Oh Mr.Writer, you can be an ardent fan of SRK and you can write anything as you hve a platform given to write anything in support. That being said, don't pit this film as India's No.1 etc. We already had Enthiran (or Robot for those saw it in Hindi) from Rajnikant to boast of effects and action. Whether you make a film for 150 cr or 150 lacs, it should have the texture, depth and insight. If these are missing then people will trash it..but why do you crib as long as ur hero made money.. that was his objective and he was successful there
Re: Re: we all know it is a combo and shameless copy
by D S on Nov 01, 2011 03:25 PM
continued ..
then Ra one, marketing by cCheaters on the house. this movie Ra One is combo copy, it not a copy from just one place. It is combination of batman, superman, a Will Smith movie, etc.
Re: Re: Re: we all know it is a combo and shameless copy
by D S on Nov 01, 2011 03:27 PM
then again, Delhi bBelly was copy of sScooby dDoobe theme song including the dDirt on the faces.Rock Star theme songs copy of bBeasty boys (showing rReligion dressed people) mingled with pPunju ethnic stuff for market it.
Re: we all know it is a combo and shameless copy
by D S on Nov 01, 2011 03:31 PM
continued ..
games of shahruk to promote Ra One were many. He came in Mosquito advertisement acting is Ravan with 10 faces to inject controversy for an children product.
then came to Amitabh bachan show, got Rajnikant in the game, etc.
Spiderman can climb buildings.. Superman does the things he does and we believe both coz their actions are supported by a convincing script. That is what story telling is all about. People are smart enough to understand fiction from reality. People enjoy fiction even though there is no logic, because a premise is created for the characters to perform. If u see spiderman wake up from bed to climb buildings, we'd be baffled. but we have been told about the radio active spider and its capabilities. after peter parker is bitten, he is shown becoming aware of his new found abilities.it doesn't happen over night.the realistic graphics help support the movie.
What went wrong in Ra.One, was everything, except for Kareena in Chammak Challo, perhaps.. G.One is a program from the cyber world who enters the real world and behaves like a ROBOT !! How absurd is that ? The hero and villain shoot fireballs at each other like they're snowballs.. I never saw any impact on hard objects, forget humans, err programs.
If the movie was made realistic, the audience would have no qualms about the lack of logic. All they need is to understand why whatever is happening happens !
krrish fared better coz the audience understood the reason for Hrithik's powers from Koi Mil Gaya.. even though the graphics didn't help much, the film was well accepted coz people were willing to believe the character and his story.
And Please.. DO NOT COMPARE RA.ONE WITH ENTHIRAN. SHANKAR IS MIGHTY AND SINHA IS AN IDIOT !
