RE:Dhoni shud be Dropped
by Ansari za on Jul 10, 2007 10:26 AM
this absolutely rt? how come Dhoni b the vice-cap its bit frustrating Question getting in to the mind? they are mad to do that?
RE:Dhoni shud be Dropped
by sameer sachdev on Jul 10, 2007 05:52 AM
totally agreee with dhoni is useless and he can only perform in indian pitches not any where else
RE:Dhoni shud be Dropped
by Ravi chandra on Jul 10, 2007 06:24 AM
Hi sameer I agree with you, not only Dhoni, many other batsmen struggle once they are out of India. Apart from Dravid no one can play well a quality pace attack. But this series he has got a dual role to play as a wall n captain.
RE:Dhoni shud be Dropped
by hari hariharan on Jul 10, 2007 09:21 AM
selector can take Dhoni in Indian Pitches( similar conditions available in other countires like pakistan,Bangaladesh). For the rest, can give a chance to youngsters linke Manoj Tiwary.
It is better to Drop Dhoni, and play Kartik, any way he will do the kepping as well batting. And he is inform batsmen right now. And its very good chance to play with 5 seamers. so it will be well balanced.
RE:Drop Dhoni
by Babu Muralidharan on Jul 10, 2007 08:55 AM
one man demolition team within india and that too if the pitch is not seaming and bouncing. A bouncer or two, then dhoni is a dead duck.
RE:Drop Dhoni for the test
by R A on Jul 10, 2007 04:18 AM
What a stupid idea ...Must be a moron to come up with the idea to drop - Dhoni - the best player in the team to support a regional player.
RE:Drop Dhoni for the test
by Mukil Kesavan on Jul 10, 2007 08:14 AM
We would do much better in EVERYTHING from politics to sports if only we STOP hero worship. A player like Jason Gillespie if playing for India would never be dropped even if he lost a leg. Not the case with the aussies. Why? They strive for excellence and take decisions based on actual performances rather than blind faith. Consistency is the key at this level of the game. We are supposed to weed out the one-game wonders who score big once in a while, right at the domestic level itself. Those that represent team India MUST be consistent and it is not that we cannot find 11 CONSISTENT players in a country of gazillions. Bottomline: If you don't perform consistently well, then the axe shall fall on you even if you are the prime minister's wife's mother-in-law's son's sister's distant cousin!
RE:Drop Dhoni for the test
by Amaranath Pannaiyar on Jul 10, 2007 08:25 AM
Hello RA what do you mean by regional player.. U mean to Say that Tamilnadu which is one of the top three teams in the Ranji does not have players good enough to represent India. Do you people think that only the part above Karnataka should dictate terms. U people dont have basic decency at all and u talk about regional bias and bullshit. If you people think that ur good enough why the hell do u people come down south to do business. Keep everything with you itself.
RE:Drop Dhoni for the test
by Ansari za on Jul 10, 2007 10:25 AM
thats right he dont deserve place in the test side instead Karthick can do the job and we can get the extra bowler! and a good attack. whats the meaning of playing two WK ? i dont undrstand? this just like shits? come indian wake up? play Karthick he does the job well in test? so he is very much fit for the job? no Dhoni atleast we dont need washing(Dhulaii) in test hope selectors and team management understand that better?
