the truth is always hidden whether the gulty is caught or no..who knows what transpired between them when it happened...only GOD knows...maybe the maid was lookin to enjoy and she got afraid at the last minute..maybe she wanted money and he refused..maybe shiny was under alcohol and did not see the end result..maybe he just sweet talked to her and she thought somethinn else...like this there may be so many ifs and buts...but ultimately only they know the truth...