Of all the things that made me p*ssed off in this movie is heroine's junk accent. Heoine's sister is more Desi than Heoine herself. Her accent is so bad, that her lips comeout im ugly postures for real good dialouges. Although they seem more romantic, they are not working just for dialogue delivery
It seems that after directing the two, Jab we met & Love aajkal, Imtiaz has been lost somewhere. The film starts on a good note, with live in concert in Prague, with college life but after the entry of Nargis Fakhri, Imtiaz seems to have imagined movie himself rather than describing it to the cine goers. Unnecessary fight at home just coz Ranbir went to Kashmir. Playing Gibson guitars all of a sudden. The first half of the movie is still watchable to very much extent but the second half becomes too much burdened with lots of flaws to handle.
When using heavy words like JORDAN, ROCKSTAR, JIM Morrison...you expect a more strongly sewed story. U dont expect the movie to go on from some where to somewhere. Only saving graces are the music by Rahman, Songs by Mohit and some acting by Ranbir. Not nicely knitted with sloppy Script writing, Editing, Story to Screenplay. Imtiaz it seems in the end was not able to handle the movie or was not able to make it end on a logical note. Mohit chauhan might get a Filmfare. So does, the AR Rahman for his music. Even Ranbir can get a nomination for acting. But definitly not Imtiaz for direction. Its only a one time watch movie. My ratings 2.25.
Re: Re: Cine Pundit
by sumit singh on Nov 12, 2011 10:46 PM
Kashif's Kamal Review is absolutely what even i feel:) Ranbir's Acting and AR Rahman Music saved this movie from being another Saawariya !! Well Tried Though!1
Re: Re: Cine Pundit
by sumit singh on Nov 12, 2011 10:46 PM
Kashif's Kamal Review is absolutely what even i feel:) Ranbir's Acting and AR Rahman Music saved this movie from being another Saawariya !! Well Tried Though!1
Re: Re: Cine Pundit
by sumit singh on Nov 12, 2011 10:47 PM
Kashif's Kamal Review is absolutely what even i feel:) Ranbir's Acting and AR Rahman Music saved this movie from being another Saawariya !! Well Tried Though!1
Re: Re: Re: Cine Pundit
by pradeep kumar on Nov 13, 2011 01:41 PM
These 4 will definately get the filmfare :- Irshad Kamil - Lyrics AR Rehman - Superb music Mohit Chauhan - Singer Ranbir - Actor...
Movie script is not good and imtiaz direction also not good as same as in Jab we met and Soocha na Tha....
Re: Re: Re: Re: Cine Pundit
by HateLoveMyTeam on Nov 13, 2011 07:12 PM
Ranbir an actor?. U r joking. COming on the screen and screaming is not acting. Emoting is acting. He is big zero
Re: Re: Cine Pundit
by sumit singh on Nov 12, 2011 10:50 PM
Kashif's Kamal Review is absolutely what even i feel:) Ranbir's Acting and AR Rahman Music saved this movie from being another Saawariya !! Well Tried Though!1
It seems that after directing the two, Jab we met & Love aajkal, Imtiaz has been lost somewhere. The film starts on a good note, with live in concert in Prague, with college life but after the entry of Nargis Fakhri, Imtiaz seems to have imagined monie himself rather than describing it to the cine goers. Unnecessary fight at home just coz Ranbir went to Kashmir. Playing Gibson guitars all of a sudden. The first half of the movie is still watchable to very much extent but the second half becomes too much burdened with flaws to handle.
When using heavy words like JORDAN, ROCKSTAR, JIM Morrison...you expect a more strongly sewed story. U dont expect the movie to go on from some where to somewhere. Only saving graces are the music by Rahman, Songs by Mohit and some acting by Ranbir. Not nicely knitted with sloppy Script writing to Screenplay. Imtiaz it seems in the end was not able to handle the movie or was not able to make it end on a logical note. Mohit chauhan might get a Filmfare. So does, the AR Rahman for his music. Even Ranbir can get a nomination for acting. But definitly not Imtiaz for direction. Its only a one time watch movie. My ratings 2.25.
