Tata Motors needs Bengal more than Bengal needs Tata Motors.
Firstly, 150 plus leading industrialists including Yogi Deveswar, Anil Ambani, Purnendu Chatterjee, Sanjeev Goenka, R.K. Birla, Harsh Neotia, Sanjay Budhia etc are already interested in investing in Bengal. So are other companies of the Tata group.
So Tata Motors needs Bengal market and its purchasing power. Bengal's lack of prominent industries (56 thousand factories closed by CPIM's millitant trade unionism) made them think they would have early bird advantage. How are you so sure:
1. Tata motors' business rivals aren't secretly interested in the 600 acre land after returning disputed 400 acres to farmers?
2. Even if corporates aren't for argument's sake, several central govt projects including railways are already openly interested in setting up shop there. What's the difference between one investment and another?
3. How can you be sure Tatas haven't been adequately compensated by Gujarat govt for their losses incurred in Singur?
4. Tatas wrote to CPIM in 2008 that they would return the land if compensated by WB govt. So why this sudden about-face and legal battle? Especially when current WB govt had openly said Tatas could continue production on undisputed 600 acres land and even ask Hoogly District and district court for compensation should they wish to terminate lease. Why this sudden interest instead in challenging a bill which has acquired force of law, unless acting at CPIM's beh
TATA ARE RIGHT TO HAVE LAND THEY HAVE PAID for it . THEY ARE NOT LIKE MAMTA BEGGING MAONEY FROM CONGRESS AND USA. WHEN THIS STATE WILL GET SELF RESPECT AND REVIVE. SO THAT BONGS DOES NOT HAD TO GO OTHER STATE FOR THIER LIVELYHOOD> THERE ARE 2 CRORE Bengali out of Bengal
Re: MAMTA IS SHAMELEEEEESS LEADER WHOM BONGS ADORE
by hal jordan on Jun 25, 2011 12:07 PM
stop abusing the caps lock on your keyboard. the 2 crore people out of bengal you refer to were driven out in desperation during fascist CPIM's 34 year reign of terror in bengal.
Re: Re: MAMTA IS SHAMELEEEEESS LEADER WHOM BONGS ADORE
by hal jordan on Jun 25, 2011 12:13 PM
no wonder dogmatic commies don't undersand the difference between bargaining and begging since they perceive the world through their narrow focus scarlett tinted glasses.
Re: MAMTA IS SHAMELEEEEESS LEADER WHOM BONGS ADORE
by Joy Gupta on Jun 26, 2011 10:00 AM
Nirmal, you need to learn something called netiquette. Repeatedly you abuse the CAPS lock key in your keyboard and strain the eyes of the people visiting the forum. By writing like this, you are becoming the biggest nuisance factor in the forum.
Also, you have no sense of English, your spellings are horrible and you write non-issues. Typical signs of a half-educated school dropout CPM cadre.
Re: Re: Re: Re: MAMTA IS SHAMELEEEEESS LEADER WHOM BONGS ADORE
by Nirmal Ganguly on Jun 28, 2011 05:30 PM
What Congress has done befor CPm forget my netiquet and language for your kind information I dont belong to you as well. I am just informing you how pathetic is the state of Bengal when will the Glory will come to this state supposed to be most intelligent people are living in this state but still backward in every respect. ( I am Not supporter of CPm)
