Re: GHAZNI
by Harpreet Khurana on Dec 20, 2008 04:00 PM
Oh you're talking about Rab Ne! Yeah whatever you said is completely true...but only for RNBDJ!!
After attacking shahrukh khan ,,he gives lots of money to rediff and all news channel..
Shah Rukh said: "I want all the people to watch 'Ghajini'. We as people from the industry know how much pain it takes to make a film. We wait anxiously every Friday to see the result of our hard work that we put in to make a film."
plz check msn dot com,,,,entertainment section,,, i cant able to paste the link,,,
Re: Re: Re: Re: check it
by Harpreet Khurana on Dec 20, 2008 04:06 PM
It's Mr. SRK who pays media to give 'good' reviews to his silly movies! Inviting journos to have tea with him and asking them to sing his praises all over news channels and internet...that's what he always does! Since your favorite SRK does the same stuff, so you fans think that Aamir too would do the same! Aamir Khan doesn't need to bribe the media to blow his trumpet. The name Aamir Khan, associated with a movie, is more than enough. His name alone is a seal of quality and excellence.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: check it
by akshiu on Dec 22, 2008 06:05 PM
Before reminding him about Fanaa, Mangal Pandey and Mela, Mr. Tukaram, why don't you remember 'masterpieces' like Army, Chahat, Chamatkar, Dil Aashna Hai, King Uncle, GUDDU (a classic!), Ram Jaane, Trimurti, English Babu Desi Mem, Koyla, Zamana Deewana, Oh Darling! Yeh Hai India, Asoka, Phir Bhi Dil Hai Hindustani, Hum Tumhare Hain Sanam, One 2 Ka 4, Shakti The Power, Paheli, Dushman Duniya Ka, Duplicate, Gaja Gamini and of course, the awesome Maya Memsaab....to name a few!!
First things first - Ghajini is only an INDIANIZED version of memento, the ending is quite different, so are some parts of the storyline
though I did not want to highlight - Carrie Ann Moss was an waitress in Memento, Nayantara/Jiah are medical students
there are many such differences - none so the fact that Guy's wife had only a minor role in the movie
some people (ignorant, of course) have said its a copy of Guy Ritchie's movie (what a joke) - its a Chris Nolan movie (TDK, Batman Begins fame) - and the lead actor is Guy Pierce
There are also a few very smart souls who have tried to point out that watching Memento requires intelligence while Ghajini is for less-intelligent individuals - well trying to show themselves as admirers of good cinema
a tru admirer of cinema is one who can apreciate the goodness in a movie like The Seven Samurai and even a hindi movie which was loosely based on it - Sholay. Its all about seeing goodness in the movies, and not "this movie is a copy, so it must be rubbish" stuff
There are also a few SRK dala*s who says in the aftermath od Mumbai, watch romantic crap like RNBDJ - well a crap is a crap, whenever it is released. Indian audiences have matured, thats why movies like Bheja Fry and Oye Lucky are admired - people here no longer fall that Rahul Anjali sh*t
Ghajini, will be a huge hit (already the prints and rights have been sold for 80 odd crores) - and Amir Khan will again prove he doesnt need big movie houses(YRF) to act
Re: Memento and Ghajini
by tiger on Dec 20, 2008 12:11 PM
there are lot more difference also kaushik,in memnto the real hero's name is leonard,,,here sanjay,,,,so all the characters name,,,,
big difference,,,, no songs in memento,,,,,
and music directors are also difference,,,
the tattos are also different,,,,
the fight sequence shot in india(this is also a big difference)
aamir khan is mch shorter than him,,(very big difference)
Momento..................................momento...................................momento............. 90%people saying the same thing. How can you ignore 90%people? This is democracy baba. If one is doing that he surely have been paid big by the "nautankia" aamir khan. So to say, "Aangrezi film ko masale se wrap karke 8 pack ke nampe rona dhona ka nautanki kar raha hai babua." His childhood problem. How is he looking? Well the older edition of brother Faizal khan ( know toh he has a brother whom he never attends?)
Re: Watch momento instead
by anand on Dec 20, 2008 09:26 AM
momeno indian audiance ke liye nahin hai.Usmein kaafi dimaag lagana padega kuch samajhanekeliye.Indian aadmi want full entertainment for 3 hrs.bina koyi tension ke. tum kitana bhi chillao srk ke chamche tera gas to ghajini ke first sho ke saath hi nikal jayega.go and do some constructive work.
Re: Watch momento instead
by varun on Dec 20, 2008 11:53 AM
if people are accusing aamir of doing masala films, then what has SRK been doing all these years? He is no patch on aamir as an actor, SRK is an entertainer and people don't take his clown act seriously, whereas aamir has always known for doing good, sensible cinema. Ghajini might be an adaptation of memento which is fine, you can't make memento in hindi the exact way and sell it to the indian audience becoz a lot of people won't get it, especially people who have grown up on candy floss srk stuff.
Re: Re: Watch momento instead
by LeaveSRKandSachinAlone on Dec 21, 2008 12:27 AM
if aamir makes sensible cinema, do u call mangal pandey, mela, fanaa, ishq etc as sensible cinema? u must be mad. aamir just utilizes some pretentious nationalistic issue and makes a movie out of it unlike srk who just wants to keep entertaining and has no such pretentions...look at aamir what he is saying that srk is scared to act with him...this after srk openly told that he wants to work with aamir...aamir is a manipulator and is jealous of SRK's global success and popularity...he copied OSO way of distributing film for a profit before its release...he is now hyping ghajni same way as OSO was done...if he wanted to make sensible cinema one need not hype it through ushers in multiplexes, giving media feed every other day abt the movie etc...which just goes to show aamir wants to make his film a hit every possible way and not just provide good cinema as u so stupidly claim...
Re: Re: Re: Watch momento instead
by varun on Dec 22, 2008 12:23 AM
dude doing a film on a national issue is bad or what? Then what would you call chak de india and swades? were they manipulated cinema. Get a life man, when srk celebrates his birthday in front of the media then nobody will say a word, but if aamir is doing what every other actor is doing that is promoting his movie everyone is acting as if he is commiting a crime. 99% of the people will say undoubtedly that aamir is way ahead of srk as an actor and one more thing he never said that ghajini is sensible cinema, from day 1 when he released the promos he has been stating that it is a hardcore commercial entertainer and completely different from his usual style of films which are sensible and serious. You guys just pick up the wrong signals becoz you can't see anything beyond srk.
considering his last film TZP i thought people would look forward to ghajini, but reading some of the comments here it's as if people have decided even before the release of the movie to run it down.
The problem I have with Sukanya is, even though her reviews and pithy and poignant, she is clearly the biggest Aamir fan in the world. You can see it from most of her columns, it is all about Aamir gushing. Seriously, Sukanya, have you never heard about a movie called Memento? Why watch the tamil original, watch Memento instead and then think about how shoody a copy Aamir is going to make of it and torture us all with that nostril-flaring, widened-eyes, deep-breathing antics. I cannot believe people are even looking forward to trash like Ghajini. I have seen the original, it just pales in comparison to Memento. The only good thing that will come out of Ghajini-2 is the same that came out of Ghajini-1. The birth of a new star - Asin.
Re: I hope Sukanya does not review Ghajini
by Harpreet Khurana on Dec 19, 2008 07:47 PM
So what if Sukanya's reviews are about Aamir gushing? At least it's a refreshing change from usual SRK gushing that is thrust upon us every day!
BTW, if people can 'tolerate' RNBDJ then why can't they watch Ghajini? People have every right to watch any film they want.
Re: Re: I hope Sukanya does not review Ghajini
by Balaji B on Dec 19, 2008 08:06 PM
So, obviously, like a lot other people, you do not like SRK-gushing either. Then, how could you tolerate Aamir-gushing if that is the case? What's good for the goose is good for the dander. I do not see a pattern in anyone else's reviews of SRK movies. Raja Sen, who is always blamed for SRK-gushing, gave bad reviews for Don, KANK and RNBDJ. But you can never ever expect Sukanya to give an honest opinion of even bad Aamir movies like Fanaa, you know. I mean, she gave 3 stars for a rubbish movie like Fanaa, imagine that !!
Re: I hope Sukanya does not review Ghajini
by nitish jayakumar on Dec 20, 2008 02:35 AM
Mr Balaji, Ghajini was never said to be a remake of Memento. It was just misconceptions by retards like urself that it was a remake. And the sentence "Ghajini pales in comparision to Memento". The only reason that Memento was watchable was thanks to the editor of the movie who himself felt the story was boring, and proposed an idea to the director to make it in the non linear format. If his idea wasnt put to use, Memento ki tho.... Face it, the acting was ordinary and irritating too. If they realy wanted to remake Memento in hindi, there are lot of wooden actors in Bollywood who generally walk around as if they have no idea where they are.
Look at each movie for itself and stop comparing it to others. If u really think like that, the whole world is copying stuff.. I dont see u writing about that. For all u know, u must b copying stuff from others. Get a life, and stop criticizing ppl publically.
Re: Re: I hope Sukanya does not review Ghajini
by Balaji B on Dec 20, 2008 02:47 AM
Well, you are correct. Ghajini is not a remake of Memento, it is just an indianized "copy" of that fabulous English film. I have seen the tamil original and it is no misconception Nitish, no matter how much Murugadass insists otherwise. And does it matter who proposed what to who? All that matters to me, the viewer, is the end product be worth my time. And while Memento was a serious study and prompted multiple viewings especially for the immense detailing of the timelines, Ghajini was a masala film straight out of the Rajiv Rai school of filmmaking.
If someone is going to give me a plagiarized product, why the heck should I not compare it with the work that it copies from. Maybe you do believe that is not a copy, but a mere "inspiration". He he. No saving you in that case.
"For all u know, u must b copying stuff from others." Err... you mean "For all I know" surely.. LOL.
Re: Re: Re: I hope Sukanya does not review Ghajini
by shaon islam on Dec 20, 2008 08:00 AM
all i can call is utter dishonest, simply because you do not respect an artiste of the caliber of aamir- the only- so to speak in bollywood today. no matter what you say or write, the fact remains that you can't digest his achievements and honesty with his profession that is so rare in this rotten time. Ghajini is only an excuse for you. Pity!
Re: Re: Re: I hope Sukanya does not review Ghajini
by shaon islam on Dec 20, 2008 08:00 AM
all i can call is utter dishonest, simply because you do not respect an artiste of the caliber of aamir- the only- so to speak in bollywood today. no matter what you say or write, the fact remains that you can't digest his achievements and honesty with his profession that is so rare in this rotten time. Ghajini is only an excuse for you. Pity!
Re: Re: Re: I hope Sukanya does not review Ghajini
by satya s on Dec 20, 2008 06:36 PM
yes there is no justification whatsoever to call it a copy...when the plot,scripts and the scenes are so different, you are insisting it is a copy. where is the logic in this ????
did you even understand the true plot of the english film? it is not a genuine story of revenge like the indianised versions,only seemingly so.
Re: Re: Re: Re: I hope Sukanya does not review Ghajini
by Balaji B on Dec 22, 2008 08:55 PM
Is it not obvious enough for everyone to see that the same film when made in India will sail over the top of most of our viewers and that is the ONLY reason they are sticking to a straight-forward revenge drama instead? Of course it is a copy, with just a slight alteration of the storyline.
SRK should retire and stop repeating the old movie remakes. SRK, try to make some different movies like Aamir. Ghajini will be a blockbuster, i have seen the Tamil movie starring Surya.
Re: Re: Aamir rocks
by Harpreet Khurana on Dec 19, 2008 08:12 PM
Don, Devdas and forthcoming Billu Barber are all remakes. So you should know who else is making remakes.
Music Big hit, Promos big hit, interviews big hit, curousity big hit, style big hit. This also before the release of the film. So wat will hapn when the film actually releases. Any Guess????...........The biggset Blockbuster of the year. A sure hit without any doubt. Go for hit on 25 Dec. It will be a paisa vasool movie. North, east, south ho ya west, Aamir is the best. He will rock the world. God bless his movie.
Re: Blockbuster
by Gopi Bhaiyya on Dec 19, 2008 06:04 PM
remember roop ki raani , choron ka raja , the magnum opus , much talked about at that time . and very recent yuvraj .. hype doesn,t sell a movie . i think xtreme violence in this movie will deter families away frm this movie ..we don,t have a action movie history . we like love , song ,dance, emotions, drama , et al
Re: Re: Re: Re: Blockbuster
by Harpreet Khurana on Dec 20, 2008 04:14 PM
You're right Kaushik! BTW, these romance fans should also know that Ghajini also has romance angle to it. Let them watch a hero jumping around like a Kangaroo on the roads, while singing praises of his loved one, while we look forward to the Ace's next masterpiece.
