RE:A really good message...
by Loser The Indian on Apr 30, 2007 06:06 PM Permalink
First there was no reservations in the past as you like to think.
1. No one can stop others from studying for your information. You can stop them from working, stop them from eating or even from drinking water but you can never stop others from learning. With all your reservations you can only stop Brahmins from progressing further but you can never make them illitrate and they would not give this as an excuse and remain illitrate 2. If every Brahmin were to follow the rules strictly they need to beg for food and must not accumulate wealth. 3. Every Brahmin must have Cow and they must get all diary products ONLY from that Cow. 4. Brahmins in general has nothing to do with temples. It was due to barbaric medivial Abrahamic invasions, others gave this responsibility to Brahmins. 5. Most of the well-to-do are NOT from Brahmins instead from Banya castes. Brahmins are still poor and live hand-to-mouth. 6. Dont confuse yourself with some urban elite wearing Cross-threads with Brahmins. They are Vaisyas not Brahmins. FYI, anyone can wear Sacred Thread for that you need to follow certain regulations.
RE:A really good message...
by Sam on Apr 30, 2007 06:32 PM Permalink
Again you got it wrong dude.. I know all urban elite are not bramins.. The point is since education was not allowed to a major section of the country - it is nothing but social justice to give some reservations to uplift them..
It just like if a elderly couple have two kids - one is uber-rich and the other was just able to meet his ends meet, his parents will help him, even with their pension money.. That is wat was provided by the constitution and should be there till the inequality is erased.. got it?? there can be an additional clause like if anyone from your father's/grandfather's generation has been benifitted from reservation (education/job) you will not be eligible..
RE:[object]
by Loser The Indian on Apr 30, 2007 08:16 PM Permalink
You still did not get it. Brahmins may be probagating vedic texts within their communities, this is just "may be". Even this vedic texts was written by SC/ST Vyasar.
The language tamil was in its full swing and every tom,dick and harry knew how to read, write and speak Tamil language during ancient and medivial periods (just before barbaric Abrahaic invasions).
You just cant stop from from reading, learning and getting educated. You may deny oppurtunities in government or private organizations citing millions of reasons but you just cant stop people from learning!
RE:RE:A really good message...
by Crazy Human on Apr 30, 2007 06:41 PM Permalink
wrong analogy on every count. No one is rich in India except for a few OBCs and a few UC, remaining are mired in poverty so why should government only favour poor OBCs why not poor UCs too. Majority of UCs are poor
RE:[object]
by Sam on Apr 30, 2007 06:38 PM Permalink
great.. some intelligent one had reported my post which does not have any single abuse for abuse.. long live democracy...
