Discussion Board

Sholay & Lagaan: India''s Best?


Total 37 messages Pages < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4   Older >
surekha tenneti venugopal
India's 10 best
by surekha tenneti venugopal on Jun 05, 2005 09:09 AM

Sholay, Lagaan, Mother India, Pather Panchali, Yes.

But, for simple, heartwarming films, I will add-

Sujata (Dir: Bimal Roy; cast:Nutan, Sunil Dutt),
Seema (Dir: Amiya Chakrobarty, Cast:Balraj Sahni, Nutan)
Boot Polish (Dir: Raj kapoor; cast: David, Ratan Kumar, Baby Naaz) ?

Also, for sheer rivetting cinema, there is
Deewar with Amitabh bachchan

I would bring up the rear with Dilip Kumar's Gunga Jamuna, a very realistically made film, and
Lamhe (Anil Kapoor, Sridevi) an enjoyable, but sensitive film.

Surekha Tenneti Venugopal
Hyderabad


    Forward  |  Report abuse
Vimal Kumar
Change the title as BEST NORTH INDIAN FILMS!!!!
by Vimal Kumar on Jun 04, 2005 07:15 PM

Hi,

It is very demoralising to see only North Indian directors and films being choosen for the Best Indian Films list.

For your info it is "Nayagan", a south indian film which made it to list and it is the only film which was declared as classic and the almost all the Crew members are still ALIVE....

There are some south indian films which are miles ahead in quality and content.The National awards is totally dominated by Malayalam and Tamil films for a very long time.These films are very much original and does not derive inspiration from Western Films.

Can a site like Rediff ignore it? Or Change the title as BEST NORTH INDIAN FILMS...

With Disgust,
Vimal

    Forward  |  Report abuse
debendra choudhary
about best film
by debendra choudhary on Jun 04, 2005 10:01 AM

dear,

in my view mother india & sholay is the best film of indian cinema..


    Forward  |  Report abuse
Pavan
India's best
by Pavan on Jun 04, 2005 09:48 AM

My top 10 movies of all time would be:

1. Do Aankhen Baarah Haat (Shantaram's)
2. Sholay
3. Hum Aapke hain Koun
4. Amrapaali
5. Lagaan
6. Mother India
7. Moghle Aazam
8. MunnaBhai MBBS
9. Baazighar
10.Anand

It is surprising how Shantaram's Do Aankhen Baarah Haat is missing from everyone's list.
Pavan

    Forward  |  Report abuse
vamsi
what about the other languages????
by vamsi on Jun 04, 2005 07:18 AM

So does this mean that the films from other movies are no where near the top????
these hindi film makers think inside the well..

people hindi isnt the only language!!! there r nearly 25other languages!! and of which the south indian films rank much above their hindi ones!!!



    Forward  |  Report abuse
Debasis Sen
Ghai's top 10
by Debasis Sen on Jun 04, 2005 07:12 AM

Will kindly tell ghai taht Indian cinema is not equal to the stupid bollywood masala stuff. there have been genius people like ray who made some masterpieces even 1% artisitic quality of such would not be achieved ever by ghai. by the way, has he ever heard of ray, ghatak?

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Reji Nair
Best films
by Reji Nair on Jun 04, 2005 05:48 AM  | Hide replies

Well, I am surprised as to no one speaks about the movies made by Raj kapoor.
Those were the movies which showed what the future will be.
eg- Awara, Shree 420, Jis Desh Me Ganga Beheti Hai, Jaagte Raho.
I feel one should think over those films also.


    Forward  |  Report abuse
abc_xyz1
RE:Best films
by abc_xyz1 on Jun 22, 2005 05:24 AM
do u mean to say,

Bengali/Marathi films are more popular than South indian films ....even u guys look up to hindi movies for entertaiment ...



by the way, What do u know about Mohanlal? ...He is easily .. one of the top 3 indian actors of this generation ....You will accept a TOP 10 list from Ghai and vipul shah ...but not a TOP 10 list from malayalam/tamil ...grt !!!!!!!!

keep thinking like this ....may god bless u.....

   Forward   |   Report abuse
K. Shashi Kumar
vipul shash's list
by K. Shashi Kumar on Jun 04, 2005 04:42 AM  | Hide replies

Not only Hindi films are made in India,
When you consider India's best film. You should have considered films made from all parts of India.
I have seen almost all the ten films. But more better films than that.
Come down little to south, you will find 100 more films better and the best than this compilation.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
rahul
RE:vipul shash's list
by rahul on Jun 17, 2005 04:18 PM
Hello Mr Shashi
Same thing applies to u ...
Regional lang does not mean only Tamil/Malyalam/Kannad and Telgu..
There are other as well...
Vipul shaha's list has marathi and bengali movies ...
See the list provided by ur south (indian ?) superstart mohanlal ..has he mentioned in movie from bengali or marathi ? why he could not do so ?
It's high time for u guys to comeout of south shell and face the world ..




   Forward   |   Report abuse
Total 37 messages Pages: < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4   Older >
Write a message