No body can generalize any countrymen. The fellow was bashing Indians and nobody. Yes we have lacs of Million poor people - because we are Billions. But no body gives any right to condemn the whole of citizens on the name of a few. The Nepalese people off late are behaving like Anti Indians. Although their 90 % of people are earning bread here. Many of these so called Napelese Guards are involved in killing our elderly and retired family members and are involved in many robberies, But we did not generalized the whole of community. We did not demand their expulsion. India is a Free Country. But it should not be taken for granted. We respect co-existence and thjat is why SRK - IRFAN etc are at the TOP. Tell me any Hindu in general at top in Pakistan. So mind you language when taking about our country. It's not a kabila - it's a cultured society. Exception are alway there and we condemn the wrongful doing of the RJ. But you can not hang him for this fault.
RE:RE:It's a free world !
by Halali Dalahullah on Sep 29, 2007 02:13 AM
Mukharjee Sahib. COME VISIT ANY MUSLIM AND I CAN ASSURE YOU WILL BE TREATED LIKE A LORD.
RE:It's a free world !
by on Sep 29, 2007 02:49 AM
by Asim,
I think by saying india is free you dont mean to say that it's liberated from other..do you mean to say that india is country of freedom..if so, i dont believe that..aftermath of richard gere and shilpa sheety kiss is still fresh..just recenly ex mp from BJP called for chopping off the head of Tamil nadu CM..nobody could take action against that mp...whole world knows the human right situation of muslims in kasmir and gujrat..if you say that nepalese are ani indians..just follow the news in nepal about how ramdev is being treated as living god who is currently there..you might not have any idea about the fan followings of indian actors and cricketers there..that does not imply that we have to love everthing about you..and who said that 90%of nepalese are earning breads in nepal? get you facts right, those persons are of nepaleese origin..they are there because british won many part of land from Nepal and gifted to you when they left...and there are many indians in nepal as well ..I dont think that our country is feeding them..they are earning their own bread even if doing petty and mean jobs..yes we are poor in comparision to you..but we take this fact gracefully because of a good reason that we were never under british regime..most of the infrastructure in india from railway to highways were built in india under the slavery of british rule..if you continue saying such things about my country..i have thousands others to say about your too..
this message is for Tathagata Mukherjee and people like Tathagata Mukherjee , I am an Indian pleading you and some others pl stop writing abt your issues with muslims.this will increase the fire morw. why are u instigating by bad comments.This clearly shows there is no difference between peopl who burn public property and people like u who burn public mind by useless bad comments.If u r true indian then pl stop here. if anybody reply back to this is accepting that he is not.
RE:Tathagata Mukherjee
by aeges on Sep 29, 2007 01:53 AM
Thanks brother, I never wanted to retaliate to Tathagata, but couldn't refrain. There is some limit to instigation. Why do everyone has to pull muslims in all issues? Thanks for your wise advice. I respect your advice.
RE:Tathagata Mukherjee
by Adnan Khalid on Sep 29, 2007 02:12 AM
yea precisely why azim premji is one of the world's richest indians, na tathu gatu!? :P hahaha!
Dude, get out of ur sick mentality, when you dont even know what you are saying!!! LOL!!!
RE:Tathagata Mukherjee
by Virender Sehwag on Sep 29, 2007 02:07 AM
Tathagata Mukherjee, my sweetheart, you need urgent medical help. Please visit your nearest psychiatrist first thing in the morning tomorrow. Man, u need help. Every alcoholic says he is ok and not drunk, and you also may think you are fine but dude u r S-I-C-K. Go and get treated if you want to lead a healthy normal and happy life. With the kind of thoughts you have in your head, you can never be a happy person, forget about being a responsible citizen.
RE:RE:Tathagata Mukherjee
by ABHIJIT ROY on Sep 29, 2007 01:48 PM
TATHAGATA! Do you know the meaning of your name? Come to my chamber. I will treat you free of cost.
RE:Tathagata Mukherjee
by Virender Sehwag on Sep 29, 2007 02:18 AM
Do you have a real name? Ur name was given by your parents and your religion was given by your parents. I have given my own name and I have not taken any religion. Understand Mr. S-I-C-K Mukherjee. Who tells you I don't have a real name? You do not have a real brain. Go and visit a psychiatrist tomorrow. U need help.
RE:This is what appeasement has led to
by Tathagata Mukherjee on Sep 29, 2007 01:51 AM
MF himself said he is NOT in exile. In any case, the Arab state where he is saying HAS MUCH MUCH LESS FREEDOM than India.
So, stop this anti-Hindu propaganda whoever SPEAKS FOR HINDUS, HINDUISM ARE COMMUNAL (god knows then how Muslims, Xtians are to be described). And try to respect Hindu sensitibilities.
RE:This is what appeasement has led to
by Vijay Saini on Sep 29, 2007 02:01 AM
You are going too far my dear. If you don't have faith in you culture of Hindustan, please take citizenship of Pakistan and have a first hand information. Jitni Batten yahan kar rahe ho utni saanse bhi wahan permission ke sath leni hogi.
RE:RE:This is what appeasement has led to
by Adnan Khalid on Sep 29, 2007 02:07 AM
abbey kab sudharega tu gadhe? pyaar se bol rahe hai chup hoja, gaaliya deni padegi kya ab? is that the language you would understand you piece of illiterate scum???????????
What started as a discussion about the RJ's comments has led to invite people like you into this and give your color of communalism. Dude, get lost, nobody likes your comments here, and inshallah there would be a day of complete peace and the same secular feeling would prevail as it was a long time back, and the whole country would despise such thoughts of communal hypocrisy. You represent a class (.000025%) of indian population, that the rest of us disgrace. SO SHUT UP AND GO SPREAD UR SCUM SOMEWHERE ELSE!
RE:Indian Society is getting brutalised
by Murtuza on Sep 29, 2007 01:50 AM
We in India talk about so called development...but what about development of peoples' mentality?? Here an ambulance was stopped & God knows what the family of the patient must have gone through just because some little known RJ's comments towards Prashant, who doesnt deserve top crown. Pathetic!
RE:Shame on you
by somnath kar on Sep 29, 2007 01:45 AM
Taken...Mr... well I see you did not put in ur name here.. anyways... I dont really understand ur views... we, in India feed people from Nepal, Bangladesh and Pakistan....I am extremely hurt by the fact by the remarks made by the RJ on the talented guy... but that does not mean that u (from wherever u belong) start abusing MY country. I m a citizen of India... and I dont allow anybody to abuse my country... whether u r from Nepal or from wherever... sadly though u feed on our money... u seek our army's help... but u shelter those who want my country to fall... I say again-- that RJ should be punished... but then that should happen to you as well.. right here--right now!!!
Feed on our resources... and abuse us... INDIA IS 'BLESSED' WITH AMAZING NEIGHBOURS...
RE:RE:Shame on you
by on Sep 29, 2007 01:59 AM
who the hell told you that we are seeking your army's help..think about your own security and feeding you own people..about the neghbourhood, we are cursed being a neighbour to india...especially sharing borders with Bihar and UP
The public does NOT have the authority to DECIDE if the RJ was being RACIALLY INSENSITIVE or if his remark is an ACT OF TREASON.
This will be decided by the Courts and the courts decision will be implemented by the government (State or Central). That is how our system should work.
I see people passing judgement some going to the extrems. So what is the difference between you and the protestors. And you are suppose to me more educated ?
When people decide and punish on their own, that is a MOB REACTION. People are doing it in the street and we are doing here through our blogs.
We must support and follow our constitution and respect the LAW of our land.
We have the right to have our opinions, but don't rights come with responsibility...Responsibility of knowing the facts before we decide.
Pray does anyone know what RJ actually said that incited this.. I condemn the words whatever it may be if it hurt a section of Indians...RJ shuld know he is not a letterman etc whu can freely bash any Indian related cultuer in this country
RE:aag mein tel but...
by Neil on Sep 29, 2007 01:39 AM
YO BHANEKO THIYO BUJHIS! (This is what he said)
He (Nitin) said : Aaaj Prashant Tamang 'Nepali larka from Darjeeling' has become Indian Idol 'with sarcastic laugh'%u2026.. and we have match tonight so we need to guard our house / malls / restaurants by ourselves as there will be no Nepali People to guard these place and whole night we need to say "Jagtay Raho". He also added that all the Footpath momo shops will remain closed as Nepali guy has become Indian Idol%u2026%u201D
