this is why i always liked rediff .. rediff attracts people by posting of this kind of meaningless/controversial reviews .. its indeed a good tactic to increase the number of viewer .. to confirm it just see the no. of comments review1 (255) got ..almost double that of review 2 (125) ..
RE:Superb Movie and a powerful performance by Hrithik
by nitin rajwar on Feb 15, 2008 05:32 PM
can u plzz tell me how are d WAR scenes are directed...Any match to Lord of d Rings, Troy..!!!
RE:Superb Movie and a powerful performance by Hrithik
by sushil dubey on Feb 15, 2008 07:02 PM
nitin, please go and see the movie yaar. Why are you asking the war secne only :). and of course it can not be like war of the world because of tech differences. Ok buddy , have a nice day
I WOULD REQUEST THE WORLD FILM PRODUCERS TO LOOK AT THE GREAT INDIAN DIRECTOR AND OFFER HIM PROJECTS.THIS MAGNIFICIENT VISUAL TREAT CAN BE CREATED AND SEEN ONCE IN A LIFETIME.IT IS FORTUNATE FOR US TO HAVE SEEN A FILM LIKE THIS
RE:A TREAT FOR THE EYE
by nitin rajwar on Feb 15, 2008 05:44 PM
can u plzz tell me how are d WAR scenes are directed...Any match to Lord of d Rings, Troy..!!!
RE:A TREAT FOR THE EYE
by HR Mumbai on Feb 15, 2008 05:57 PM
Go & watch first watch lords of rings and then see JA... u will know the difference & still u dont recognize the diff, u are dumbo !!!!!
RE:A TREAT FOR THE EYE
by Nirmal on Feb 16, 2008 05:29 AM
to direct such scenes all u need to do is to lick Dawood ibrahim bhai's ass...u will get enough money then !
RE:Just saw the film...
by saurabh sharma on Feb 15, 2008 03:19 PM
it seems u dont want to talk about movie "Jodha Akbar" , instead you just want to talk rubbish about Shahrukh Khan. Grow up Krishi. Do you have any personal rivalry with khan? Has he taken away your girl friend? :-)
RE:RE:RE:Just saw the film...
by saurabh sharma on Feb 15, 2008 04:05 PM
If you are writing about JA just write about the movie itself, dont keep comparing its star cast with other stars. Its really sad that people dont understand this thing. You keep saying whatever you want but everybody can see that your first three lines were abt movie and rest other were wasted in abusing SRK. And one more thing being a child at an age of 50 doesnt mean that you will keep abusing someone. and the funniest part is, if somebody retaliates then you say that u r 50 yrs old. being a child means you keep learning and keep exploring new areas. I m really sorry if i have said something wrong. But just wrote wht i felt. Now keep saying whatever you want.
RE:RE:Just saw the film...
by alan fernandes on Feb 15, 2008 10:02 PM
We don't have any personal rivalry with SRK but he has fooled the audience for so many years with his very much below-average acting. All this he managed to mantain due to his films being big hits. He is nothing but a big star who has made it only due to good luck. Long live the very talented actors Aamir Khan, Hritik and Akshay Kumar.
RE:RE:RE:Just saw the film...
by on Feb 16, 2008 12:23 AM
Before this go into some kind of war of words I will like to clarify that I am not a SRK fan or HR fan. >>>We don't have any personal rivalry with SRK but he has fooled the audience for so many years with his very much below-average acting. Agreed. But dont forget people get what they deserves. If SRK is hit with the public, then the public is making his movies HIT. One cant make his own movie hit or flop. That is for the general public to decide.
RE:Just saw the film...
by Krishi Varma on Feb 15, 2008 03:43 PM
hey saurabh.. to tu kisike words sey woh baap hai ki nahi pataa sakta hai... i am a grown up but i never want to lose the child inside me forever.. even if i am 50 in my later life.. aur too kya internet language ki baat kar raha hai? remember who said this : " Has he taken away your girl friend? ".(i think not just the words, the meaning of a phrase too is important) agar yeh chalta hai to mera kyon nahin... i was just replying to you in a different lang....tu hi bolta hai ki main father nahin hoon aur toohi poochta hai "apney bachon ko kya sikhaoge?" who is being childish here?
RE:RE:Just saw the film...
by Krishi Varma on Feb 15, 2008 03:46 PM
and to add to my previous words.. kya main bolun ki tere words se mujhe too kya lagta hai.. bolun kya??
RE:Just saw the film...
by saurabh sharma on Feb 15, 2008 03:34 PM
It seems u r having some serious problem man. Teri baaton se yeh nahin lagta ki tu kisi ka father hai u r so immature. If anybody will go through your views , he will just feel that YOu are settling some personal score with SRK. You are really childish. GROW UP!!!!! Aur sabse pehle to INTERNET par kaisi language use karte hain seekh lo. Warna apne bachhon ko kya sikhogey?
RE:Just saw the film...
by Krishi Varma on Feb 15, 2008 04:08 PM
pehle khud keliye duva maang .. baad mein doosron ki soch.. mere liye too kyon kasht uthaata hai.. mujhe teri duva ki koyi zaroorat nahin.......
RE:RE:Just saw the film...
by Krishi Varma on Feb 15, 2008 04:41 PM
k then everyone.. bye for now... will join later in the day if possible.. go watch JA for an excellent but a touch lengthy movie(3:30 hrs).. had it been an half an hour shorter.. it is ALMOST perfection in movie making... my liking for Hrithik and Urdu only bettered after this movie... Ash is stunning in her traditional looks and the way she tried to potray a princess.... all in all.. i want to go for another round of Gowariker's ability in movies and for the same film...this is my feeling...
good preview...positive and motivating for viewers..unlike ur colleague sick raja sen..... atleast it is a good tribute to the hard work of film's technical team of A gowrikar...will definitely watch this movie. needless to say, when i saw Preview 1-and its author as Raja sen...i immeditely switched over to Preview 2..and iam glad it is positive
RE:well done Arthur J pias
by Waheed Hamid on Feb 15, 2008 09:00 PM
Go watch the movie Rashmi, you will love it Every one was excellent, Hrithik and Ash. Music - Rehman Direction This will be the biggest blockbuster of the decade.
RE:well done Arthur J pias
by Mhd.Arshad on Feb 15, 2008 02:40 PM
Madam you pity the hard work putin by the films technical team but, have no regard whatsoever for the viewing publics hard earned money I think you alsongside Arthur from NY must have been hired as publicist to fill in these web notings by the UTV or maybe Ashutosh. If you are so concerned about hardwork then you should also admire hardwork of netas who canvas for our mandate and vote on those lines...you sound like a utter fool.
RE:well done Arthur J pias
by on Feb 15, 2008 03:14 PM
I Think the movie is worth a watch as i had also read a review from taran adarsh and he's said Noone ever before has dared to make such a movie and ashutosh's brilliance in directing epics is undoubtedly supreme...i had loved swades too.
RE:well done Arthur J pias
by nitin rajwar on Feb 15, 2008 05:37 PM
can u plzz tell me how are d WAR scenes are directed...Any match to Lord of d Rings, Troy..!!!
RE:RE:well done Arthur J pias
by shiv sunny on Feb 16, 2008 08:22 PM
i think u hav gone mad......how many times shud v come across da same msg written by u?
"...why the film does not show any indication how, in his later years, Akbar would not allow his son to marry a court dancer."
Come on, we all like Mughal-e-Azam. And while most of us haven't seen Anarkali, we love its songs too. But historians dismiss Anarkali as, at best, bazaar gossip. Aren't we taking entertainment too seriously? So here is at least one future viewer who won't want the film to explain anything (not shown in the film).
Well Done Mate, thats a wonderfully scripted movie review. Nice to read and your the winner. Yes, this is definitely a wonderfull movie made in Hindi Cinema World. Hrithik just great, he is damn good and box office will definitely pour like his last movie DHOOM2...
Guys, enjoy this movie, its great to watch. Dont messup with Raja Sen's baissed reviews..
RE:Well Done Arthur J Pais - your the Champ and your the winner over biassed Raja Sen
by dhananjay sinha on Feb 15, 2008 12:40 PM
I thinks this is the mos boring movie in decades. No story line, characters weak... A Dancing AKBAR??? Such cheaply shot battle scenes.. only money spent has been on the clothes and jewels of the lead actors. Historicaly totaly completey a pack of lies.
RE:Well Done Arthur J Pais - your the Champ and your the winner over biassed Raja Sen
by Mhd.Arshad on Feb 15, 2008 02:42 PM
I agree toto I spent my hard earned money Rs 1200 to be precise to catch this boring Directorial misadventure and editorial blunder. Btw who is the goddamn editor here...
RE:RE:Well Done Arthur J Pais - your the Champ and your the winner over biassed Raja Sen
by nitin rajwar on Feb 15, 2008 05:45 PM
can u plzz tell me how are d WAR scenes are directed...Any match to Lord of d Rings, Troy..!!!
RE:Well Done Arthur J Pais - your the Champ and your the winner over biassed Raja Sen
by maya menon on Feb 15, 2008 02:26 PM
"Dancing Akbar" hahahaha ; thats really amusing
RE:It Supposed to be a good Movie, don't miss.
by Waheed Hamid on Feb 15, 2008 09:01 PM
Arshad, you are a LUNATIC. Why are you opposing a movie made on AKBAR the GREAT. You of all should be supportive. You STUPID LUNATIC
RE:It Supposed to be a good Movie, don't miss.
by Deepak MA on Feb 15, 2008 09:38 PM
All this while I thought that you were appreciative of the movie. Now the truth is out!! What shallow thinking you buggers have!!!!
thank good i saw 1st time rediff's second review is differing from raja sen. Any was how long others can support his stupid idea. Though i have not seen the movie yet. Its great to see some one has give quite a different review in rediff than the stupid dumb. and the fact that this review is differing from raja sens ... thats enough to show that this man has good taste of movies.
