by our forefathers. They knew that genetic disorders would be more prevalent when they marry their siblings. Parsis are the biggest example and it is feared that they would be extinct soon!
Now, they also said that as long as you are able to trace up to seven generations, you should AVOID marrying withing the same gotra, because, by this time, the dilution of the genes is so much that it is as good as not marrying withing the gotra at all. if one is not able to trace up to 7 generations, they may marry but with the accepted risk, if any, of congenital diseases in the offspring. But nowhere they ordered killing of the couple if they went against the convention.
In that context, this case will fit well within the rarest of the rare cases and the judiciary has awarded correct punishment, since no one can take law to his/her hands.
Re: 5 get death in Karnal honour killing case
by Chanakya on Mar 30, 2010 05:07 PM
sir, but unfortunately, in India the verdict does not end with one court...there are so many other options and upper courts available for the culprits to escape punishment...
Re: 5 get death in Karnal honour killing case
by Indian Dreamer on Mar 30, 2010 05:18 PM
All that theories about genetic disorders and the genes "diluting" to a point of extinction are all humbug! If a girl A has a hereditary genetic disorder, how will its effect on the next generation change by her marrying a boy B from a different "Gotra"? In any case, the genes may get transferred to her offspring, whether she marries within the "Gotra" or outside! Could any of you "doctors" out there please elaborate? And for your kind information, the Parsi community is facing the threat of extinction not due to any genetic reasons!
Re: 5 get death in Karnal honour killing case
by Ninja Kirgi on Mar 30, 2010 05:11 PM
Except in Haryana, Rajasthan and Western UP, no where else people follow the rule that marriage shouldn't happen in same gotra.
What will happen to castes where a single gotra is predominant?
Re: Re: 5 get death in Karnal honour killing case
by Balan Iyer on Mar 30, 2010 05:23 PM
You are wrong,marriage withinthe same Gotra is not allowed from Kerala to Kashmir
Re: Re: Re: 5 get death in Karnal honour killing case
by Ninja Kirgi on Mar 30, 2010 06:30 PM
Ignorance is bliss. Just go to MP and Chattisgarh. There are many castes where 95% of people belong to single gotra and nobody cares if both the bride and groom belong to same gotra. Also there many they won't accept that you are from same caste if you can't prove a family relation with them.
INFACT CAPITAL PUNISHMENT MUST BE INCREASED. IN MURDER CASE THERE IS ONLY 14 YEARS IS GIVEN THAT IS VERY LITTLE CONSIDERED TO LIFE EXPECTANCY OF A PERSON. ALSO SEVERAL OTHER CASES THE PUNISHMENT GIVEN IS VERY LESS SO PEOPLE DON'T MIND DOING THE CRIME AGAIN AND AGAIN.
Re: Re: CAPITAL PUNISHMENT
by Roy on Mar 30, 2010 05:07 PM
And Goverment have spend for their life? They must send to some uninhabited islands of Lakshadweep or Andamans with out any luxury,and allowed live their lonely life away from the civilized community.
Those who violate indian law and take lives of others in such cases must be dealt in strongest manner. There must be a separate law to also impose heavy financial penalty on entire khap etc. Penalty must be in crores so as those who do such things must cough up huge amounts and learn a lesson. Mere punishing five or ten persons is not going to solve the problem.
Re: Jaat panchayats
by Amit Dhull on Mar 30, 2010 05:05 PM
Jaats are one of the martials of India. You absolutely don't know about Jaats. They are most sensible.
Re: Jaat panchayats
by Sanjeev Sharma on Mar 30, 2010 05:02 PM
My dear, do not generalise People from Haryana. There are other castes also who are not like the jats.and are better people to deal with
see mera bharat... we start haters abt moslms..then with govt.. then wth regional..then with own subcaste.. then with zone wise.. what is hinduism then...
Re: this is india
by The Patriot on Mar 30, 2010 04:54 PM
india is not heaven to have everything perfect...but remember, india is the land of hindus...whether we kill each or kiss each other....thats among us....just because we fight doesnt mean we should let outsiders come here and fight as well!!!! and equate outsiders to ourselves saying bcos we do it, even they have the right to do it!!!!
Re: Re: this is india
by cool dude on Mar 30, 2010 04:58 PM
that what i m saying dear but we not united thats why outsiders comes and destroy peace here.. and india is not hindu land but anyway i never follow relgion and religional beliefs so it doesnt matter.. i only want to see we should b brave hearted and peace .. but we in ourself or not well knitted thats why anyone can torn
