hi, this is anupama from dharwad. i watched ur program on aamir khan and found it very good,a never before interview. aamir is the finest actor of india,who doesn't work for money .if he would've gone the shahrukh way,promoting himself unlimitedely ,dancing at award funtions,weddings,aamir would have crossed shahrukh. i deeply admire him for his sincerity and his not being greedy after money.i think he is on par with any of the top hollywood actors.
RE:comments on aamir interview
by Raj on Apr 08, 2005 07:02 AM
I quite agree with you Anupama. Aamir is one of the finest actors in India at par with Kamal Hasan. I am also from Dharwad and at present settled in Australia. I was thrilled to hear the name of Dharwad, which is like heaven for me
RE:comments on aamir interview
by Jitendra Sharma on Apr 14, 2005 11:23 AM
I Thiink Aamir is most over rated and over confident person in the film industry .He has no right to comment on any body' performance and when he talks about King Khan of Bollywood one should laugh it off.Is he so perfect ???? He has maintained his stategy and works like a snail in 20-50 takes for a scene .Aamir can't match the spontaneity or energy of shahrukh and yes aamir can't dance at ward functions as shahrukh links very easily with every body .and has more mass appeal . Aamir has forgotten his performance in Mela or what ??
RE:comments on aamir interview
by Manny on Apr 06, 2005 12:34 AM
Very well said i totally agree with you...srk is promoting himself and selling himself very cheap now days pepole are much more educated and wiser they knows everything happening..Amir is the best he is the one fine actor in bollywood.. i'm tired and fed up with srk's cheap and repeated movies he is disgusting..well i cant comment on Amir's interview..i didnt watch it, but i must say srk did look pathetic in Devdas. Manny from Toronto
i don't understand y aamir is being asked abt wat he thinks abt sanjay leela bhansali's Devdas now after 2 yrs. its been aclaimed world over & also a commercial hit.and i think aamir has no business commenting on shah rukh's performance.he's neither dilip kumar nor amitabh bachan.SRK has proved himself.Aamir doesn't belive in our country's awards but he is ready to lobby for Oscars.i had a really high regard for him, but his opinions abt others is really fake.& also i feel the media has no other work other than putting one person against the other.& this questions coming from shekhar gupta is really absurd.i think success got onto aamir & he thinks he's the best.but the audience know better than him.or maybe he thinks people know nothing.
RE:Devdas
by mayank on Apr 06, 2005 04:30 PM
shreya, you're damn right. first of all, this was a stupid thing to ask aamir. and even if asked, aamir should have been decent enough not to speak his mind.
this is just as crazy as shatrughan sinha once saying that he feels he's a better actor than amitabh bachchan, but amithabh is more popular because he scores over him (shatru) in looks department. shatru may have spoken his mind, but he ended up making a fool of himself. and that's what aamir is doing here. i am not hinting at a direct analogy but actors of such high repute like aamir should'nt go on saying anything they want.
I don't think there can be any match against the astonshing performance of SRK.He was superb in that movie.. I also agree with Aamir that he would have the same role differently!!! but he can never look real devdas as srk looks in the movie..
hi there today i saw interview of amir khan , he was quite right , i am talking about his view about sharukhan , he is great personal , sharukh khan was nothing he just overracted artist , all knows indian audieance is hopeless , most of them are fool , amir khan is great artist --thank you
RE:amir khan
by nupur on Apr 04, 2005 06:34 PM
This is apalling...asking aamir about SRK's performance in Devdas..and his answer that he would done it differently just proves his arrogance and vanity! Devdas isn't my favourite film either but kudos to SRK who like a thorough professional did exactly what he was asked to do unlike Aamir who is famous(infamous) for his interfering with the directors work. The director of the film visualises a concept and the actors just do what they are asked to do. Aamir should turn a director first and then comment on how a movie should be made. For Lagaan too, it was just his production and it was ashutosh gowarikar whose script and direction made Lagaan what it is and not Aamirs acting prowess.
RE:amir khan
by mayank on Apr 06, 2005 09:40 AM
thanks vikram pratap singh, u told what i (a typical hindi film audience) am worth of. and i'm sure u rave about star treks and mindless matrix movies. because western audience is intelligent and indians are fools. we only know dancing around trees, revenge stories, seperated at birth plots, amiri garibi conflicts. we don't have any sense of aesthetics, characterizations, visual flair, sound, editing, etc etc. we don't know what to appreciate and what not!!
i seriously would like to ask rediff guys don't you read a message to approve it for posting. i think if u obliged Mr. vikram pratap singh, the next worst thing would be to post a message full of swear words.
I would like to say that since Mr.Aamir Khan attends to each every detail of film-making his forthcoming films like The Rising,Rang De Basanti will be worth watching not once but quite a few times. I pray to God that he receives all the awards post the release of his fortcoming films
