Re: Elvis D'Silva is junk reviewer
by Johnny G on Mar 06, 2009 01:52 PM
Not his mistake friend...if you watch this movie "post censor" then one really can't make out much about the story line, which is otherwise a brilliant piece of art (pardon the nudity though!)
How old are you MrElvis,u have just given two stars for a brilliant movie,did you watch the cut version ,i mean because in India the theatres will definitly cut some scenes from the movie,well the passion is intact and you should know a bit about the holocaust to give your stupid review on this movie
IF YOU DNT UNDERSTAND CINEMA , DONT TALK ABOUT IT. IF YOU DNT UNDERSTAND GERMAN HOLOCAUST AND THE WHOLE TRADITIONS OF FILMS MADE ON IT IN LAST 68 YEARS, YOU WILL NEVER UNDERSTAND READER IN THIS LIFE TIME. WAIT FOR NEXT BIRTH. MILIND
Re: the reader
by Divya Mahajan on Mar 06, 2009 11:12 AM
No way.. i have seen both movies and no match is there. In pinjar, manoj bajpai takes her. here the scene is different
Elvis D'Silva...you are really out of your mind !! Two stars for this movie and what five star for Pink Panther 2?? If you are 13 yr old then that explains ..but if you arean adult then..then hats off to rediff to appoint you to review this movie and give rating..not your fault its a rediff's fault to allow you to rate it...you see like a guy who doesn't even have passion for movies..real movies i meant..
Re: Hats Off
by Wrik Sen on Mar 06, 2009 11:09 AM
I agree Bipin... Elvis, you need a mental health check up... this movie was a master piece, and I might as well say, it was better than Slumdog on some counts... Kate was wonderfull, and simply brilliant, and it is one of those good movies I saw lasy year... Elvis and rediff: we really do have a problem here...
Re: Re: Hats Off
by bipin sabnis on Mar 06, 2009 01:32 PM
Yes Wrik..I cant agree more with whatever you have said..this movie is like a masterpiece..even better then SDM at some points..brilliant direction and the feel of the movie is awesome..it really touched me..and I am so so happy for Kate..she won academy award for it..well these morons like rediff..they show their standard and level by acting like this..
Re: Re: Re: Hats Off
by simon seth on Mar 08, 2009 01:31 AM
I agree.Rediff does nt have issues with slumdog getting those Oscars ( undeserved except AR Rehman and sound artist rassol)and yet the id..t raises doubt about This movie?Go take a walk ,sunny boy. wake up. drill some sense in your roten jingoist head. slum... was stupid fare, won because indian markets are the only saving grace for hollywood movies and so the oscars. but this movie, any day better than others especially Kate' performance. Yas, you can question west's misplaced and overdone sympathy bits for holocaust, german torture camps and world war II but not cinematic merit of this movie.
Re: Re: Re: Hats Off
by simon seth on Mar 08, 2009 01:31 AM
I agree.Rediff does nt have issues with slumdog getting those Oscars ( undeserved except AR Rehman and sound artist rassol)and yet the id..t raises doubt about This movie?Go take a walk ,sunny boy. wake up. drill some sense in your roten jingoist head. slum... was stupid fare, won because indian markets are the only saving grace for hollywood movies and so the oscars. but this movie, any day better than others especially Kate' performance. Yas, you can question west's misplaced and overdone sympathy bits for holocaust, german torture camps and world war II but not cinematic merit of this movie.
