Re: Raja sen is mere BONG supporter
by sherlockholmes on Nov 20, 2010 05:16 AM
listen man.. he never worte in the review "dont see the movie" he found it boring .. in past he was right about some movies and for some he was not. All this cry is because he rated 3 idiots low, and it was big hit. In fact to be honest 3 idiots was a good movie , not a great movie. Vacum using for child birth and a guy faking a name and qualifications to get into a prestegious engineering collage.. those things really dont happen, so its a movie with its flaws, Mr.Sen gave it a 2 and half stars or something out of five and all hell broke lose on the comment board.. i think he should have give a 3 to that movie thats what the movie deserves.
Re: Re: Raja sen is mere BONG supporter
by sreejit steve on Nov 20, 2010 09:09 AM
agree totally..90% of people's hatred for Raja Sen is because of that one review of 3 Idiots..Even fans of Raja Sen(including me) feel it brought out his prejudice against Aamir...
Re: Re: Re: Raja sen is mere BONG supporter
by Story editor on Nov 20, 2010 09:16 AM
3 idiots was not a great movie indeed, there were many technical and factual flaws and the Munnabhai movies from the same production house were much better.
Having said that Raja Sen sometimes trashes good movies and his reviews rarely hit the bull's eye, but I do not think he is parochial or something, that he would favour a Bengali.
By the way I am Bengali...we need to get out of our regional bias in everything!
It is not as good as BLACK but much better than dabang and assume golmal too.Hrithik did excellent job and movie would have better with chitrangadda or vidya balan rather than Aishwarya
why shouldnt a quadriplegic have conditioned hair and perfectly groomed beard? he has a caretaker anyway to do them. Lot of people care for their appearance despite illness or disability
Re: silly
by Sriparna Tarafdar on Nov 20, 2010 01:19 AM
If some normal person is used to live like a "rot"(may be the critic himself) how can he expect that from a quadriplegic!
again why we r criticizing about movie, the question is whether u enjoyed or not. He is not the only who copied movie. I meant to say u went to c the movie or u went to c how much he copied.
Re: Lets Vote
by Raj Reddy on Nov 20, 2010 01:07 AM
Everyone here wants to kick Raja Sen's b&!!. No one wants him. That idiot does not get it and Rediff does not get it.
Re: Lets Vote
by sreejit steve on Nov 20, 2010 09:13 AM
dont agree..Raja Sen has a great sense of movies, at time clouded by his deep-rooted biases and prejudices..for most part, i rely on his reviews to decide if i shud watch a movie or not
Re: shame on BHANSALI THE ENTIRE MOVIE IS COPY
by First Last on Nov 20, 2010 01:16 AM
A jerk has spoken. You seem to be a copy of some firangi (thanks to your mother). Shame on your mother.
Re: Re: shame on BHANSALI THE ENTIRE MOVIE IS COPY
by Mick Patel on Nov 20, 2010 06:52 PM
Firstlast, you vomit crap on ppl who like the movie and you also do it to ppl who hate it. WTF! Is that a lifelong bimaari for you to just ooze crap all the time?
Re: shame on BHANSALI THE ENTIRE MOVIE IS COPY
by Raj Reddy on Nov 20, 2010 01:07 AM
I thought we had just one idiot in the reviewer. Now we have another one.
Re: Re: shame on BHANSALI THE ENTIRE MOVIE IS COPY
by Radha Krishna on Nov 20, 2010 03:10 AM
Yes,movie copied..so whats something to do with India you idiot.. Talk about movie...not india..
