Kolkata: Research scholar Purabi Roy on Wed claimed that thousands of men belonging to Indian National Army (INA) were massacred at a camp in 1946. She made this revelation while addressing a discussion on implications of Justice Manoj Mukherjee commission report.“When Nehru visited Malaya to meet INA men captured by the British forces, three ships had already left for Chittagong, Madras & Calcutta carrying the soldiers. About 29,000 INA men were taken to a camp in Nilgunge and massacred when negotiations for the INA property were on,” Roy said. INA property was worth $72,000 & that was divided among India, Pakistan and Britain,” she pointed out. Roy also claimed that INA owned gold mines, diamond mines &rubber plantations. Commenting on the Centre’ rejection of Justice Mukherjee commission report, Roy said successive Congress governments have not allowed the facts regarding Subhas Chandra Bose to come out. “Whenever they are in power, inquiries into Netaji’ life and death are aborted. For 12 years, I have been struggling with this subject. Hopefully, one day we will be able to answer the questions raised by Justice Mukherjee about what happened to Netaji if he did not die in the air crash,” she added. Former Union human resources development minister Murli Manohar Joshi said the Centre had not extended full cooperation to the Justice Mukherjee commission. “Unless the Centre takes up the matter with the Russian government, the archi
Re: TRUTH ABOUT NEHRU, GANDHI N NEETAJI
by dp on Nov 30, 2009 05:58 PM
The concept of partition is most widely misinterpreted. The idea of extremism and a seperate partition started by the foundation of Aligarh University which itself was founded on basis of competiton with Hnds of those times who were learned and close to the Britishers! Hnds were more learned and not militant!
Vicky Nanjappa! it is not easy to fool Indians of this age coz we are more into reading than u fundamentalist paid writers.
RSS wasnt against Mslms! Neither is it now! If it was than the Shankaracharya wouldnt recite "La Ila InAllah" to a crowd of 50000 Mslms.
So CONGRESS writers, we Indians plead u to stop DIVIDING INDIANS!!!!! STOP!!!!!! Vicky Nanjapaa is himself a Xtian! See the idea behind all attacks on India in terrorism and media are from Xtians and the major basis is to create a fight between H and M.
Stop it! for GOD is watching! Dont divide Hnds and Mslms.
Bose's army had all communties involved and thus he couldnt have been anti mslm as your article suggests!
We can see now why Congress is converting so many Indians to Xtianity! Gr8 politics!
Shame on south indians for leaving their original faith! neither hell nor heaven for you.
H e was a true hero by all means...but the congis reduced his importance in Indian history thru the ages... they filled school text books with Chacha Nehru, Gandhi and nowadays Feroz Ghans clan( donno why they r called Gandhis) !!
Its a pity that we are so spineless when it comes to dealing with real culprits ! Our media is even worst than our politicians...only good for snacking samosa and chai at whatever press meets !
Gandhi and his chamcha nehru took the Hindus for granted...left us high and dry without a country for our selves...later congis became anti hindu culture in order to please the vote banks... Ultimately... Hinduism is the looser in its own land !!
Kolkata: Research scholar Purabi Roy on Wed claimed that thousands of men belonging to Indian National Army (INA) were massacred at a camp in 1946. She made this revelation while addressing a discussion on implications of Justice Manoj Mukherjee commission report.“When Nehru visited Malaya to meet INA men captured by the British forces, three ships had already left for Chittagong, Madras & Calcutta carrying the soldiers. About 29,000 INA men were taken to a camp in Nilgunge and massacred when negotiations for the INA property were on,” Roy said. INA property was worth $72,000 & that was divided among India, Pakistan and Britain,” she pointed out. Roy also claimed that INA owned gold mines, diamond mines &rubber plantations. Commenting on the Centre’ rejection of Justice Mukherjee commission report, Roy said successive Congress governments have not allowed the facts regarding Subhas Chandra Bose to come out. “Whenever they are in power, inquiries into Netaji’ life and death are aborted. For 12 years, I have been struggling with this subject. Hopefully, one day we will be able to answer the questions raised by Justice Mukherjee about what happened to Netaji if he did not die in the air crash,” she added. Former Union human resources development minister Murli Manohar Joshi said the Centre had not extended full cooperation to the Justice Mukherjee commission. “Unless the Centre takes up the matter with the Russian government, the archives there will not open their doors
Re: TRUTH ABOUT NEHRU, GANDHI N NEETAJI
by jaykumar j on Nov 30, 2009 05:44 PM
Manney, All are eager to know about Bose the hero. So we will wait for the day to come when fact will come out.
If we are glorifying S C Bose then we don't have the moral right to brand the people who took the path of voilence in kashmir , Assam , Manipur and the LTTE fighters etc are terrorist.Even we can't criticize Osama also.Because all these people are fighting for some cause.May be according to our perception it is wrong.Bose's intention was correct but he opted the wrong path.He alligned with Nazi Hitlor arguably the most hated personality in the history of mankind.
Re: Re: Hitlor
by patriot on Nov 30, 2009 05:53 PM
So you ran away from india to netherlands to 'lead a better life'. You cant even live among your indians and you want to espouse indian nationalism. I am ashamed that you hold the same passport that i do. Please become dutch.
Re: Re: Re: Hitlor
by UDDALOK BASU on Nov 30, 2009 08:32 PM
I am really surprised to see your feelings about an Indian abroad. First of all I have come here for a few days and that no to lead a good life. To get more work for India. If you are too obsessed or passionate to stay in NL or any other western country then please go ahead, in that case I sincerely believe that the Ministry of External Affairs had done a very wrong thing to grant a passport to non reliable Indian people like you. I don't write comments like you, I do contribute a lot of social work and I don't have any intention to clarify these points to you. Before you make any such comment make your platform strong and then do comment.
Re: Hitlor
by UDDALOK BASU on Nov 30, 2009 07:51 PM
If you really follow the career of Netaji, you will come to know that he is a person with greatest democratic ideas. While he was the Mayor in Calcutta, he allotted special quotas for Muslims and he announced that in Calcutta Municipal Corporation very few employees were Muslim, and if we are heading towards a new country then people from all religions should have equal rights. So associating his name with RSS or Hindu Mahasabha is wrong. If you can travel back, you all will come to know that he founded the Forward Block - a moderate left liberal party which still exists nowadays except without the moral views of Netaji. Netaji dedicated his life for India and he is not like Gandhi who after finding him defeated b a vast majority in Tripuri COngress declared "Pattabhi's defeat is my defeat". Netaji could have stayed as the Congress President but he never wanted to hurt the sentiments of mean minded Gandhi as the whole of India would have suffered a big jolt, resigned and thought of a great plan for the cause of India's freedom. Nehru, who always was busy with Lady mountbatten inspite his wife Mrs. kamala Nehru suffered from TB and died, was all eager to be the PM of India and in order to serve the cause he had gone to the extent of destroying the real facts. Irony is that we still consider these people as Father and Chacha who have categorically harmed India with their so called (un)wise statementship and achieving personal goals(especially Nehru).
Re: Re: Hitlor
by varghese thomas on Dec 02, 2009 02:02 PM
U bengali people are always obssesed with bose and defaming all other leaders.Bose not only alligned with nazi hitlor who alongwith japanese and Musolini was responsible for the massacre of millions of people in Europe , china,and other countries,but he also allowed the poor INA which lacked the military might to be butchered by Allied forces.In the Burma jungles the poor INA fighters perished due to hunger and desease.Instead of leading from the front he tried to escape and perished unlike the LTTE prabhakaran.If u want bose has to be respected from others u should respect other leaders also.Every body has positive and negative points.Even you are giving too much credit to Bose for forming the INA.INA was formed by General Mohan Singh with the help of Japanese by the prisnors of war.
Re: Hitlor
by Nut on Nov 30, 2009 05:40 PM
If you have brains then you would have never told this. This is how Nehru ate up peoples mind. It was a military exercise that was taken up in Germany and Japan to bring freedom to this country, you idiot. Why dont you read the history and then open up your fould mouth?
Re: Hitlor
by jaykumar j on Nov 30, 2009 05:41 PM
Vargese, He didnt alligned with Hitler he went and brought back our India's war of prisoners. What a big contribution he did even no one dared to bring any of them back he did it.
Re: Re: Hitlor
by ACHINTA ROY on Nov 30, 2009 05:49 PM
Dull headed people are always fooled. Subhas was the founder of the first version of Indian army,which included Indian people of all religions, who all faught for India.Go to Moirang near Imphal. INA base is now the Indian army base over there. See how the army men respect him.All because he is an extremist? You go to Australia and settle.
Re: Re: Re: Hitlor
by kaushik ghoshdastidar on Nov 30, 2009 06:01 PM
Dont bother replying to patriot - ironic name of course. These are the kind of repressed people from whom our forefather tried to save India. Because nobody hears to them anywhere else they believe only way to make them heard is disgressing others. Frankly speaking he could be next successor to Bal Thakerey.
Re: Hitlor
by patriot on Nov 30, 2009 05:44 PM
I agree with you. Your people, the dravidians must have been scared of him, because he was alligning himself with hilter who was espousing arya supramacy which meant that bose believed in dravida inferiority.
Anyway, no difference between bose and ltte, both must be destroyed.
The discussion forum has gone too wayward. The discussion needs to be kept strictly revolving around the life and conttibutions of Netaji. No place for RSS or BJP or Congress when talking about Bose and his contributions.
Re: i am still there , India ...............
by John on Nov 30, 2009 05:23 PM
Everyone before coming to poer talk like this. Afterwards they willscrew the country royally.
Re: i am still there , India ...............
by Prakash Pandey on Nov 30, 2009 05:39 PM
If you truly mean to mean anything at all, try mailing to: prakash_pandey2001rediffmailcom
Re: Re: Real Hero
by Nut on Nov 30, 2009 05:19 PM
Patriot asking is S C Bose was a terrorist or not? To hell with your patroism. Read the dictionary first you dull head to find the meaning.
Re: Re: Real Hero
by better thanyourx on Nov 30, 2009 05:24 PM
ms patriot i suggest you aquiant yourself with history a bit more before you open your mouth or your fingers.
Re: Re: Real Hero
by better thanyourx on Nov 30, 2009 05:24 PM
ms patriot i suggest you aquiant yourself with history a bit more before you open your mouth or your fingers.
Re: Real Hero
by jayanta mukharjee on Nov 30, 2009 06:09 PM
thanx asim, if not the whole maximum the credit goes to netaji. Gandhiji was a key player in bringing freedom. we can't also forget bhagat singh / Rashbehari bose / V savarkar / Damodar Savarkar / B G Tilak / Khshudiram Bose / Prafulla Chaki / Vinay, Badal, Dinesh / Masterda Surya sen / Ms Matangini Hazra / Ashutosh Mukherjee / Syamaprasad Mukherjee / Jatindranath Mukherjee / Mangal Pandey to name a few.
Re: Do you know?
by subash gopalaswamy on Nov 30, 2009 06:22 PM
bose defeated the candidate of gandhi(pattabi seetaramayya). gandhi felt ashamed and said that pattabi's defeat is my defeat. Bose held gandhi in the very highest esteem always. He didnt want to oppose gandhi since he mightnot get the full cooperation from other gandhi followers in congress. So he decided to resign his post.
