Discussion Board

Mumbai Xpress in Tamil rocks!


Total 30 messages Pages < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3   Older >
Lal
Mumbai Xpress
by Lal on Apr 16, 2005 10:19 PM

An utter waste film by KamalHassan.
I lost my money thats is what i can say @this Moment..
Nothing else ....

    Forward  |  Report abuse
yogi
DOESN'T ROCK
by yogi on Apr 16, 2005 09:05 PM

I guess u slept quite a bit during the movie. else u couldn't 've found every dialogue comic. The movie was a let down comparing kamal's comic movies standards. The movie was sprinkled with comedy. yes, kids will njoy. Crazy mohan's dialogues are missed sorely. performances r good. manisha is just there, absolutely no role.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Indo
The review from Rediff not impressive
by Indo on Apr 16, 2005 06:30 PM

Hello,

We recently saw the film and movie is quite okay.
I think your review should not be your personal opinion. It should be common people's opinion .
There is alo another review from www.indiafm.com and that review is quite impressive ..
You better change your style of reviewing the good movies ( previosy you did the same mistake on Anbe Sivam )
FROM FM
*******
On the whole, MUMBAI XPRESS is a well-made entertainer that has ample moments to keep you in splits. At the box-office, the film should work with word of mouth. Its business at multiplexes of metros mainly will be excellent.

Rating:- * * *.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
sanil abraham
Mumbai Express
by sanil abraham on Apr 16, 2005 02:59 PM

Dear Warrier,
First u have to learn the basics before writing a film review. U have written classics somewhere. First, u should learn what is classic in film parlance. Then comes, Kamal the best comic actor in the country. He is one of the best actors in the nation and please dont dare to suggest him as a comic actor.
Read lot and see lot of films then write something.
Sanil

    Forward  |  Report abuse
sekkappan
Biased Review
by sekkappan on Apr 16, 2005 01:13 PM

Dear Sir,

I strongly believe that the review of Mumbai express Tamil is biased and in favour of Kamalhassan. Compare the recview of the tamil & hindi version of Mumbai xpress in your own website.

I strongly feel the Hindi version review is more appropriate for both the Hindi and tamil versions.

For any normal viewer (non fan of both of Kamal & Rajni)Chandramuki is far better than Mumbai express and not the other way round as your review suggests.

Regards
Sekkappan - Chennai

    Forward  |  Report abuse
R.Sriram
biased review
by R.Sriram on Apr 16, 2005 11:21 AM

These reviewers are biased. Just the mention of the name Kamal makes them to review the film in his favour. One other guy in this group is Madan. Who boasted alot about Alavandan, which is a utter flop. But most times people reject him in tamil nadu, because he only boasts and do not do justise to his name tag.

Warrier mentioned the story is original. I heard, people who saw the movie, still wondering what the story is. Kamal is good in choosing good technicians, but when it comes to acting or chosing a story, he is a copy cat. Yet to see a original film(except thevar magan and maganadhi) from him. Everything is a remake of some hindi or english film. And his acting/mannerism are the same after Nayagan. I find only kamal in all his films and not the charachter. Unlike Surya or Vikram who actually potrays the charachter.

Warrier talked about Goundamani/Senthil. They cater to all the masses, unlike Kamal who caters only to middle and upper middle class.

Better luck next time kamal. Try to live upto your expectations. You are yet to give a good film. And that too original.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
KV
Sick Review
by KV on Apr 16, 2005 08:24 AM

Sidhu Warrier needs to re-look Chandramukhi ('CM')...I cannot believe the comment made that it is a "terrible" movie..!!..Whats so terrible??..Can Sidhu be more elaborate? So what if its a copy of the Malayalam movie..so many movies are dubbed and re-made..is there anything wrong with it?

I take the point that Kamal is indeed one of the best actors the nation has produced...no doubt about it!..he is a classy actor and many a time produces good films..all south indian actors even Rajini acknowledges that!.

I completely disagree that CM is a terrible movie..just look at the mass hysteria and the jubiliant mood that is floating around in TamilNadu, USA, Japan, Dubai, GCC Countries, Srilanka, Singapore, Malaysia, UK and Indonesia...!!...People have declared it a SUPER HIT and say that is much better than Baba!..Its is different role that Rajini has played, which is a positive sign in itself..

Sidhu..please stop your crap All comments about CM!..Looks like you are tired after watching CM and have nothing better to say!..The public is not a foool to believe in your stupid comments about CM..If you cannot appreciate certain things better DO NOT COMMENT!!

KV


    Forward  |  Report abuse
Valekumar Krishnan
rajini rocks
by Valekumar Krishnan on Apr 16, 2005 05:45 AM

come on please.guess it's just people like you and your cool bunch of engineers who sat around you who would enjoy kamal's comedy movies more than rajinikanth's movies.i would agree if you were talkin' about a hey ram or a nayagan.but please not bout a lame movie like mumbai express.i say this for myself and for the millions of ardent "ordinary" tamil fans that when it comes to mass appeal and pure screen presence kamal,the big B or even al pacino are just nothing.you hear me.thalaivar vaazhga.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 30 messages Pages: < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3   Older >
Write a message