IPL definitely has its place in cricket and yes there are many positives of the game, in terms of cricket or money. I agree with all those points and the author also lists them through his almost daily columns.
What is really hideous is that you dont get to hear the downside of things. I would have expected this author to give a balanced judgment taking the cons into account, but he too seems to have joined the money bandwagon alone.
When you start only praising something and that too at the top of your voice and in numbers, it turns into a typical product. You suppress healthy views which show the flipside and start running truant.
This is when articles like these seem more like advertising propaganda than anything else.
Example, the author is heell bent on trying to prove that parochialism is creeping into IPL. Ok, agreed it is for the people who belong to the 8 cities or nearby regions. But that probably does not even account for 2 percent of the population. What about the rest of the country? Who do they cheer or form loyalties?
I do not however dispute that parochialism is creeping into the local crowd. Ok. But surely, if that happens, then there will be lesser takers for the sport when you play intra country tournaments. You have to understand that either a league like this will be successful or country level will be successful. They may co-exist but both cannot be successful. A simple way to understand this is to look around other sports and you get the answer.
RE:More like propaganda than an article
by GR on Apr 24, 2008 04:15 PM
I totally agree with you. I didnt see a single article from this author during ICL, and let me tell you some of those players were really good. The ICL matches were nice too.
Prem, how much have you been paid by Lalit Modi and his cronies for this article?
RE:More like propaganda than an article
by kaushik on Apr 24, 2008 04:06 PM
More quality local players should be brought in and encouraged to play in the league so that the public can get behind their state/city teams. Now all we have is a Mumbai/Chennai/Hyd team with international stars and players from other parts of the country with a few local players. Watch this format take off when local public get really loyal towards their team. I'm not sure people will still be interested in watching India playing against other countries then.
RE:sachin
by manoj das on Apr 24, 2008 05:26 PM
Sachin is the most valuable player India has produced in last two decades. He has played and still playing the maximum No. of winning Knocks in ODIs . The new brokes are no good than 30-40 runs (Maximum) and hence fit for 20-20 games only. Only Yuvi & Dhoni(partly) suitable for ODI. They are not even suitable for tests(The man's game).
RE:sachin
by Soj on Apr 24, 2008 03:57 PM
Sachin is the best at any form of the game. He is god. Can you point a person who can play as many as different shots like him.
Well ICL has started this competition and now IPL is enjoying it with teir super stars.... But both are equally good... where in ICL you will see some quality cricet and here you will see fighting for money .. here in IPL players will be judged on its money not by quality of playing... see last 8 matches.. players who were high in getting money are very low at field.. :) anyhow its business my dear...
