Freebies is free poision. Congess, CPM, SP, BSP, TDP, AIDMK, DMK, TMC (Mamta), what given to the public in the name of freebies is free poision. It not only spoiled our youth workforce & capability to work physically & mentally, It also destroyed our future nation. And if it goes for long, then India will inherit useless beggars with a bowl. Stop the vote bank politics & join with the present Governments.’s aspiration to be a part of energetic & work alchoholic like our PM. Make India great through proper vision, not like corrupted opposition’s Kichdi coalition.
Re: Freebies is free poision.
by Chaitanya on Mar 19, 2018 05:16 PM
@nilanjan roy:
What AP is asking for is not freebies. It is a NECESSARY (and yet INSUFFICIENT) compensation for the BIG BLOW INFLICTED on AP, by Cong and BJP, in 2014. It is essential for the BARE SURVIVAL of AP's economy.
It is not a new fancy. It is a 4-year old commitment.
It was not proposed by Cong or TDP. It was proposed by BJP and accepted by ruling Cong.
It does not need any further legislative or constitutional action. It is an assurance given by former PM and converted into a Cabinet Decision.
It does need any new justification. Any justification should have been discussed in 2014, before the AP Bifurcation Bill was bull-dozed, purely for the Telangana vote bank in 2014 elections. Both BJP and Cong knew that Bill was INCOMPLETE, IRRATIONAL, INEQUITABLE. But it was the last day of Parl before 2014 elections, and they both badly wanted the Telangana vote bank.
BTW, it is the BJP that is indulging in freebies -- not AP. Hope you are aware of Yogi's farm waiver, free laptops, free data connection, etc.
Hope you are not so strongly biased in favor of BJP that you were completely unaware of BJP's freebies?
And FYI, the Centre has been enjoying freebies from AP, not the other way round, FOR DECADES. AP needs to be given revenue for the offshore oil being drawn from the KG Basin, just as Maharashtra is being given. In fact, this injustice was pointed out by the 12 th Finance Commission years ago.
So, AP's demands are not freebies. Please understand that.
Re: Re: Freebies is free poision.
by pusarla kumar on Mar 20, 2018 09:46 PM
ask Jagan, Babu and other big wigs in the AP reformation committee to open up their coffers for the benefit of AP .. if they reveal their then no need of any money from center .. this is political hypocrisy by all parties ...
Re: Re: Re: Freebies is free poision.
by Chaitanya on Mar 20, 2018 10:41 PM
@pusarla kumar:
What is this new thing called "AP reformation committee"?
The people you refer to ("Jagan, Babu, and other big wigs") may be rich, may be corrupt. That is completely IRRELEVANT to AP's problems created by the AP Reorg Bill of 2014.
This fight is not between BJP and TDP, or between BJP and YSRCP.
TDP may be here today, and go tomorrow. YSRCP may come and go.
Please understand that this is a fight for justice, between the people of AP and the Central govt. The whole of AP is boiling with anger at the injustices, and the people's anger has finally forced TDP to act.
The PROBLEMS of the people of AP were created purely by the AP Reorg Bill. A Bill whose draft was rejected by the AP State Assembly, but was still bull-dozed through Parl by both the so-called "National Parties", purely for bagging the Telangana vote-bank.
Re: Re: Freebies is free poision.
by pusarla kumar on Mar 20, 2018 09:49 PM
tens of thousands of crores of Black money with all Ap bigwigs should be identified immediately and use the same for new state development ..
Re: Re: Re: Freebies is free poision.
by Chaitanya on Mar 20, 2018 10:52 PM
@pusarla kumar:
Thank you for your sincere suggestion to solve the problems of the people of AP.
Some doubts regarding your suggestion:
( 1 ) The blow to AP is far bigger than the black money of all politicians of all parties, including BJP's. In case you don't know how the damage happened and how big are the figures, you will find some answers in the govt's own CAG reports.
( 2 ) What about the jobs? Please understand that the blow to AP is not just monetary. The jobs in AP have also been grabbed overnight and given away. That is one of the main reasons why Special Category Status was promised by BJP and Cong, in 2014. How will that problem get addressed by your suggestion?
Re: Re: Freebies is free poision.
by KRISHNA KUMAR on Mar 20, 2018 10:58 AM
Dear Mr.Chaitanya, you are absolutely correct. Freebies are being encouraged by NPA Govt., you can see it in Tamilnadu on subsidized scooters for working women, where PM is the special guest and during election campaigns in North Eastern States they announced Free Jherusalem tour for Christians, where as they discontinued the subsidy on Haz yatra for muslims. Seems double standards in policy making. Further, NPA announced 20K Crores as special package for UP (Bundelkhand), where the state is having capital and various infrastructures. How do we think about the Govt. Policy Decisions?
It is likely to be a hung parliament with a great degree of uncertainty. The BJP which now in power is steadily loosing popularity. The maximum seats it likely to be as under: AP(25)- 05 Assam (14)- 07 Bihar (40)- 30 Chatishgarh(11) 02 Delhi(7) 04 Goa (2) 01 Gujurat (26) 13 Haryana (10) 05 Himachal (4) 02 J&k(6) 03 Jharkhand (14) 07 Karnataka(28) 14 kerala(13) 0 MP (29) 15 Maharastra(48) 24 Odissa (21) 01 Punjab (13) 05 Rajastan (25) 05 Tamilnadu (39) 0 Telengana (17) 05 UP (80) 20 Uttarakhand(5) 03 West Bengal(42) 0 North East(11) 05 Union Territories(5) 02
North East(AP-2, Manipur-2,Meghalaya-2,Mizo-1, Naga-1,Sikim-01, Tripura-02)
Both, Sumitra Mahajan(loksabha) and Venkaish Naidu(Rajysabha) have power to name and suspend continually unruly members from the house. This could ensure business in both houses. But since past three sessions, both these exhibit inefficiency and meekness in face of unruly members, leading to no work and crores of rupee loss to the country daily. Why not replace such second grade and incompetent people? Why not suspend/expell poorly behaving members? Country and its work is more imoortant than them.
The fact is that Bengal government has been excellent in order to develop their business atmosphere, no bandh in last 6 years in bengal, huge development in infrastructure, law and order and now attracted big business house of IT to come to bengal leaving bengaluru. Excellent move by mamata banerjee to win the heart of hill and Gorkha morch on date has asked TMC supremo that they will give their candidate as TMC will direct. Gurong is now past and hill is on development path. It has been all round development story in Bengal, in spite of the fact that NDA govt take away huge amount to tune of nearly 50 thousand crores towards interest of central loan take by left government. So Bengal also deserve to get special status from centre.
Re: WHY ONLY AP? BENGAL SHOULD ALSO BE GIVEN SPECIAL STATUS.
by DVG KRISHNA KUMAR on Mar 19, 2018 03:43 PM
Reason is AP is divided into two states; one is Telangana and another AP. After separation, it state don't have capital city and most of the manufacturing industries and software industries are strategically established in and around Hyderabad, which is the present capital of Telangana State. Hence, there is a need of Special Status to empower the state financially. In case of Bengal, it is well developed and also had capital city. Bengal may demand for special package rather than special status like Bihar and UP.
Re: Re: WHY ONLY AP? BENGAL SHOULD ALSO BE GIVEN SPECIAL STATUS.
by nilanjan roy on Mar 19, 2018 04:33 PM
She has given free cycle, 2 rs/- kg rice, free money to clubs, free drinking. Only party office is open 24 hrs which is only industry in W.B & thats the only job she created. Joti bosu created Chandon Bose. Mamta created her brother & nephew who run hotels in Orissa & Singapore. She has only one agenda to protect her family at the cost of anything. Young people are migrating in masses to other cities with a begging bowl. She has created atmosphere of fear same as CPM did in the past. So that nobody can speak against her. CPM had destroyed industires. Mamta had successfully destroyed University & educational institutes.
Re: Re: WHY ONLY AP? BENGAL SHOULD ALSO BE GIVEN SPECIAL STATUS.
by nilanjan roy on Mar 19, 2018 04:41 PM
Mamta has given free cycle, 2 rs/- kg rice, free money to clubs, free drinking. Only party office is open 24 hrs which is only industry in W.B & thats the only job she created. She has only one agenda to protect her corrupted brother & nephew. Young people are migrating in masses to other cities with a begging bowl. She has created atmosphere of fear same as CPM did in the past. So that nobody can speak against her. CPM had destroyed industires. Mamta had successfully destroyed University & educational institutes.
Re: WHY ONLY AP? BENGAL SHOULD ALSO BE GIVEN SPECIAL STATUS.
by Chaitanya on Mar 19, 2018 04:29 PM
@subrata banerjee:
Please understand that what AP is asking for is not some new fad that caught the AP people's fancy.
It is a necessary and insufficient compensation promised for the HUGE LOSS INFLICTED ON AP, by the AP Bifurcation Bill, which gifted away Hyd to Telangana.
In that CRIME, Cong and BJP were equal PERPETRATORS. Both bull-dozed the bill thru Parl. BJP proposed, and Cong agreed, that in view of the HUGE DAMAGE to AP, AP must be given Spl Status. Manmohan even took the matter forward and issued a Cabinet Directive on it.
AP's economy was thrown overnight into a massive deficit. It was converted overnight into an agricultural economy without any jobs, infrastructure, revenue sources. Everything went to Telangana, with Hyd.
Does Bengal have a 40% deficit budget? Does it have zero industries, zero urban infrastructure? If so, it certainly deserves special status for the same reasons as AP.
Anyways, I am not qualified to comment on Bengal's qualifications for Spl Status. All I can highlight is the reasons why Special Status was promised in 2014, and why the people of AP are insisting on fulfilment of that promise today.
Re: WHY ONLY AP? BENGAL SHOULD ALSO BE GIVEN SPECIAL STATUS.
by nilanjan roy on Mar 19, 2018 05:01 PM
In West Bengal, TMC party office is the only industry open for 24 hours, without any holiday & no bandh. Earlier it was CPM party office, now TMC has replaced and running syndicate government.Any house repairing, any building painting – people have to give money to local councilors. It came so many time in the paper & so many people have been killed.
Re: Renula choudhary
by KRISHNAN DAMODARAN on Mar 19, 2018 04:03 PM
Please avoid such comments against ladies . She is a Member of Indian National Cogrss and Rajya Saba Member.
