This movie it not bad as described in the review. The reviewer attempted this effort with some biased approach and misleading the people who actually trusts rediff. I've seen the movie and it really differnt than any other War kind of movie..go fot it. dont listent to this review.
This is Very Good and family entertainer movie....all are acted very well accept Tanisha, I think she will take time to learn some acting. Anyway movie is totaly diffrent and subject is new, otherwise now a days sex battle is going on box office, ie: Sheesha, Fun, Hawas etc. Thanks Mani Shankar for producing such movie.
Gosh!! How can anybody tolerate this movie. It portrays the guys as idiotic, stupid and childsih.
- What the movie shows in uniform are boys NOT MEN. - Does anybody know what insubordination is? or what it can result? - One cannot just land the copper whereever he wants, nor leave his position in the field in conflict with orders. -BSF is made to look like bodygaurds in Bengal. BSF should sue the director for the portrayal.. I know its insane, but the movie is doubly insane.
If I start punching holes in the storyline, movie would be a black hole. There are only 2/3 instances where I liked the dialogue writer's work. Otherwise, this is load of crap.
If I compare it with the making of movies like Swades/Lakshya, I wish this never even released.
by Srikanth Nalla on May 09, 2005 05:41 PM
I really dont like Tanisha in this movie. Its really painful to watch her. She is neither glamorous (forget glamorous, she is fat like a cow) nor a good actress. And I am really sad that we got so less of Nandana Sen who is both beautiful and a very good actress. She is really amazing in Black too.
by Srikanth Nalla on Apr 23, 2005 04:42 PM
Yes. Infact this is the best war movie ever made in India so far. I am sick and tired of movies like Border and LOC which depict soldiers as homesick singers and stupids who give away their lives without any thought. Even though we Indias have a still long way to go before making hard hittin war movies like Saving Private Ryan I am sure that this a right step in the right direction to making good movies.
I was totally amazed when I went through the review how can people write like this.. it was really a great movie.. my first impression about this movie was a total bukwass since Manishankar has directed this movie.. his previous two movie were total crap.. but now he has learnt how to direct.. Ajay has done a good job.. I liked him the best.. Please people start liking a movie which has substance rather than just phrasing movies like main ho Na and Veer-Zara
This is excellent movie , I completely disagree with the Review, Performance of Both main leades are best. Techincally film is excellent.Ajay as usual best, Bobby also improves lot.Every Indian must see this movie