It is extremently unfortunate to see the behaviour and attitude of rougue like Ms. Mamata Banerjee. The people of West Bengal should realise that her action is briging disrepute to all Bengalis all over the world and the agitation will lead West Bengal nowhere. Satyajit Banerjee
RE:Ratan Tata's words of inspiration
by manoj kumar on Aug 26, 2008 05:21 PM Permalink
Mamta giving comrade their own receipe, which is now sour and sweet when they did it. West Bengal is moving towards stone age. Mamta actions are publicity rather than for real cause - All Politician are worried abt themselves, vote and note,
RE:Ratan Tata's words of inspiration
by vinod gupta on Aug 26, 2008 05:20 PM Permalink
it's not for Mamta but for Commies, ppl of india disrespect Bengali. The agitation will give right lesson to industrialist who only understand profit at any cost. Someone correctly mention SEZ stands for Special Exploitaion Zone.
RE:RE:Ratan Tata's words of inspiration
by Kaustav Kar on Aug 26, 2008 05:38 PM Permalink
Sorry Vinod I don't think that People of India disrespect the Bengalis... U r wrong...
RE:Ratan Tata's words of inspiration
by sathish kumar on Aug 26, 2008 05:45 PM Permalink
you know one think they had selected mamtha as them political leader means how the people are well educated. also they dont know about outer world.. they are not self thinking. then how its possible.
RE:Ratan Tata's words of inspiration
by NKnath on Aug 26, 2008 05:15 PM Permalink
Your CPM has made our bengal a quite heal. Bustrad Joity and ruscal Budha has made already an uncivilized and uneducated socity in Bengal. Now these people so how people would realise the value of industry ? So for good industrilization we need proper education. For that first we need to remove CPM out of Bengal.
Re: Ratan Tata's words of inspiration
by JKNATH on Sep 14, 2008 04:13 PM Permalink
Dear N K Nath,
I like to add with you : THIS "DHEKHUN BHABUN AGIYE CHALUN" BACCHRA LOOTED ALL LANDS, JOBS, BUSINESS.
NOW THE ORIGINAL WEST BENGALEES WELL UNDERSTAND THE MEANING "DHEKHUN BHABUN AGIYE CHALUN" I.E WHO WILL GET THE BENEFIT, JOB, BAGAN, MAUJ MASTI, SWIMMING POOL IN LIE OF POOR WEST BENGAL FARMERS.
TATA IS 420 THEIR ASSOCIATES BIMAN, NIRUPAM, BINOY ARE DOUBLE 420.
NOW ALL WEST BENGAL PEOPLE NOT GIVING ANY MORE LAND OR FOOD TO THIS PS 1971 ERA.
NOW THE WEST BENGAL FARMERS STARTED RECOVERED THEIR LOOTED LAND FROM BAKRESHWAR (NO LAND PRICE NO SERVICE) FROM SHANTINEKETAN THE MIRZAFAR SOMNATH CHATTERJEE LOOTED P0OR FARMERS LAND AND NOT EVEN PAY THE PRICE OF THE LAND.
RE:Ratan Tata's words of inspiration
by Kaustav Kar on Aug 26, 2008 05:35 PM Permalink
Its nothing but Mamta is trying to gain some Political Advantages.. And Someday She becomes the CM.. Hope anyone except she becomes the CM of WB... She will do the smae thing... Its a Political Game or nothing....
He is not saying to shift his plant but to close this plant. An capitalist can never compromise with his profits. In view of price hikes of Petrol, Diesel and all merchandise, It may be possible that the cost of Nano is not coming under the rate promised by Tata.
RE:Price Hike may be a reason
by akhilesh dixit on Aug 26, 2008 05:24 PM Permalink
Why are u spreading rumour?Already Pantnagar plant is made for Nano and now Pune is being considered .He has invested thousands of Crore for people who can afford, still if u see him capitalist you need understanding of TATA group and their philosphy how they made Jamshedpur plant.In India any person like you can make a loose comment and sit.
RE:Price Hike may be a reason
by PCNawal on Aug 26, 2008 05:30 PM Permalink
Hey man, this is a discussion board. Why are you becoming aggresive. Take is cool boss. Don't say like a spokeperson of Tata.
RE:Price Hike may be a reason
by akhilesh dixit on Aug 26, 2008 05:35 PM Permalink
So u mean to say in a iscussionboard you can write without knowing basic facts!!! If you dont know subject better not to comment. It is in all newspapers that Pantnagar plant is already gearing up for Nano.Half knowledge always dangerous nothing aggresive dear.
RE:Price Hike may be a reason
by akhilesh dixit on Aug 26, 2008 06:00 PM Permalink
You know Pantnagar is going on and still saying That because of increase in petrol diesel he may not deliver in one lac?Is cost of ptreol disesel different in S I N G U R and Pantnagar. I dont know about my knowledge quotient, like you know but I know how to respect our heroes be it in sports industry or any field. I do not believe in making comments on stature of people of his stature just for sake of writing on writeboard without representing full truth.
RE:Price Hike may be a reason
by sathish kumar on Aug 26, 2008 05:39 PM Permalink
so he planned to escape from his words by using mamtha... this is almost like a political drama.
RE:Price Hike may be a reason
by akhilesh dixit on Aug 26, 2008 05:44 PM Permalink
He has said it will be shifted and can be slightly delayed.You trust his word or immature people.He delivered first Indian car and 1 lac car as promised.In India we dont respect even most desrving because we failed people can't see anything large and out of policics.we think everyone like us.Out of all Indian industrial houses I have highest regard for this house.
iT IS NOT mAMATA bENERJEE she is only a puppet in the hands of purana bengal industrialists like birlas/todi's who do not want TATA to enter Bengal and they are funding all these activities thru Mamata to push out tatas and any other big groups like reliance etc from bengal permanently. That is the crux of the issue
RE:NANO PROJECT
by yele on Aug 26, 2008 05:20 PM Permalink
What aJoke ! Industrialist like Biral can not think of such thing that TATA should not enter in Bengal. Your thinking is cheep & poor. Mamta and like politician can do this what they are doing now.
RE:RE:NANO PROJECT
by bunty on Aug 26, 2008 05:31 PM Permalink
I am sorry to say that you are not able to see activities in the right perspective. Once TATAs are successful in Bengal many industrialists are going to enter - this is a test case and negative messages are being sent by whom?? Bengal people are not- then Who? Do not think emotionally.
RE:No more factory & IT industry in Bengal
by arupanjan mukherji on Aug 26, 2008 05:10 PM Permalink
Mr Shah start coming up from you narrow loyalities of AWARENESS and state - You Medha Patekar was one of them here. Dont think ALL bengalis support these hooligans Read and learn before you make comments based on narrow loyalities
RE:No more factory & IT industry in Bengal
by RAJAH on Aug 26, 2008 05:22 PM Permalink
crazy guys. calcutta is already dead. now tatas trying to give some life to west bengal villeges that also you guys have killed. well done bhai. keep it up good work.communists are orphan today. without them congress is happy ruling this country. your attitude kills you.
RE:RE:I, ME , MYSELF - Ratan Tata
by Kabeer on Aug 26, 2008 05:28 PM Permalink
Dear Bhushan Hazare,
So much for the fighters of FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION!
My post is not abusive, it is just critical!
You dont have a stomach to hear criticism!
Why should a farmer who has a fertile land tilling it for centuries be forced to sell to someone like Tata Motors?
You have two gigantic stadia in the prime business district of Bombay (Wankhede & Brabourne) where a single match is played in a year. When asked to sell that land to build multistoreyed office space people say that it is the prerogative of the clubs to sell the land or not; it is privately owned and you can not force them to sell.
Fine! Then why forcing poor farmers to sell their farm lands? Because they are poor right?
RE:I, ME , MYSELF - Ratan Tata
by Ashok on Aug 26, 2008 05:14 PM Permalink
Its not a public sector company...Kabeer seth. Forget about this life u will not be like tata in ur all 7 lifes. Bcos TATA is not like reliance he said my employees and he means it. Its just the way u take. May be ur big buisnessmen or educated but to be Ratan Tata.....forget i dont think u can be like him. Its useless telling u and Indians like u. Be happy in ur own shell and let Ratan Tata do what he feels is correct. From supporter of TATA Group
RE:I, ME , MYSELF - Ratan Tata
by suresh menon on Aug 26, 2008 05:09 PM Permalink
I am a Tata employee and i am proud to be an employee of "Ratan Tata". This is because each employee is his own and he is my "ratan". U should work with tatas and then with reliance to know the difference my dear friend.
RE:RE:I, ME , MYSELF - Ratan Tata
by Joseph Gomez on Aug 26, 2008 05:41 PM Permalink
Go down to the history of TATAs from the beginning and they are always an INDIAN. They will never do a thing against any Indian nor to the any Government. I am not an employee nor I ever had the chance to know them directly. But I fully believe and trust that the TATAs are really Indians.
RE:RE:I, ME , MYSELF - Ratan Tata
by Kabeer on Aug 26, 2008 05:50 PM Permalink
For all those who are screaming hoarse their lungs out in this blog in support of Ratan Tata, please answer me honestly, if you want.
In Bombay you got two whacking stadia Brabourne & Wankhede in the prime business district where only a couple of cricket matches are played in a year.
Govt asked the land be sold to any one and build multi storeyed office space there. The ongoing office space rates are already one of the highest in the world there i.e Nariman Point.
The owners of the stadia i.e Private Clubs refused to sell that land stating that it is their private property and they can do whatever they like with it. Selling it to build multi storeyed offic space for the good of the nation didnt bother them. Every educated person supported them stating that it is their property and they can do what they like and the GOvt has no say in it.
FINE!
Now, in Singur, the land is alluvial soil i.e. the richest arable soil irrigated by the gangetic tributaries over millenia. The farmers are tilling that land for centuries and are makiing a living out of it.
What moral right has anyone to force them to sell their lands to the Tatas?
If you are rich you get away by builing whacking stadia in the prime business district of the nation.
If you are poor you are forced to sell your best farming land to some one else and you have no say in it?
Are all those educated lot who are screaming hoarse here believe in equality and common rights? Or are they regurgit
RE:I, ME , MYSELF - Ratan Tata
by hasnoor on Aug 26, 2008 05:03 PM Permalink
It's this man who has taken forward Tata's to these great heights not Tata Motors. Tata Motors is one of the Cos. from the Tata Group.
RE:I, ME , MYSELF - Ratan Tata
by Neeraj Bhatnagar on Aug 26, 2008 05:12 PM Permalink
Really Bookish... Grow-up Man, you are taking about a man who is fighting to make common man's dream come true. Against all Odds.
RE:RE:I, ME , MYSELF - Ratan Tata
by Kabeer on Aug 26, 2008 05:28 PM Permalink
So much for the fighters of FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION!
My post is not abusive, it is just critical!
You dont have a stomach to hear criticism!
Why should a farmer who has a fertile land tilling it for centuries be forced to sell to someone like Tata Motors?
You have two gigantic stadia in the prime business district of Bombay (Wankhede & Brabourne) where a single match is played in a year. When asked to sell that land to build multistoreyed office space people say that it is the prerogative of the clubs to sell the land or not; it is privately owned and you can not force them to sell.
Fine! Then why forcing poor farmers to sell their farm lands? Because they are poor right?
RE:I, ME , MYSELF - Ratan Tata
by akhilesh dixit on Aug 26, 2008 05:10 PM Permalink
It only shows how much concerned he is for safety of his employees.The word my employees means his attatchment and belongingness if you can see it from Mgmt perspective, TATAs are the best employers just go and find out.
There is no doubt that in the Singoor case , TATA is trapped in between the dirty politics of the above two . Both are equally to be blamed for the current situation . Over confidence had lead the WB Govt to do whatever they wanted to do in the land case / didnot even bothered to review or predict the outcome.
Better not to tell anything about Mamata as she would oppose everything whatever Left front want to do WHETHER GOOD OR BAD .Ultimate sufferer are the common people .
Hope with this situation anybody in future would ever dare to come to West Bengal .
RE:WB GOVT & MAMATA
by vinod gupta on Aug 26, 2008 05:01 PM Permalink
What's about the suffering of poor farmer of Singur. Except Mamata, no one really takes care.
RE:WB GOVT & MAMATA
by pappu on Aug 26, 2008 05:15 PM Permalink
Dear friend , Even WB Govt today returns the 600 acre land back to the Farmers , still she would find other ways to make the issue live to take political advantage . Trinamul today is the replica of Lefties of sixtees / seventies when they used to oppose everything during the tenure of Congress .
RE:I, ME, MYSELF - Ratan Tata
by Veenaay Deshpande on Aug 26, 2008 05:07 PM Permalink
In what context it is said is important. He just want to protect his employees and thats what he meant and we understood. His statement will definitely help boost the moral of all the TATA employees all across the TATA empire due to the care and concern shown by Ratan Tata. This hightened moral will certainly be beneficial to TATAs.
RE:I, ME, MYSELF - Ratan Tata
by lalit kedia on Aug 26, 2008 04:56 PM Permalink
Gentleman, probably you are not aware that TATA is not a process driven organisation but it is a personality driven organisation. that is why you see different aspect of management with change in top leader ship between JRD,Russy Mody, sumant mulgaonkar and Ratan tata both at tata motors and tata steel. with Ratan tata taking over the reins it has become more aggresive and visible globally. There is nothing wrong in it he is at least careful about its employees whether he says my employees or our employees. however this is true that with such growth and mergers the organisation needs to be more process and culture driven not personality driven.
RE:I, ME, MYSELF - Ratan Tata
by Umesh Sharma on Aug 26, 2008 04:58 PM Permalink
mr kabeer, as a chairman of tata group, he has every right to say "my employees" and like the great man he is , he has put the employees before the investment , and not like others who wud protect their investment and not employees. we must appreciate this gesture. it is the misfortune of bengal that after such a long time there was someone who had the courage to invest in that state. it is the political leadership that has to protect his investment and gv him confidence that the people of the state will back him. leaders like mamta will like their pound of flesh in political upmanship without interest of the state at heart. i sincerely pray that the matter is solved at the earliest.
