RE:CLASSIC WAR MOVIES
by lovely purohit on Mar 09, 2007 09:35 PM
Well I think .. we r indians and we shuld talk abt indian movies rather than english movies. Its about Indo-pak war not just war movies. tell me some Indian Classics of war movies if u can?
WE R SO STUPID,WE TOOK CONTROL OF PAKISTAN BUT LEFT THAT PLACE COZ USA FORCED US TO LEAVE THAT PLACE AND WE DIDNT EVEN BOTHER TO HUNT FOR OUR SOLDIERS AT THAT TIME. WE HAVE NO GUTS TO FIGHT PAKISTAN SO WE ALWAYS TALK ABOUT PEACE PROCESS..STOP ALL THIS BULL SHIT AND START A PIECES PROCESS AND BREAK THAT COUNTRY INTO PIECES. I FULLY SUPPORT BAL THACKERY AND HIS IDEAS COZ THESE PEOPLE CAN NEVER UNDERSTAND PEACE. PAKISTAN IS THE MOST UNSTABLE COUNTRY IN THE WORLD AS THEY NEVER COULD FORM A STABLE SITUATION IN THIER COUNTRY AND THEY NEVER WILL..WHO EVER BECOMES THE PRESIDENT OF PRIME MINISTER EITHER RESIGNES OR IS ASSASSINATED AND ONE DAY SAME THING WILL HAPPEN TO MUSHARAFF BUT STILL PAKISTAN WILL CONTINUE TO TROUBLE INDIA AS WE ARE PEOPLE OF GANDHI WHO BELEIVE IN NON VIOLENCE. THAK GOD GANDHI WAS NOT PRACTICING SUCH METHODS AGAINT GERMANS OR CHINESE ELSE HE WOULD HAVE BEEN CRUSHED LONG TIME BACK...STOP MAKING SUCH STUPID MOVIES INSTEAD MAKE A MOVIE ON AMERICAN HISTORY OR VIETNAM. SUCH MOVIES SHOW HOW THOSE PEOPLE FOUGHT AND GOT THIER RIGHTS INSTEAD OF SHOING COWARDICE OF INDIA
RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by shanmuga subramanian on Mar 09, 2007 08:05 PM
you see Pakistan was a part of India 60 years before and I say at some point from now again Pakistan would unite with India
like Vietnam and Germany
India was divided just like Germany as the powers do not want to create another hitler
RE:RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by Rohit on Mar 11, 2007 11:29 AM
WHAT ON EARTH ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT?
The Partitions of Germany and Vietnam were done against the wishes of both countries. The people of both countries always longed for reunification.
Does even someone with your LIMITED knowledge of history believe that the people of Pakistan didn%u2019t want to partition India, and now want reunite with India? Did Bangladesh try to reunite with India in 1971?
RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by pavan porje on Mar 09, 2007 07:53 PM
Sorry..but who every has written this please leave India now & got to US & Kiss thier a**
RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by test on Mar 09, 2007 05:14 PM
JUST FOR 2 SOLDIERS ISRAIL RUINED LEBANON AND WE STUPID INDIANS DIDNT CARE FOR THOSE SOLDIERS..SHAME ON THIS NATION. BAPU ALL WHAT U DID IS GOING IN DUSTBIN
RE:RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by Suneet Sancheti on Mar 09, 2007 06:11 PM
Its not matter of 2 soldiers dear!!! Comparing India with Israel is easy... But compare palestine with Pakistan. Pakistan has army 10 times that of palestine. Pakistan has got much advanced air crafts serving their air force and the most important thing, Pakistaan is N-powered country. If India decides to attack Pakistaan chances are we'll win the war in a month or so, but It can not be neglected that, they are nuclear weapons, that they will definitely use on us resulting in mass destruction. If Israel had Pakistan as his nemesis, I bet they also wouldn't have dared to go that further. Punch bags dont hit back dear...
RE:RE:RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by dinesh b daga on Mar 09, 2007 07:06 PM
Dear Mr, Pakistan would not have allowed to such situation as it is of now and would not have allowed america to support Pak as is done for reasons more known to everybody.
RE:RE:RE:RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by Rohit on Mar 11, 2007 11:31 AM
With your Std II level English I think you are trying to say that India should have stopped America from supporting Pakistan in the early 1950's?
HOW exactly could PM Nehru's govt have done this? Please try to respond in English.
RE:RE:RE:RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by dinesh b daga on Mar 09, 2007 07:07 PM
sorry ! Pakistan would not have been allowed to reach such a state by america and israel, had that been problem for Israel and America
RE:RE:RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by Amit Pathak on Mar 09, 2007 08:10 PM
Bahut accha .....to darr ke haatho me churiaan pehen lo......wait karte karte aj wo chooha pakistaan sheer ban gaya aur hum indians geedad ke geedad hi rahe....Ladna hi bhool gae....Ab humesha darte rehna unke nuclear weapon se...
RE:RE:RE:RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by ABHRAJIT CHATTERJEE on Mar 09, 2007 09:34 PM
have you ever held a gun in your hand....if everyting was that easy then Israel and palestine problem would have been solved many years back....
RE:RE:RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by Amit Pathak on Mar 09, 2007 08:09 PM
Bahut accha .....to darr ke haatho me churiaan pehen lo......wait karte karte aj wo chooha pakistaan sheer ban gaya aur hum indians geedad ke geedad hi rahe....Ladna hi bhool gae....Ab humesha darte rehna unke nuclear weapon se...
RE:RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by smruti parida on Mar 09, 2007 05:45 PM
This is because that poor J.Nehru wanted to get nominated for noble prize (there was nomination at that time). He thought if he takes the matter to UN then he%uFFFDll get huge accolade but it happened in other way. Because of the lack of vision on the part of that politician we're now paying the price and so many boodbath in Kashmir....The Culprit
RE:RE:RE:RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by venkat raman on Mar 10, 2007 03:40 PM
Mr. Mihir,
At least that would have saved us from the politicians who are now the onwers of our disicions, you cannot decide how to live and do the things u elect some illitrates and goondas to govern on our minds.The core issue we have been faceing since independence is Kashmir, this would have never happened had they took correct messures and not greedy ambitions. Peace is better then war bt not at the cost of selfrespect.
RE:RE:RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by ruchita sharma on Mar 09, 2007 11:28 PM
Its our bad fate only that after Mr JAWAHAR Lal Nehru,his Family tree has never lost is greenish and they have ruled our country directly or indirectly till today.and we are no where....without any vision.I am not a political man but yeah its true they have ruined our country.
RE:RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by Rocky on Mar 09, 2007 05:51 PM
First of all you have to stop talking like a 10 year old kid. We are not as advanced like Israel is as compared to middle east countries. Therefore, India should not go on an allout war with Pakistan at this point of time. I understand your frustration as an Indian that we could not destroy Pakistan completely in wars. You have to put the blame solely on our Politicians since they are the ones who let down the Indian Army on all occasions. Please give respect to those who have died for us and our Country alike.
RE:RE:RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by test on Mar 11, 2007 10:30 AM
you dumb guy.. was vietnam advanced?/ still they managed to kick usa out..read the history then talk.. You indians talk two things. Gandhi didnt have any weapon then how on earth people say he kicked out Brits..?? I beleive INDIA IS A PUSSY CAT COUNTRY
RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by venkat raman on Mar 10, 2007 04:14 PM
Please stop creeping about American History or Vietnam, we also got our independence due to our brave soilders they may not have dressed up in uniforms bt least they fought for us don't forget the subhash chandra boses,azads,bhagatsinghs,rajgurus,sukhdevs,subramaniambhartis,and many more like them who have been our unsung heroes. It is jst our textbooks which tells us about our peace loveing leaders n their efforts but largely ignored the warriors. We own our independence to them. As far as Pakistan is considered we can get them anytime, but war only kills innocent people ask the soilders at front even they have their families who egarly wait for their return. Let us forget what happened in the past and look for future and first of all we need to gather courage and pick up the arms to finish the internal enemy who is more tyhretening and dangerous then the pakis. Corruption and Goondasim at every level first finish that and then see where we stand America will be left far behind as we Indians are the best in every aspect comnpared to any TOM Dick or Harry in the world. Proud to be an Indian
RE:RE:RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by ABHRAJIT CHATTERJEE on Mar 11, 2007 11:57 AM
Mr.English,kindly go back to the pages of history and you will find that the movement taken by Bose,Azad,Bhagat Singh and many others of this kind carried a lot of significance.You can't say that just because they died in the middle of the battle of independence they are of no value.There movement had played a vital role in igniting the passion of freedom and I am not saying this,these things have been said by researchers and historians. Now its up to you, whether you want to question them or not. It is because of all these FREEDOM FIGHTERS that people like you talk all rubbish sitting before the net.Show some respect to these people they gave there life for people like you.
RE:RE:RE:RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by Rohit on Mar 12, 2007 02:00 AM
Don't equate Bhagat Singh with Bose. Unlike Bhagat Singh, Bose's 4000 soldiers didn't die in battle, most of them starved to death in the jungle. BRILLIANT leadership! That must have scared the English into leaving.
What kind of 'leader' goes CRAWLING to a homicidal monster like Hitler? Or did your Commie teachers in Calcutta not tell you that Bose spent ONE YEAR in Germany waiting for an audience with the Fuhrer?
Even if the Japs had won do you think they would have simply handed India to Bose? Did Bose not know of unspeakable Jap atrocities on the natives in Malaysia, China, Korea, the Philippines and Indonesia? His megalomaniacal desire for power so great that he didn't care what the Japs would do the people of India as long as he could become Fuhrer of India.
RE:RE:RE:RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by Rohit on Mar 12, 2007 10:37 PM
Bose's soldiers died of STARVATION in the jungle without fighting. Bose achieved NOTHING
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by on Mar 13, 2007 12:53 PM
"How EAXCTLY did Bose, Azad, Bhagat Singh, et al get India her Independence?" it was u who first compared bose with bhagat singh,as per ur first mail.Mr.Chatterjee is right in pointing out the fact that that every freedom struggle has its own relevance.for ur kind information bose has asked for unconditional militaty , he was aware of the fact that japs may take control.do u think all those who followed him were fools ,for ur information Mr.BOSE had an army not of a couple of soilders but many and also from different sects and regions.Get ur history right Mr.Rohit.Bose didn't fought for bengal but for the country.
RE:RE:RE:RE:INDIA IS A COWARD COUNTRY
by Simren Rajput on Mar 11, 2007 07:14 PM
chatterjee sahaad, Totally agreed with you, I slute to our BRAVE INDIAN SOLDIERS.
yess t movie is a good one......showing the realities faced by a soldier....... but i shud ask the reviewer a qn? tat a movie in malayalam keertichakra (showed the commando operations so superbly with out reducing the realistic feeling than any other film )was given a poor raring why?REMEMBER ONLY REDIFF HAS GIVEN IT POOR RATING ???? IS IT JUST BECAUSE ITS A MALLU MOVIE?
RE:t film 1971
by Shailendra Singh on Mar 09, 2007 05:27 PM
Dear Mr. Krishnakumar Please Grow Up.....and rise above all this REGIONALISM. YOu have been behaving like a Local Politician who only things of My family, my village, my state. Rise above all this and think for the Nation as a whole......
RE:RE:t film 1971
by samir varier on Mar 10, 2007 01:42 PM
Mr Singh I support Mr Krishnakumar in his statments. The justification is that though IIFA awards are meant for Indian films, why is it that only Hindi Movies,( their Heroes and Heroines) as compared to regional movie actors and actresses are not even invited for the show and drama abroad. Mr Mammooty( a famed and national awards winner- for those who dont know) was right in calling it a Hindi award function.People who admire regional films are known to reciprocate their feelings as they view a film due to its story line , screenplay , cinematography etc and not due to the SO CALLED HEROES and HEROINES. Hindi films dont have actors, barring a few like Naseeruddin, Amitabh, Sanjeev Kumar, Guru Dutt etc.
RE:RE:t film 1971
by Kashyap .M on Mar 09, 2007 06:15 PM
Dear Mr.Singh, Mr.Kumar is pointing to the double standards in measuring the film of a certain language.He is as proud as you to be an Indian.He is also proud of Malayalam which is an Indian language for your information,and loving something Indian does not make a person anti-Indian.You should respect the diversity in this country in terms of other states and its languages,not just use words like REGIONALISM and stuff......
Till date I have not seen any Good Indian war movie.. We fought very few wars in History but we have no good stuff around.Its a shame our soldiers are still in captive as in 1971 our troups had entered pakistan and we gave away their land out of good will. Till date no politician has cared to get those soldiers back to India. We are not able to fight a tiny Pakistan and we boast of being a nuclear power. AND AM SURE THIS MOVIE IS ALL CRAP AND REDIFF GIVING STARS TO ANY CRAPPY MOVIE IS WELL KNOWN
I had promised myself that I'd never see a Hindi War Movie again. (This was after I saw LOC: JP Dutta's epic disaster about the Kargil war)
I believe a War movie should be just that..A War Movie. Period.
Adding songs and sobbing housewives and mothers tend to dilute the intensity of the story in such cases. And it would be precisely for this reason that I would give 1971 a try.
My heartfelt support to young film makers like Amrit Sagar.
RE:1971
by Deepak Yadav on Mar 09, 2007 04:49 PM
Dear Sir,
When you go and see such movies there is nothing to enjoy but a tribute that you can give to our fallen heroes.
Go and read about the Battle of Chushul or Battle of Basantar or Battle of Saragarhi or about 2nd Lt. Arun Kheterpal or Captain Vikram Batra or Captain Anuj Nayyar and other fallen heroes, they all are inspiration to millions.
They'd promised their families they'd come back soon. They more than kept their word. Went as mere men. Came back as heroes. In coffins.
RE:RE:1971
by Adarned Fungus on Mar 09, 2007 05:07 PM
Dear Deepak, I think there is a confusion here. By no means I'm taking away anything from the heroes that u've mentioned. I was talking about the way certain director's tend to get carried away by their own ego and ultimately ends up making a mess like LOC.
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:1971
by vinay jacob on Mar 11, 2007 12:32 AM
Hi guys. Deepak made a pertinent point and got that across absolutely clearly. Wonder how some people lose the plot in the discussion!! Same feelings for the services here man. The movie is just the means to the end.Not seen it yet, but I can feel it. Vinay Jacob.
RE:RE:1971
by test on Mar 09, 2007 04:54 PM
You dumb head. India has no sense in making war movies. you watch the following movies PLATOON SAVING PRIVATE RYAN FULL METAL JACKET FLY BOYS BORN ON THE FOURTH OF JULY GARDENS OF STONE I KNOW MUCH MORE BUT THIS IS ENOUGH FOR a person like u
RE:RE:RE:1971
by Deepak Yadav on Mar 09, 2007 05:10 PM
When you are using such indecent words like "dumb head" and your name "test" reflects two things about you, first 100% you are a rich brat with no manners and also no self respect for your name.A man who can't write his name, I don't expect him to defend his country.
Mr. Test go to your club and remain there in arms of your girlfriends. Battlefield or war movies or Army fallen heroes are not for you.
RE:RE:RE:1971
by Deepak Yadav on Mar 09, 2007 05:01 PM
Go through my first line "When you go and see such movies there is nothing to enjoy but a tribute that you can give to our fallen heroes."
There is no argument on if our movies are inferior or superior to American war movies.
Really looking forward to see the movie.after a very long time,after lakshya a movie of such caliber we might witness. may not have big star casts but i like it that way.it maintains the movie theme and not the star's style. kudos for the movie and the director.
