amitabh is excellent work no doubut Nishabd is medicore at the core level of the movie..did any body seen joggers park on the same theame on so diginified way..wrapping product with s*x paper will not make u sell the product or make you and gr8 actor..He can do anything for money..guys just don't waste your time to praise. guys wake up there is world out of bollywood too.
There was no critism on film Jogger's Park where Victor Banarjee shown as a judge falls in to love of young girl. Movie just realesed few years back and shown on TV many times. There was no critism but praise for Shammi Kapoor's role in Professor when old woman falls in love with young boy. Movie was infact super hit. When Hemamalini was asked in Apki Adalat whether she would like to do reverse of Nishabdh she too agreed.
RE:Amitabh unnecessarily targetted.
by Milind Joshi on Mar 12, 2007 03:02 PM
Such "Hue and Cry" is only because the Film's Actor is Amitabh and Director is RGV. If some other Actor would have been in place, it would have been declared as a Flop and Mad Concept !!!
RE:Amitabh unnecessarily targetted.
by beena on Mar 12, 2007 02:53 PM
He is not unnecessarily targetted in Joggers Park the issue was handled well, in Nishabd its more titllation and semi nude poses and more provocative no substance only skin show
RE:RE:Amitabh unnecessarily targetted.
by Indian on Mar 12, 2007 02:55 PM
true I think puranik is not seen joggers park..what a movie it was without taking the help of nudity its presented the subject so well..victor was more dignified old man.
RE:Amitabh unnecessarily targetted.
by megharaj rajeev on Mar 12, 2007 03:34 PM
Beauty lies in the eyes of the beholder. For me the movie was amazing without tickling me anywhere
Present day Amitabh is just like any other scrap actor.Only some fools think he is Badshah of Bollywood.He does every thing for commercial reasons.Otherwise how could an actor do a film like NIshabd in a generally conservative sub-continent.If he wants to command respect among masses he HAS to respect their SENTIMENTS.As he has fallen so low to act in a film where he falls in LOVE with 18 year daughter of his friend he has only polluted the mind of people & I am afraid many people will go one step further.I request the readers not to make GOD,S out of these Demons.
RE:Amitabh lost glory
by Nagaraj Agasthya on Mar 12, 2007 03:03 PM
why do you obligate stars to follow the sentiments and all. He's an actor and he does different roles. If you can't watch the movie, forget it.
RE:Amitabh lost glory
by deepak kumar on Mar 12, 2007 03:21 PM
he has make this mistake,how he done all of this,but u can't say him a scrap actor,really he is superstar till now
In an interview to a news channel Abhishek said"there was no actor like my dad and even in future where won't be any".Amitabh is a great actor totally agreed but saying he is the greatest on this earth is a bit too much.There are so many greats in hollywood , in India and the rest of the world .There are so many greats.Ajay devgan,Nana patekar,Manoj bajpai,Pankaj kapoor,Sanjeev kumar,Kamal hassan,Robert de niro,Ben kinsley,Mel gibson etc .Its a long list.
RE:Mile sur mera tumhara tho sur bane hamara(entire family singing the same song)
by Pragya Tripathi on Mar 12, 2007 03:06 PM
May be you didn't notice that it has been some tradition in the film industry... all the actors name their parents, children or any such relative present in the indutry as the best one on this earth etc etc... karisma to kareena kareena to karisma... sunny to dharmendra... esha to hema... an on an on... each and every actor who has a relative in the industry... surely does it...
RE:RE:Mile sur mera tumhara tho sur bane hamara(entire family singing the same song)
by Illur Iqbal on Mar 12, 2007 06:46 PM
Shahrukh, Aamir, Saif Salman ...Etc.,
RE:liar amitabh
by prakash haranahalli on Mar 12, 2007 03:24 PM
Well, all the discussion about Amitabh in Nishabd are targetting Amitabh at his personal level. Growup guys, think twice before writing something. He is just an actor. See his work from the acting point of view not the content. **** also think, what will be your views at his age.
RE:RE:liar amitabh
by trivandrum padmanabhan on Mar 12, 2007 03:07 PM
Dear friends, Amitabh is an exemplary performing artist of our era.Plesa view his work artistically and let our personal aspersions are avoided.
It is a very well made film.Jiya is great, particularly so while working opposite Big B. Photography and camera treatment in pale shades is excellent. I felt that Amitabh's loneliness and his justification for sudden infatuation with Jiya has not been clearly brought out.His last monologue could have done more justice to bring out his pathos. RGV has made a very clean film an avoided vulgarity. It is immaterial wheather people accepted or rejected his film. I will consider Black as Big B's All time best acting..
RE:Nishabd
by purple on Mar 12, 2007 02:50 PM
You are right especially showing her legs all the time.What an acting or should i say great skin show,no NRI should behave in such a manner
Mr. Bachchan you are thinking that whatever you do people will will appriciate.
But people are not so fool as you are thinking. Public will always shows the way to overhyped stars like you when you are dancing with a girl younger than your daughter.
Now get retire asap, we are bored to see you everywhere.
RE:Mr. Bachchan Public is not fool
by sandeep nahar on Mar 13, 2007 05:28 AM
Mr Rajesh I ve no idea about others but from your lines which u ve written about AB one can clearly judge ur mind.FOOL. and....why should he retire? Only bcoz you are bored........If u r so bored don't watch his movies. simple as that. YOU CAN'T ASK YOUR PARENTS TO GO TO RETIREMENT HOME SIMPLY B COZ YOU ARE BORED TO SEE THEM DAY AND NIGHT. That's not fair. Is n it?
RE:Mr. Bachchan Public is not fool
by Mahendra Mishra on Mar 12, 2007 03:09 PM
He never said or believed ever such thing.. It only people who create an issue out of their minds. No actors expect that all his movies to be a box office hit or audience will like it. In fact They are not fool and Big B is not at all. By Mahen
RE:RE:Mr. Bachchan Public is not fool
by Milind Joshi on Mar 12, 2007 03:13 PM
Thats Quite Logical, Mahen!!! Good reply Bro!!! Atleast in all these Reply 2 Reply, someone spoke something of some sense !!!
please tell amitabh, the nishabd kind of Ideas are not healthy for any society. if you encourage these stories, what is the future of 18 year old girl who is going to settle for 60 year old man, widow at early age or again will attract towards new yound man.
amitabh is responsible civilian & he should himself discourage appearing this kind as an example.
look past the marriage of Laxmi bai (14 Year) with 56 year old Raja of Jhansi/ do you support this difference?
if amitabhs own daughter/ Grand daughter woudl go this way?
RE:'Why would people target me
by sumit kain on Mar 12, 2007 02:59 PM
Well, incase u forgot, its a film and Amitabh played a fictional character; not himself. U cant accuse him of anything immoral.You may hv a valid point/reasoning on a particular issue but at the end of the day, its an artiste's job to portray a character. A villain, in the real life doesn't plant bombs, rapes women or takes innocent lives.
Bear in mind tht these r just stories and one's personal character is nt to be infused with it. Show sm maturity and understanding.
