Re: Don't get angry
by mahesh pillai on Apr 21, 2010 06:38 PM
i remember the day force one was inaugurated many commandos were sick and didn't turn up for the parade section. this doesn't happen with NSG so NSG is better
Almost every one(common people) who drives car in US has a GPS, but how will the GPS help them reach early in case of a traffic jam. These people just talk rubbish. NSG only saved them, what a joke. These commandos will still be behind NSG. NSG Commondos are actually men from Army. We already know how army is better than state police, state police have their bellies protruding. Tell police force to first become fit, then do comparision from NSG.
Re: What is he speaking
by hiral joshi on Apr 21, 2010 06:44 PM
NSG and MARCOS are the still best what India has got. But its good to have commandos at local police level.
you should have avaoided this type of comments.it is unfair to compare like this.you keep quite and these type of comparisions will divide the people.please donot compare like this in coming days. we can never ever forget the time NSG spent during 26/11 and leave or skip such type of questions. leave alone better than them. A person of your stature should still have avoided such comments and you would have said that every one is specialised in their respective field.
Re: Do not compare like this and this is ridicules and shame.
by mahesh pillai on Apr 21, 2010 06:37 PM
i remember the day force one was inaugurated many commandos were sick and didn't turn up for the parade section. this doesn't happen with NSG so NSG is better
Re: Do not compare like this and this is ridicules and shame.
by hiral joshi on Apr 21, 2010 06:38 PM
You are absolutely right. No need of comparisons. The services of NSG commandos are well tested and such statements may demoralise their spirits.
yeah right! What way are they better? Just in talking? Maha ATS chief's jacket was like the jacket used to protect from ordinary rain and not rain of bullets. Even the weapon they had was rusted old weapons. When Maharashtra police have not held a modern weapon for ages much less get trained, how can they be better than NSG.
Or Is CP giving a wrong hint to terrorists that NSG is worse than lathi weilding Maha police?
This is an unwarranted comment comparing apple and orange.
Probably we can give the benefit that this is more a subjective comment and said out of pride. Hopefully the pride keeps us build a formidable internal security.
Re: Unwarranted Comment
by mahesh pillai on Apr 21, 2010 06:37 PM
i remember the day force one was inaugurated many commandos were sick and didn't turn up for the paraded section this doesn't happen with NSG so NSG is better
seems GPS is now a days Joke of technology.. when its needed they not used it.. they float tenders and earn from them not utilize services.. and he is talking better than nsg.. just ask him to make those 1000 commondos security guard of all big politicians,biz mans and sensative place and free those poor NSG commondos from there and they will happyly serv for nation...
we know what is difference between police and army
Very shamful statement by a responsible officer.every security person is better than other,even home-guards,watchmen,may be better than scotland yard police or mosad.DO NOT DIFFERENTIATE ANY SECURITY PERSON WITH OTHER.BE RESPONSIBLE FIRST.
What security,dont bring water,eats,cellphones,dont do this that is it security.people come to enjoy relax and see some cricket.This is worse than USairports security,
you should have avaoided this comment... we can never ever forget the NSG in our entire life for what they have done post 26/11 and there can never be a match for them, leave alone better than them. I wish our elite force of Mumbai all the best, will power and courage and success.. A person of your stature should still have avoided such comments or compliments.
Re: Dear Mr. Sivanandan
by Abc Def on Apr 21, 2010 06:37 PM
NSG operation during 26-11 was such a waste. Pathetic NSG could not arrive at the scene for 12 hours. They waited for a special plane. Couldnt they take any airline. They couldnt rescue a single person from Chabbad house or the Taj, All rescue was done by the ill equipped mumbai police in the previous night.
Re: Re: Dear Mr. Sivanandan
by thinkingaloud on Apr 21, 2010 06:43 PM
Ask these questions to the then police commissioner of Mumbai. He should be the one who answers.
Re: Re: Dear Mr. Sivanandan
by hiral joshi on Apr 21, 2010 06:41 PM
What you wanted them to do? Run from Haryana to Mumbai? NSG were not for rescue, they were to flush terrorists out with minimal damage to innocent citizens, and that is what they did. Learn full ABCD before commenting!!
Re: Dear Mr. Sivanandan
by Samir Moosa on Apr 21, 2010 06:34 PM
Bombay Police chased, shot and captured a live terrorist. What did NSG do?? Wait behind barracks for them to make a mistake and fired from 100 mtrs. The only time they ventured inside the Taj, they all got killed. East or West Bombay (its people & police both) are BEST.
Re: Re: Dear Mr. Sivanandan
by thinkingaloud on Apr 21, 2010 06:45 PM
Wait its no more Bombay Police, who are you? Its known as Mumbai. And where were these so called Police, they should have taken charge and killed the terrorists. Where were they hiding. One did a good job accepted. Others were running here and there, thats all that they did.
Re: Re: Re: Dear Mr. Sivanandan
by Samir Moosa on Apr 21, 2010 06:50 PM
Now debate about Mumbai/Bombay. Gr8. They chased them from VT (now called CST), Cama Hospital & Eros. If it were not for these ill-equipped guys, many more might have had unfortunate faith. They cornered them in the Oberoi Hotel, Taj Hotel & Chabad House, after which the NSG took over.
Re: Re: Dear Mr. Sivanandan
by hiral joshi on Apr 21, 2010 06:42 PM
NSG killed rest 9. Mumbai police kept that b##std alive and we are paying for his well being now.
Re: Re: Re: Dear Mr. Sivanandan
by Samir Moosa on Apr 21, 2010 06:47 PM
He is a real lottery. He is the reason Pakistan had to admit after 60 years that there are elements within its state which are responsible for attacks within India. If he was also killed, we could never have proven that.
Re: Re: Provocation
by ganesh subramanian on Apr 21, 2010 06:49 PM
pappu,u r irrelevant.comparison of army and police should not be done.nothing to do with marathi region.
