Discussion Board

We OBJECT, Mr Chetan Bhagat!


Total 217 messages Pages    <<  < Newer  | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10   Older >   >>
K Binu
Review of the book.
by K Binu on Aug 22, 2012 03:03 PM  | Hide replies

Nupur Madam has literally gone on to answer what young India wants. Well madam each Indian will have his/her own opinion about what young Indians what and no two opinions might ever match. It would be better if you just stick yourself to reviewing the book rather than listing what young Indians really wants bcoz somebody else on the discussion board will write "We object Nupur Madam".

    Forward  |  Report abuse
K Binu
Re: Review of the book.
by K Binu on Aug 22, 2012 03:04 PM
Nupur Madam has literally gone on to answer what young India wants. Well madam each Indian will have his/her own opinion about what young Indians want and no two opinions might ever match. It would be better if you just stick yourself to reviewing the book rather than listing what young Indians really wants bcoz somebody else on the discussion board will write "We object Nupur Madam".

   Forward   |   Report abuse
BHASKAR CHOUMAL
Publicity
by BHASKAR CHOUMAL on Aug 22, 2012 02:14 PM  | Hide replies

A publicity funda for Chetan Bhagat's book.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
rahul rai
Re: Publicity
by rahul rai on Aug 22, 2012 03:57 PM
This is not publicity funda of Chetan Bhagat book but of Nupur mam itself.. This is the best way to become her more popular

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Partha Das
calm down
by Partha Das on Aug 22, 2012 02:05 PM

Nupur, why dont you write your own book- What Young India Really Wants!!

    Forward  |  Report abuse
RJ
what young India wants
by RJ on Aug 22, 2012 01:35 PM  | Hide replies

why do we have an opium like cricket in the first place? why do we have corrupt politicians and corrupt, unholy , destructive nexus between them and builders/industrialists/glamour world etc etc? isnt it bcos we the people--me and u and all of us(well , most of us) are indifferent? if the state makes military training, where they teach a lot about human and patriotic values , we will most likely criticise it as draconian, opressive. but have we ever thought of volunteerring to send one able child per family to even training in such values, shedding aside engineering courses run by street-level self-proclaimed engineering colleges? what s wrong with chetan bhagat criticising ourselves or even anyone else cricising, for that matter? but, yes, criticisng will not solve problems--but can always be a pointer to the problem or , more importantly, its source? its more useful to assess whether he has done that job in his book, rather than just refuting whatever he has said. and yes, I agree with one of the readers who has mentioned that coming home for diwali is not "value" --we do it for fun and masti, which is ok, but not a reflection of any great "value" . also, every third Indian tehse days seems to be a a literary person and author--and most of what they write is trash. this book at least has an expressed purpose-whether or not it has done the job well is another issue

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Winnie Saldanha
Re: what young India wants
by Winnie Saldanha on Aug 22, 2012 02:15 PM
ditto!

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Raj Tomar
Re: what young India wants
by Raj Tomar on Aug 22, 2012 03:48 PM
well said RJ. Nupoor wants to get publicity by criticizing Mr Bhagat.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RJ
what young India wants
by RJ on Aug 22, 2012 01:35 PM  | Hide replies

why do we have an opium like cricket in the first place? why do we have corrupt politicians and corrupt, unholy , destructive nexus between them and builders/industrialists/glamour world etc etc? isnt it bcos we the people--me and u and all of us(well , most of us) are indifferent? if the state makes military training, where they teach a lot about human and patriotic values , we will most likely criticise it as draconian, opressive. but have we ever thought of volunteerring to send one able child per family to even training in such values, shedding aside engineering courses run by street-level self-proclaimed engineering colleges? what s wrong with chetan bhagat criticising ourselves or even anyone else cricising, for that matter? but, yes, criticisng will not solve problems--but can always be a pointer to the problem or , more importantly, its source? its more useful to assess whether he has done that job in his book, rather than just refuting whatever he has said. and yes, I agree with one of the readers who has mentioned that coming home for diwali is not "value" --we do it for fun and masti, which is ok, but not a reflection of any great "value" . also, every third Indian tehse days seems to be a a literary person and author--and most of what they write is trash. this book at least has an expressed purpose-whether or not it has done the job well is another issue

    Forward  |  Report abuse
pooja chawla
Re: what young India wants
by pooja chawla on Aug 22, 2012 02:07 PM
Hi.... not sure if you have read papers... there is more corruption in defence than in any other sector, we just dont know as the RTI act does not make it mandatory for defence to disclose citing security issues.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Kiran Joseph
Re: Re: what young India wants
by Kiran Joseph on Aug 22, 2012 02:34 PM
Pooja, at least the few truly patriotic selfless Indians can be surely found in the Armed Forces, despite the corruption.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RJ
what young India wants
by RJ on Aug 22, 2012 01:34 PM

why do we have an opium like cricket in the first place? why do we have corrupt politicians and corrupt, unholy , destructive nexus between them and builders/industrialists/glamour world etc etc? isnt it bcos we the people--me and u and all of us(well , most of us) are indifferent? if the state makes military training, where they teach a lot about human and patriotic values , we will most likely criticise it as draconian, opressive. but have we ever thought of volunteerring to send one able child per family to even training in such values, shedding aside engineering courses run by street-level self-proclaimed engineering colleges? what s wrong with chetan bhagat criticising ourselves or even anyone else cricising, for that matter? but, yes, criticisng will not solve problems--but can always be a pointer to the problem or , more importantly, its source? its more useful to assess whether he has done that job in his book, rather than just refuting whatever he has said. and yes, I agree with one of the readers who has mentioned that coming home for diwali is not "value" --we do it for fun and masti, which is ok, but not a reflection of any great "value" . also, every third Indian tehse days seems to be a a literary person and author--and most of what they write is trash. this book at least has an expressed purpose-whether or not it has done the job well is another issue

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 217 messages Pages:    <<  < Newer  | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10   Older >   >>
Write a message