Discussion Board

Zameen: The review


Total 98 messages Pages    <<  < Newer  | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9   Older >
sarfaraz
comment
by sarfaraz on Sep 27, 2003 07:41 PM

plz improve the quality matter of the review

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Victor
I Agree..
by Victor on Sep 27, 2003 07:34 PM

About bias against abhishek.. i have one thing to add that no other trade magazine or website has declared KNK a flop, but rediff was first to declare it a flop on the first monday of its release, although collections are still steady and will turn to be an average or commission earner in most teritorries. I dont feel like commenting on Zameen review because the Box office collections will tell everything.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
indrajeet
zameen review
by indrajeet on Sep 27, 2003 07:33 PM

I am sorry to say that review of zameen is useless.

A brillently made movie is put to bad reviews.Ajays-abhisheks acting is superlative .This type of coments

will keep people

distance from the theaters.After a long time a well made war movie, which will be a super hit.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
rahul
sorrr dear ''critic'' but u are wrong
by rahul on Sep 27, 2003 05:59 PM

Abhishek Bachchan is brilliant in the movie and i dont see any reason why the writer has said all this crap about him in the review. The movie on the whole is slick and cool. TAKE SOME LESSONS FROM TARAN ADARSH. I think he knows how to review a movie in a proper way without any biases and rediff should employ people who don't have to blast every hindi movie. Sorry but U are wrong dear so called "critic".

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Anis
MY open challenge to Priya
by Anis on Sep 27, 2003 05:53 PM  | Hide replies

Hi Priya, I rate your review note more than a school kid . after watching the movie
I have come to the conclusion you only like Romantic and some boring family
Drama. Do you have any idea of action movies. Just revise your funny review.
1)first of all you told movie is slow pace in second half and you never gave
any due credit to extremely talented Rohit shetty. But script writer
is ok may be he was from rediff. Now just tell me. How can a movie be slow paced if screen play is very good?
2)in fact you not only insult Abhishek but also sunny deol and ajay too. Is sunny
a Joker or some thing that you told its his type movie. I think you people are
so used with boring family drama and love story even has courage to come out.
3)Now about Abhishek ? do u have any personal problem and make witness to
Abhishek fan that he has not action metal more over no intensity. Priya now
My open challenge to you arrange a poll let's see how many people you got on favor of you.

Anis

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Raghu
RE:MY open challenge to Priya
by Raghu on Sep 30, 2003 06:20 PM
Hey, thats cool. A sunny fan reading film reviews!
That guy (sunny) is not even worth mentioning in todays scenario.

The only reason why one can take a chance with Zameen is the absence of barking sunny.

Raghu.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Arindam Bnaerjee
Zameen-must for every Indian!
by Arindam Bnaerjee on Sep 27, 2003 11:37 AM

While seeing the film it is hard to imagine that the director Rohit Shetty is a debutant. He is first rate with the proper handling of the script. Remove the 3 songs from the movie and we have a hollywood stuff in front of us. Ajay Devgan once again comes out with a winner. He breathes fire in the role of a no-nonsense military officer. Abhishek tries hard to create an impact and he succeeds, though partially. Mukesh Tiwari is good. Bipasha delivers as per the requirement of the story. The action sequences by Jai Singh are breath taking. Kudos to the cinematogropher who really helps Zameen to be a sleek movie. But it is actually the script writer Suparn Verma who deserves the lion's share of applause for an up-to-date, realistic and fiery script. Thanks to Rohit Shetty, our festive season starts of with a bang! All in all, Zameen is a must watch for every Indian.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
sree
jai hind
by sree on Sep 27, 2003 11:08 AM

+the film is very very damm good ,

specially ajay's acting and patrieotism, his dilouges

and army walking, looks real an army officer.



convey my regaards to him and whole team of Zameen

indian youth are need a such kind of movies to join indian armed forces.(real stories not mixtureone)

thanks to director and the team.

after Nanaa Ptekar this part is sueted to Ajay Devgun



Vande Mataram

Pakistan Besharam



Satyamevajayate



    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 98 messages Pages:    <<  < Newer  | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9   Older >
Write a message