Discussion Board

'Pinki is innocent and a victim of conspiracy'


Total 44 messages Pages | 1 | 2   Older >
Manoj Adwani
Irony
by Manoj Adwani on Jul 10, 2012 10:14 PM

Irony is since June 14 when she was remanded to judicial custody till date the state has not been able to complete a gender determination test as charges of rape have been levelled against. Everyone is innocent till proven guilty; but this athlete has been physically and mentally tortured and still there are no results. Its an absolute shame.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
nrmgrm
but why did Pinki suppress her gender
by nrmgrm on Jul 10, 2012 09:40 PM

Her parents initially , herself then all the national and international screening medical authorities are responsible.But Pinki was dishonest -that is the root cause-and she had meddled in the life of another woman -thats it

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Brat
What/Where is the Root Cause?
by Brat on Jul 10, 2012 09:04 PM

Pinki Pramanik represented India in the Asian Games as a female. I am sure medical tests have been conducted at different levels. If not atleast in the International(Asian Games) level. If now some tests prove that SHE is actually a HE the there must have been something wrong at all these organizations - Sports Authorities, National Agencies, International Acencies, etc. All of them and their officials should come under scanner and punished?
On the other hand, if She is SHE, the the people who brought those charges should be severely punished? And those who supported it and the Police too should come under scanner?
But nothing will happen...This is the state of West Bengal...Here, in the rural anybody say anything and do anything.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Jitesh Dasgupta
PINKI PRAMANIK
by Jitesh Dasgupta on Jul 10, 2012 08:37 PM

She is innocent.Please don't disturb her anymore.It's request & prayer to all.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
arindam das
maltreatment of a medal-winning international athelete
by arindam das on Jul 10, 2012 08:30 PM  | Hide replies

the way this person who brought india an international gold medal in atheletics was treated, the way she was manhandled by policemen on her arrest was shocking. how could male police personnel even touch her? so long as she is not proven to be a male nobody has the right to outrage her modesty. just think what would have been the repurcussion had the person concerned had been a p t usha or a sania mirza?

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Ravi Kiran
Re: maltreatment of a medal-winning international athelete
by Ravi Kiran on Jul 10, 2012 08:38 PM
whi is pinki? I dont like idolying the name Pinki and feeling great about it ?

   Forward   |   Report abuse
anup sengupta
Pinki Pramanick
by anup sengupta on Jul 10, 2012 07:41 PM  | Hide replies

What ever be the decision of Hon'ble Court, humiliation with a human being to be stopped immediately. Pinki is a human being. Treatment should be like that.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
lustlovelife
Re: Pinki Pramanick
by lustlovelife on Jul 10, 2012 07:56 PM
Whatever has happend is a big mistake and it went on for 25 days!!! What are the human rights ppl doing.

If she had been a minority all congressmen would have jumped up on one leg to fight for her!!!

   Forward   |   Report abuse
sudheer mahajan
Re: Re: Pinki Pramanick
by sudheer mahajan on Jul 10, 2012 08:53 PM
if thishad happened in Gujarat & Pinki was a muslim the heavens would have fallen & all the khagrass & the paid media would have brayed for Modi's blood .......but as she is a HINDU & it happened in bengal & as the didi is a upa ally nothing of the kind happened ,how did mms of her being subjected to a gender test made public who was responsible & what action is going to be taken for outraging the modesty of a woman the state under whose care she was must be help responsible & the top brass be sacked & put into jail & a hefty compensation be made to Pinki & the amount be recovered from the official concerned even by auctioning their properties this would act as a dterrent to other officials

   Forward   |   Report abuse
sudheer mahajan
Re: Re: Pinki Pramanick
by sudheer mahajan on Jul 10, 2012 08:54 PM
if thishad happened in Gujarat & Pinki was a muslim the heavens would have fallen & all the khagrass & the paid media would have brayed for Modi's blood .......but as she is a HINDU & it happened in bengal & as the didi is a upa ally nothing of the kind happened ,how did mms of her being subjected to a gender test made public who was responsible & what action is going to be taken for outraging the modesty of a woman the state under whose care she was must be help responsible & the top brass be sacked & put into jail & a hefty compensation be made to Pinki & the amount be recovered from the official concerned even by auctioning their properties this would act as a dterrent to other officials

   Forward   |   Report abuse
modernengineering limited
Re: Re: Pinki Pramanick
by modernengineering limited on Jul 10, 2012 08:55 PM
if thishad happened in Gujarat & Pinki was a muslim the heavens would have fallen & all the khagrass & the paid media would have brayed for Modi's blood .......but as she is a HINDU & it happened in bengal & as the didi is a upa ally nothing of the kind happened ,how did mms of her being subjected to a gender test made public who was responsible & what action is going to be taken for outraging the modesty of a woman the state under whose care she was must be help responsible & the top brass be sacked & put into jail & a hefty compensation be made to Pinki & the amount be recovered from the official concerned even by auctioning their properties this would act as a dterrent to other officials

   Forward   |   Report abuse
modernengineering limited
Re: Re: Pinki Pramanick
by modernengineering limited on Jul 10, 2012 08:58 PM
if thishad happened in Gujarat & Pinki was a muslim the heavens would have fallen & all the khagrass & the paid media would have brayed for Modi's blood .......but as she is a HINDU & it happened in bengal & as the didi is a upa ally nothing of the kind happened ,how did mms of her being subjected to a gender test made public who was responsible & what action is going to be taken for outraging the modesty of a woman the state under whose care she was must be help responsible & the top brass be sacked & put into jail & a hefty compensation be made to Pinki & the amount be recovered from the official concerned even by auctioning their properties this would act as a dterrent to other officials

   Forward   |   Report abuse
DIGAMBAR JOSHI
Pinki
by DIGAMBAR JOSHI on Jul 10, 2012 07:33 PM  | Hide replies

What is her gender according to Court or What verdict court has given Male or Fehemale.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
lustlovelife
Re: Pinki
by lustlovelife on Jul 10, 2012 07:51 PM
It is none of ur business and not even the business of the court or anybody.

If at all there is a misrepresentation about gender then the sports federation needs to inquire since she has won medals saying she is a female.

There the matter rests.

After enjoying for some months or years it is very common for live in partners to accuse of rape when they dont get what they want!!!

   Forward   |   Report abuse
correct
Oh how horrible
by correct on Jul 10, 2012 07:18 PM  | Hide replies

It is high time the bad women in this country are taught a lesson there are so many women in work place and lot of other places who are getting a free ride just ecause they are women they show some emotions and climb up corporate ladder they show upstairs and butter the boss at the right place and get promotions and boss and create horror

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Shail
Re: Oh how horrible
by Shail on Jul 10, 2012 07:28 PM
Mate I am a man and I know that there are so many women who are smart intelligent and deserve the position they get to ....except for some who are expert in cooking for Indira Gandhi and climb steps of Raisina Hill

   Forward   |   Report abuse
some one
Re: Re: Oh how horrible
by some one on Jul 10, 2012 07:38 PM

Where basic human rights are concerned, questioning the individual's absolute freedom to exercise their basic rights is itself wrong. The individual who has a right does not have any duty to be or to appear to be reasonable in using it, or to conform to so called social norms, except where it prevents equal use by others of their similar rights. Indians do not normally have this kind of respect for fellow Indians, because the concept of freedom of the individual is largely absent in Indian tradition. Freedom is a European concept that is sought to be imported into India.

Privacy should be respected even in a public place or discussion. It is irrelevant and not the business of others whether she is a male or female or other gender, whether their sexual preference is homo or hetero sexual, etc. Whatever be the case, it is their own business.


   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
rajesh
Re: Re: Oh how horrible
by rajesh on Jul 10, 2012 07:45 PM
i belive your intelligent woman couln't cook. i feel the burn of jealousy in your words

   Forward   |   Report abuse
lustlovelife
Re: Re: Re: Oh how horrible
by lustlovelife on Jul 10, 2012 07:53 PM
About women using their charms to rise up the corporate ladder is very common. But there are competent women also.

How this comment applies to Pinki I am at a loss to understand.

She is a fine athelete and it is nobodys business what her gender is except the sports federation since she has won medals in the female category. So they can enquire in a respectable fashion and not in a vulgar manner.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
jose xavier
shameful
by jose xavier on Jul 10, 2012 07:12 PM  | Hide replies

Every right thinking Indian should hang his head in shame.For most people this is a joke .Just imagine how the person may be feeling about themselves .It is enough to driver a person to suicide .

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
Shail
Re: Re: shameful
by Shail on Jul 10, 2012 07:26 PM
The case will have to be burried even if it is found that she is a man, can you you imagine taunts hurled to Indian players at the Olympics. There will be demands for stripping them all for gender testing which will mean that share prices of hair removal products will go through the roof hehehehehehehehe

   Forward   |   Report abuse
lustlovelife
Re: Re: shameful
by lustlovelife on Jul 10, 2012 07:55 PM
aftab what is there to laugh? Have some sympathy for the poor lady.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Total 44 messages Pages: | 1 | 2   Older >
Write a message