Indian made fantasy films are terrible, cliched and overracted. Add some loser sideline actor as the lead, and some predictable scenes, you have a guaranteed flop. Ritesh is already pretending that he was into lamps and genies as a kid. Chee.
Re: What do you expect? Of course it's a flop.
by Joideep on Oct 30, 2009 07:42 PM
They way they hype/market the movies these days is a joke, it is so ridiculous. Ritesh pretending to like lamps when he was a kid takes the cake
tell me how do u judge a critic??? for ex...in indiafm the critic has given 3 star ratn for london dreams and on rediff it is 2 star...they have appreciated there and they have thrashed it here...so any gyan on tat???
Re: how do u rate a critic???
by Ajay Thakral on Oct 30, 2009 02:51 PM
Rediff critic is idiot. She does not know anything about the movies and public's taste... Go with IndiaFM review which is written by Taran Aadarsh...
Re: Re: how do u rate a critic???
by Joideep on Oct 30, 2009 07:45 PM
Taran Adarsh is a joke! He is an industry man, who grovels at the feet of industry people. Clear conflict of interests there. You do you need a critic's approval/disapproval? You be your own critic! You do not need somebody eles's certificate.
Re: Re: Re: how do u rate a critic???
by candy bhatia on Oct 31, 2009 06:15 PM
joideep.....v are not vellas who watch each and every movie....u go on ur way...
Re: Reviewer got bribe form SRK
by PS on Oct 30, 2009 04:48 PM
Somewhat right you are. Bakwas films of SRK wins filmfare awards whereas very good films from Aamir Khan are never nominated for awards.How is it possible. The reviewers only praise SRK movies however crap it may be.
Re: Re: Reviewer got bribe form SRK
by ramen das on Oct 30, 2009 01:51 PM
it is a sad movie...& that doesn't mean SRK is gr8 actor..everyone in bollywood is making sad movies...& yes, before an Akki fan drops by...he is in the same league too...
First of all This movie critics are most shameless Creatures in this universe. So Far I think First shows have not come and they started to make such comments. I feel Govt should stop all those Reviews. These people can give their expert reviews after one week of the opening of film. Lots effort and energy are invested behind film. This Reviewers did not put any money rather blackmailing the people. So As a conscious viewers we should tell these Reviewers blackmailer and strictly put censorship on these creatures.
Re: This is the time to put sensorship on Review
by Joideep on Oct 30, 2009 07:51 PM
Hey Tanoy - Why do you need a critic approval/disapproval? Its just one person's opinion. Govt censoring critics is the most ridiculous idea ever! Next thing is India will become like the Taliban banning movies because people like you do not like certain kind of movies. Feel free to disregard any critic's opinion, form your own judgment. The whole world does not have to agree with you.
Re: This is the time to put sensorship on Review
by Atul Khare on Oct 30, 2009 01:18 PM
I 100 % agree to yr point sir. Its really disgusting to discuss the film and present the review. The stars put thier immense energy to complete the film, and critics simply give the stars in red and mark poor, better or good to see. I also agree that these people shd immediately be banned.
Re: Re: Re: This is the time to put sensorship on Review
by Tanoy on Oct 30, 2009 01:38 PM
Democracy does not mean you are giving free license to any one. Other wise very next day any one will murder any body in street and will be advocating for his /her work. you have freedom of speech but can't practice of yellow journalism. This Film critics are perfect example of Yellow Journalism
Re: Re: Re: This is the time to put sensorship on Review
by arun sharma on Oct 30, 2009 01:36 PM
yes i agree, and kind of enegry they put, they chagred thier fees in crore, live in 7 star life and what they do they make the fool to the people by doing these kind of movie. they are not do anything different. they dance on stage, they fight with vilion and that si the end of film.the real enery putter are labours farmers ,soldier
Re: Re: Re: Re: This is the time to put sensorship on Review
by Tanoy on Oct 30, 2009 01:42 PM
Arun sharma,
why are you become fool then? Do you want to cultivate crops in Movie theater. It does not make sense when you compare them with Farmers and soldiers. They are doing their Jobs. But what this film critics are doing is not their Job rather blackmailing for cheap Publicity and making money
Re: Re: Re: This is the time to put sensorship on Review
by sanath on Oct 30, 2009 02:42 PM
Guru, does democracy mean character assasinating a person or product ? Could u explain the rationale behind the same site granting 2 stars one day and after two weeks again granting 3 stars to the very same movie ? so who is fooling whom ?
Re: Re: This is the time to put sensorship on Review
by ramen das on Oct 30, 2009 01:46 PM
it is critics duty 2 warn ppl if a movie is poor...so that ppl avoid it and save money...just because makers have invested a lot doesn't make a movie watchable...we also pay hard earned money for a ticket and deserve value for that...mega budget craps like blue & now this one don't understand this simple thing...
Re: Re: Re: This is the time to put sensorship on Review
by Tanoy on Oct 30, 2009 01:56 PM
Don't you have your own knowledge and judgment that you have to depend on these Critics . If these critics told you to do suicide, will you do theses things. who the hell these critics are to tell people about one film. Ramen Das I am sure you are from these creatures which are known as Film critics.
Re: Re: Re: Re: This is the time to put sensorship on Review
by ramen das on Oct 30, 2009 02:05 PM
now i understand ur love for such a movie...u even lack the basic sense of logic...how does a common man know a film is good or bad if there r no critics?..by watching the film, i.e. by wasting 200 if the film is poor...ppl often watch films on recommendation by other people which is another kind of review...
if u think i am also a critic I think u r Vilasrao Deshmukh trying 2 save ur sons film...
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: This is the time to put sensorship on Review
by Tanoy on Oct 30, 2009 02:58 PM
Then lots of people don't need to watch movie rather reading those Crap Review.According to Film critics 80% films are bad. So This industry can be died already
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: This is the time to put sensorship on Review
by Tanoy on Oct 30, 2009 02:18 PM
Dude, you made me chief Minister with out election, without vote. hahahaha. I don't know It is so easy to be CM . Thanks.Thanks I at least told you Critics whom I can give maximum status of a blackmailer but you made me CM. My door is always opened for you. Please don't mind just kidding
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: This is the time to put sensorship on Review
by harish math on Oct 30, 2009 02:24 PM
tell me how do u judge a critic??? for ex...in indiafm the critic has given 3 star ratn for london dreams and on rediff it is 2 star...they have appreciated there and they have thrashed it here...so any gyan on tat???
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: This is the time to put sensorship on Review
by ramen das on Oct 30, 2009 02:24 PM
u like it or not...a lot of ppl would prefer 2 hav a look at the review before splurging money on a film...
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: This is the time to put sensorship on Review
by Prem Taparia on Oct 30, 2009 02:59 PM
I agree...reviews are a must...and that too on early Friday..so ppl can think twice b4 splurging on dud movies during weekend...
Re: Foolish Stuff
by AMBEY SRIVASTAVA on Oct 30, 2009 03:03 PM
It is a nice movie to watch. Your all indian stars are politician. Then you should stop watching every movie.
Re: Re: Re: hmm
by Sameer Sharma on Oct 30, 2009 08:05 PM
She cannot emote, always has the same expressions, non existing acting abilities. Has to get her voice dubbed. Looks good though
