Now this is really funny, these critics are not having job anymore or what? they have started criticising oscar winner movies.They are making a joke of themselves by writing such things. And even rediff is publishing such things. Dont they have editors???
i have seen beautiful mind. the movie is soo real, the characters are well written. i didnt find anything wrong in the movie. it was romantic and emotional . i think rajasen didnt get the movie atall. Rediff , please fire this guy. he is useless
i seriously doubt credentials of these , critics and that includes , Raja sen and rajeev masand and other creatures of their tribe. some of them are just are failed filmmakers , who never got opportunity . and still they come up with their points ,how come they anticipate and analyze a film , which has such varied ordinance base,all movie watcher seek different experience from movie , some for songs , some for drama and some are sheer followers. so if movie is judge purely on technical things ,its still ok .But they keep surprisng people by their wierd reviews which will contradict their own stand many of time. If movie is trash then it will trash ,still we ill have them zooming in 100 cr club. so bottom line is critics has zero or no standing , in people's mind. Critics are community of failures , who make living out of criticism . commenting on titanic , what a shame , its like hitting stars by their small ineffevtive slingshot.
I think rediff should release worst critics award ,and all of our critics will share the winner's dice.
i seriously doubt credentials of these , critics and that includes , Raja sen and rajeev masand and other creatures of their tribe. some of them are just are failed filmmakers , who never got opportunity . and still they come up with their points ,how come they anticipate and analyze a film , which has such varied ordinance base,all movie watcher seek different experience from movie , some for songs , some for drama and some are sheer followers. so if movie is judge purely on technical things ,its still ok .But they keep surprisng people by their wierd reviews which will contradict their own stand many of time. If movie is trash then it will trash ,still we ill have them zooming in 100 cr club. so bottom line is critics has zero or no standing , in people's mind. Critics are community of failures , who make living out of criticism . commenting on titanic , what a shame , its like hitting stars by their small ineffevtive slingshot.
I think rediff should release worst critics award ,and all of our critics will share the winner's dice.
i seriously doubt credentials of these , critics and that includes , Raja sen and rajeev masand and other creatures of their tribe. some of them are just are failed filmmakers , who never got opportunity . and still they come up with their points ,how come they anticipate and analyze a film , which has such varied ordinance base,all movie watcher seek different experience from movie , some for songs , some for drama and some are sheer followers. so if movie is judge purely on technical things ,its still ok .But they keep surprisng people by their wierd reviews which will contradict their own stand many of time. If movie is trash then it will trash ,still we ill have them zooming in 100 cr club. so bottom line is critics has zero or no standing , in people's mind. Critics are community of failures , who make living out of criticism . commenting on titanic , what a shame , its like hitting stars by their small ineffevtive slingshot.
I think rediff should release worst critics award ,and all of our critics will share the winner's dice.
i seriously doubt credentials of these , critics and that includes , Raja sen and rajeev masand and other creatures of their tribe. some of them are just are failed filmmakers , who never got opportunity . and still they come up with their points ,how come they anticipate and analyze a film , which has such varied ordinance base,all movie watcher seek different experience from movie , some for songs , some for drama and some are sheer followers. so if movie is judge purely on technical things ,its still ok .But they keep surprisng people by their wierd reviews which will contradict their own stand many of time. If movie is trash then it will trash ,still we ill have them zooming in 100 cr club. so bottom line is critics has zero or no standing , in people's mind. Critics are community of failures , who make living out of criticism . commenting on titanic , what a shame , its like hitting stars by their small ineffevtive slingshot.
I think rediff should release worst critics award ,and all of our critics will share the winner's dice.
This is right on the spot. Who is the person who complied this feature? Kudos to him or her. Nikhil Lakshman and Ajith Balakrishnan should make him/her rich.
Has this man gone MAD or what ? Beautiful Mind not a deserving Oscar candidate ?? Not sure if one should be even responding to such stupidity??But wanted to message in order to give vent to my frustration towards such ridiculous remarks.
