All Hindu's please take note that NDTV(Hindu basher) is co-producer of this film. So you can imagine the outcome of this whole episode. They will try their every bit to show farmers in poor taste. This story is not highlightening the core problem of farmer suicides. Farmers are commiting suicides because of govt. policies. But aamir khan another muslim(congres loving) trying his best to show farmers as real culprits. Please go to the base of real problem not for the sake of garnering votes for congress.
Re: Please note NDTV(Congress supporter) is co-producer of this f
by Paresh Rawal on Aug 15, 2010 04:00 PM | Hide message
Oh BC sawant , sangh pariwar syco_phant ! comment on the movie not on ur conspiracy theories.
Re: Re: Please note NDTV(Congress supporter) is co-producer of th
by aditya bhat on Aug 16, 2010 09:51 AM
he is absolutely right...all of ur bollywood is dominated by these pro pakistani khans and they will never loose a chance to show hindus in bad light!! this is a fact!!!
Watched the movie,its a waste if u spend money watching in theatre.movie is OK a realistic movie ...nothing great and mostly hype and u know the whole story before the movie starts....nothing
Again amir proves that he is not Rajni Kanth or amitabh or dilip. He is AMIR KHAN. TAre Zamin Par, 3 Idiots and now Peepli. people like amir can bring revolution with out even knowing that its happening. Watch out for serious realty with mix emotions, laughing and crying at hte same same time.
Re: Amir is a legend
by Sameer Bhagwat on Aug 15, 2010 03:43 AM
Chill dude, very average movie. Don't get acrried away bcos hez from your caste. There are 100s of movies down South that are much better, but don't get the recognition
Re: Re: Amir is a legend
by Mark D on Aug 15, 2010 04:40 AM
HAHA. FKN Indians. Never appreciate anything collectively. Its always mine and yours. Nothing is ours.
Re: Re: Re: Amir is a legend
by Paresh Rawal on Aug 15, 2010 04:02 PM
yep . thats the problem in this part of the world. exactly why we are where we are .
Peepli Live - good film shows agony of poor Indian Farmer. Because of Peepli is produced under Aamir Khan production the film has got such high market value otherwise its nothing but common documentary film. And Indian people tendency WATCH, HEAR and FORGET.
Re: Media Hype
by adarsh tripathy on Aug 15, 2010 04:00 PM
thats true off course and definitely that amir khan is so huge personality now adays oviously it will make his movie popular...bt the fact is d actors have done magnificient role and all have given a good effort....don't carried away by the reviews or anything else...jst watch movie which actually shows the plight of india and also great direction and enactment by all the actors...
Re: Media Hype
by Shaleen Sinha on Aug 14, 2010 06:53 PM
You sound like a frustrated marathiBhau. It is not the fault of Hindi speaking people that marathi film industry never developed beyond Dada Kondke films. GhatiCulture is to blame for the low quality of marathi films. Now you should beg Raj Thakre to save your industry.
Re: Re: Media Hype
by Abhijit Mohare on Aug 14, 2010 10:04 PM
Why u r mixing politics and film together. Actually this is Entertainment film not the political akhaada.. The people like you instigate us. So stop your faltu comments. Go and watch that film... one more thing what about Paying Guest film? was that not stolen from "Ashi hi banva banvi" Marathi film... Dont behave like you are the Advocate of Aamir or Hindi film industry..
Re: Re: Media Hype
by Abhijit Mohare on Aug 14, 2010 10:00 PM
Why u r mixing politics and film together. Actually this is Entertainment film not the political akhaada.. The people like you instigate us. So stop your faltu comments. Go and watch that film... one more thing what about Paying Guest film? was that not stolen from "Ashi hi banva banvi" Marathi film... Dont behave like you are the Advocate of Aamir or Hindi film industry..
Re: Re: Media Hype
by Abhijit Mohare on Aug 14, 2010 10:01 PM
Why u r mixing politics and film together. Actually this is Entertainment film not the political akhaada.. The people like you instigate us. So stop your faltu comments. Go and watch that film... one more thing what about Paying Guest film? was that not stolen from "Ashi hi banva banvi" Marathi film... Dont behave like you are the Advocate of Aamir or Hindi film industry..
This storyline is suspiciously similar to the Marathi film released last year- Gabhricha Paus (That damned Rain). The protagonist, a poor farmer, who is at his wits end, and his wife and mother, who suspect that he'll commit suicide, and therefore depute their little boy to keep a watch on the farmer, portrayed very touchingly a dark comedy of the Vidarbha farmer's life that ultimately ends sadly.
This movie's storyline is very similar. Seems to me like Aamir is making a career out of stealing others ideas and not giving credit (3 Idiots and the Chetan Bhagat controversy ...)
Re: Stolen from Marathi film
by preeti kulkarni on Aug 13, 2010 06:46 PM
The storyline might be similar to the movie you've mentioned, but he is not 'stealing' others' idea, its produced by him, he is not taking the credit for story/script. And seriously, before watching Three Idiots, I was also under impression that its largely based on FIVE POINT SOMEONE, but after watching the movie I realized, it has less than 5% similarity with the book. Other than definition of 'Machine' and one of the lead characters falling in love with dean's daughter, there aren't many similarities. More than anything, when an artwork is copied or used as an inspiration, the essence should not be lost. That's what really matters. Even if its a Rip of the Marathi movie, how many in India will ever get to see 'Gabhricha Paus' due to language constraints? It is appreciable that some people are investing in cinema which is more than masaala-naach gaana routine. I hope more such cinemas should reach the audience who wants to watch sensible cinema.
Re: Re: Stolen from Marathi film
by Netflix on Aug 15, 2010 06:54 PM
Looks like you do not understand concept of ethics. You must be brain dead if you think 3 idiot is less than 5% of five point someone. Yet another possibility is that you have not read the book.
Re: Re: Re: Stolen from Marathi film
by preeti kulkarni on Aug 17, 2010 10:16 PM
There is another possibility that you might have read the book with but haven't understood it at all. Do you have behavioral problems or something? FPS in one of my favorite books, and I do not find the movie very similar to the book. I think everyone out there is allowed to have different perspectives, so I have mine. Book was pure fun..whereas movie goes beyond just fun part..it also has a message. I believe that good art/movies/music should reach to all people, that is ethics for me. The movie shows that Chatur who had fulfilled his dollar dreams, could not match the real success of Phunsuk Wangdu. Book has not touched this aspect, nor it has left any message. And being an audio visual medium, cinema can reach out the way any novel written in English can never reach out in India.
Re: Re: Stolen from Marathi film
by raj on Aug 13, 2010 06:50 PM
Just for information. This is not a forum for making such sensable comments:-) . Anyway a very good post. I echo you.
with 4 family members i have to almost spend 1000 bucks for entertainment of myself and my family... The facts and ruggedness of indian society is dripping from news channels and today's serial and reality shows. To escape my self for 3hrs from all these horrors...Peepli no doubt to be good movie... dont want to get horrified pay.... and this doctored publicity of peepli is more grimming....
Re: Entertainment cost..
by soutik das on Aug 13, 2010 04:36 PM
I 'm gonna watch it for 440 bucks for 4.. why u guys go for those swanky multiplex and then cry?
Re: Entertainment cost..
by Shaleen Sinha on Aug 12, 2010 04:59 PM
so best thing for you to do is to stay home and watch Etka Kapoor serials. No one is forcing you to watch this movie..
Re: Entertainment cost..
by Shaleen Sinha on Aug 12, 2010 04:59 PM
so best thing for you to do is to stay home and watch Etka Kapoor serials. No one is forcing you to watch this movie..
Re: Re: Entertainment cost..
by amol pardeshi on Aug 12, 2010 05:03 PM
dear i am spending 1000 bucks to escape those... point is dont want to spend 1000 to get frustrated... and more frustrating thing is that cannot do anything about it except waiting for right person to come in so that i can vote hi,...
Re: Re: Re: Entertainment cost..
by Shaleen Sinha on Aug 12, 2010 05:05 PM
No one is forcing you to spend those 1000 bucks on Peepli. Spend that money on KhattaMeethaa if you wish...
Re: Re: Re: Re: Entertainment cost..
by amol pardeshi on Aug 12, 2010 05:08 PM
:) did and feel sorry for it.... be a friend by suggesting somthing good... watching movie has become like betting the horse nowdays.. isint it...
