Common, Wipro, Infosys in this list? Did they give any money to writer? One more thing, Price Water House Coopers, the same company which was a part of Satyam saga and did annual audit. Such a crap list.
This list is wrong. I have worked in Mindtree. The attrition rate is very high @ Mindtree. if this is the most admired company than the attrition should not be so high that every week at least 50 employees resigns.
Re: Wrong List
by banana republic on Dec 13, 2010 09:09 PM
our organizations are like flowing rivers. water flows in and flows out in a river. similarly, people come and go.
Re: Most admired companies
by Raj Thackersey on Dec 14, 2010 12:03 AM
Anderson Consulting which is now Accenture and look at people they have already forgotten
AC was financial consultant and auditor to Enron and largely ignored the corruption and scandals to retain their contracts
Re: Re: Most admired companies
by Atanu Chatterjee on Dec 15, 2010 03:21 PM
Anderson consulting and Arthur & Anderson are two different companies. The enron scam you are trying to refer here was with Arthur Anderson and NOT Anderson consulting
Re: Re: Most admired companies
by Atanu Chatterjee on Dec 15, 2010 03:25 PM
Anderson consulting and Arthur & Anderson are two different companies. The enron scam you are trying to refer here was with Arthur Anderson and NOT Anderson consulting
Re: rediff please
by banana republic on Dec 13, 2010 09:01 PM
Dude, if you had obtained this list in google, you would have said that rediff is just a copy cat.
Re: Re: rediff please
by Mohan Rao on Dec 20, 2010 04:51 AM
Hey dont get patriotic over rediff. If not this one, most of the Rediff's articles are paid articles. But then if you ask me why I am still interested in Rediff, I will have to say 'just for comedy'. See the kind of comments by user like 'banana republic'. I almost break into laughter when ever I read his/her comments. Quite funny, aren't they?
Price WaterHouse Coopers were also invloved in the Stayam Scam where they bluffed the whole world. I really do not understand how they are part of the list of admired companies.
Re: How did PWC come in the list???
by ritwick sanyal on Dec 14, 2010 03:33 PM
The company mentioned here is PwC Global. PwC India is a member firm of PwC Global. Anyway PwC is present in more than 150 countries and is over 130 years old company. Do you really think one Satyam in India can tarnish that image..
Re: Re: How did PWC come in the list???
by surya das on Dec 13, 2010 06:40 PM
these ranks are nothing but bullSHT. In 2007, Lehman brothers was awarded by S&P as well as Times magazine the best global financial institution. Then, AIG was awarded by US govt the best employer in US, where as CITI(who never sleeps) awarded best bank in 2006. The entire world knows their feat. One already perished, rest 2 got life line of billions of money to survive. Same this you may see in 2002 IT bubble, Sun Microsystem was awarded one of the top 3 IT co.s who made US proud, whose share were trading at 126$ per share, after 8 years trading at 3$. So, don't be over react on these numbers, cause these are just gimmicks to stay on plot.
Re: Re: Re: How did PWC come in the list???
by viswanatha seshadri on Dec 13, 2010 09:06 PM
perhaps, this list was given to rediff by the tata-lobbyist lady radia, placing tatas in the number one position..
Reliance chor company not on list of admired firms. They are well known for looting innocent farmers in name of SEZ & Investors in name of share buy back, takeover.
Many companies which have been admired in the past have been proved corrupt to the core. Many of these big companies and their CEOs will be admired until they are caught. Ex: Sathyam, Enron and the list goes on.
Re: Re: This list is totally wrong
by a p on Dec 13, 2010 05:45 PM
My dear lonegladiator for last 4-5 years MindTree always comes in top place in MAKE India & Asia. Its no surprise for me that MindTree has finally made it to world list too.
I know lots of people in MindTree.. Really a fundu company with great people.
Re: Re: Re: This list is totally wrong
by Raj Thackersey on Dec 14, 2010 12:05 AM
Hewitt gave Satyam the best employer award but they infact had the worst HR practice, and I personally experienced this
And this is not a hate post, I can prove this with facts
Moral of the story never beleive in surveys, rankings and list
Re: Re: Re: This list is totally wrong
by lonegladiator on Dec 13, 2010 05:55 PM
Oh Really, 6 years. yes, you heard it right. i have worked in that company. i know about them more than any one else and yeah please dont jump on any conclusion that i was a average performer or a loser. i have got spot award or 10/10 awards nearly 4 times and technical expertise award, shining star award, u name it. I quit mindtree on my own terms, i can give 110 reason with proof what they are. so please dont think i am just commenting because i have lots of free time.
Re: Re: Re: Re: This list is totally wrong
by lonegladiator on Dec 13, 2010 06:00 PM
Ap, One more thing, since you know lots of people in mindtree. why dont u have a look at their offer letter specifically the salary package section and compare it with their pay slip which they actually get. i hope you will know what mindtree is right away. (Provided the lots of people who u know in mindtree are willing to show you both). Sorry mate, No offence made.its just that i cant hear anything good about that company.
Re: Re: Re: Re: This list is totally wrong
by a p on Dec 13, 2010 06:02 PM
thats cool... whtz ur name?? wanna meet u .. wanna meet some1 with so so many awards.
Bro its ur wish to quit MT... and all want growth in life, so its nothing wrong quitting MT. waise whats ur name? so many awards.. u must be frm R & D division of MT
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: This list is totally wrong
by lonegladiator on Dec 13, 2010 06:13 PM
ap, Are you trying to probe me and get information. hehehehe. i guess your not one of useless MT managers. Because it is their age old trick. Anyways, R&D,ITS or IMTS how does it matter. mail me. i will give you even my employee id. then you know who your talking with.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: This list is totally wrong
by a p on Dec 13, 2010 06:18 PM
Dont worry bro I am not part of MT... I have worked in MT for 5 yrs and left MT for my own reasons.. Well we all feel our company is dull/useless.. I have seen lots of brillant and innovative ppl in MT in my time... I am out of MT does not mean its a bad company. Its our own perception.
I know lots of ppl in MT and the way are talking sounds like my old frnd frm MT. :-)
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: This list is totally wrong
by lonegladiator on Dec 13, 2010 06:26 PM
I am not worried ap, never . I lived like a tiger and i left like a tiger. No company is good or bad, its the people. people dont leave company the leave managers and i had my share of horrible ones. Anyways i dont devulge my personal info on any forums. As i said before you can mail me and let see whether we were really old pals.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: This list is totally wrong
by Cool Mahesh on Dec 13, 2010 06:32 PM
@ lonegladiator. Absolutely right. People don't leave organisations but they leave because of horrible managers.
