by prem chand on Dec 26, 2011 06:58 PM If DRS is available, then why do we need on field umpires. Appeal every out to the DRS and DRS show the result. Either have the DRS system or have the on field Umpiring system. Not both
So we should stop runout and stumpout slomo replays? Good idea!!
Re: Re: Prem Chand
by Mahesh Saoji on Dec 26, 2011 07:18 PM
If fixing is done in the matches. I am not sure but have been hearing a lot of fix matches.
Re: Re: Prem Chand
by prem chand on Dec 26, 2011 07:32 PM
We wont be having on field Umpire errors. It will be either advantage or disadvantage to both teams. But the game will be fair. Blaming concept will go of
Re: Re: Re: Re: Prem Chand
by prem chand on Dec 26, 2011 07:52 PM
I know that DRS is available. But what I am saying is, have only 1. Either DRS or OnField Umpiring system and not both
by prem chand on Dec 26, 2011 06:58 PM If DRS is available, then why do we need on field umpires. Appeal every out to the DRS and DRS show the result. Either have the DRS system or have the on field Umpiring system. Not both
So we should stop runout and stumpout slomo replays? Good idea!!!
I think if India get all the wickets by tomorrow lunch, and if we play well for the next 2 days, India has a very fair chance to will the boxing day test. Go India Go
Re: Premchand
by prem chand on Dec 26, 2011 07:34 PM
Provided India get good runs on the scoreboard and build enough lead and try not bat second innings
Re: Re: Re: Anurag Rathore
by madanmohan siddhanthi on Dec 26, 2011 06:59 PM
It just dadagiri -DRs will make atleast 90% of wrong decisions rectified or corrected.Yes ! this will not help gambling population which has enormous power.
DRS creates unnecessary presuure on umpires. It's not perfect. It's better to trust on on field umpires. Just give them power to refer to third umpire in case of any decision.
Re: Don't use DRS...
by breddy last on Dec 26, 2011 06:32 PM
So 3rd umpire is perfect and for what ever reason, he won't create pressure on field umpires!!
Re: Re: Don't use DRS...
by Anurag Rathore on Dec 26, 2011 06:37 PM
Since it will be upto on field umpires whether he wants to go for 3rd umpire. In case if he thinks it's a close call, he can go for 3rd umpire. But in DRS players challenge umpire decision which is not right. Whenever decision will be revert, umpire confidence will shake.
Re: Re: Re: Don't use DRS...
by breddy last on Dec 26, 2011 07:04 PM
In which case 3rd umpire secretly use techonolgy like DRS, VRS or what ever to assist making desicions :)...
Re: Re: Re: Don't use DRS...
by Mahesh Saoji on Dec 26, 2011 07:19 PM
We are not there to give Confidence to umpires. Its match of One Nation against other Nation. And records. So correct decisions are always requested.
Re: Don't use DRS...
by prem chand on Dec 26, 2011 06:58 PM
If DRS is available, then why do we need on field umpires. Appeal every out to the DRS and DRS show the result. Either have the DRS system or have the on field Umpiring system. Not both
Think abt our last indian tour to Aussie! If we had good decison by the Unpires we would have won the series by 2-1 ! U just lost a wicket notthe match , be happy
Re: All in the game boss!
by Against Pseudos on Dec 26, 2011 06:29 PM
Is it? But we too lost a few wickets only back then. Unless you were watching some different match.
Re: All in the game boss!
by prem chand on Dec 26, 2011 06:53 PM
I also agree. In the last tour, we saw Dravid, Sachin & Ganguly were given out even when they are not. At that time, we suffered a lot and we haven't raised any complaints
