It is her own failings that the coalition failed, as it was expected to. He flip-flop statements and attempts to gain points from the separatists made her look weak and vulnerable. Most of the times, she played in the hands against the same people against whom she was supposed to act. She and her father can be recalled for the similar tactics. Now she neither has the local nor BJP' support.
MUCH OF THE MESS THAT IS SEEN IN KASHMIR IS DELHI'S MAKING . FROM AN ALMOST NORMALCY IN 2014 IF KASHMIR HAS TODAY SLID INTO ANARCHY LIKE SITUATION THE PRESENT CENTRAL GOVERNMENT MUST TAKE SOLE BLAME . THE WISE WORDS OF RAJAJI ON KASMIR-IGNORED BOTH BY PATEL & NEHRU- MUST BE HEEDED TO AT LEAST NOW . OTHERWISE, PORTENTS SEEM FRAUGHT WITH DIRE POSSIBILITIES
Re: DELHI INFLICTED ANARCHY
by Sachidanand on Jul 17, 2018 04:03 PM
Creation of Article 370 and 35B are the two blunders the Center has done during the inception. Non taking over of Gigit -Baltistan and POK till date is another blunder by the center. It is followed by non action of demographic cleaning of Kashmir in late eightys is yet another blunder. The rectification has just begun now during Modi's regime.Long way to go.. Mr Ramprapan wants to see Kashmir in India or out?
Re: Re: DELHI INFLICTED ANARCHY
by RAMPRAPAN on Jul 17, 2018 09:40 PM
AS PER THE FORMULA FOR PARTITION ALL CONTIGUOUS MUSLIM MAJORITY AREAS SHOULD HAVE GONE TO PAKISTAN. DURING 1947 THERE WAS TREMENDOUS GOODWILL OF KASHMIRIS WITH INDIA . AGAINST THE ADVISE OF RAJAJI PATEL DECIDED NOT HAVE A REFERENDUM A PLEBISCITE . IN FACT, RAJAJI WAS ADVOCATING A REFERENDUM EVEN IN THE 60S THEREBY WEAKENING HIS OWN SWATANTRA PARTY . THE HINDU COMMUNALISTS OF THE CONGRESS PREVENTED A PLEBISCITE. THAT IS THE LONG & SHORT OF IT
Re: Re: Re: DELHI INFLICTED ANARCHY
by rajendra tare on Jul 18, 2018 09:13 AM
Go for a plebiscite based on Kashmir 500 years back when majority was Hindu. We are living in a literate society and still have some who want division based on religion. Any society that follows aggression has to vanish. Look at history and you will find same. If the religious faiths of Kashmiris are in aggression put these words, that they will vanish some day. Religion teaches to follow humanity. This simple rule should be fallowed by all. Division based on religion will kill everyone.
Re: Re: Re: DELHI INFLICTED ANARCHY
by on Jul 18, 2018 10:35 AM
There was no question of plebecite in 1947 when accession of Kashmir took place. It was UN resolution which was solution to Kashmir Dispute. The precondition for plebecite was withdrawl of Pak forces from POK. The was never agreed by Pakistan so the question of plebecite is meaningless. The whole mess was creation of Nehru who ensured the retention of Article 370, although it was introduced as only temporary measure. It was perpetuated by successive Governments leading to separatist tendancies.
Re: DELHI INFLICTED ANARCHY
by Vidyut Shenoy on Jul 17, 2018 10:35 AM
Dire possibilities for India's detractors for sure. Thankfully, somebody had the courage to impress India's legitimacy over J&K.
Re: DELHI INFLICTED ANARCHY
by arungopal agarwal on Jul 17, 2018 10:41 AM
Kashmiris are to first stand against all forces which dis-integrate India and do not have faith in our constitution. Modi never reconciled with such forces anywhere including naxals. He showed his broad heart for Kashmir but in response, nothing. One sided love - not possible.
Re: DELHI INFLICTED ANARCHY
by Dipankar Mukherji on Jul 17, 2018 10:48 AM
Nobody dismissed the Mehooba Govt nor imposed Governor's rule forcefully. BJP just withdrew the support. If she can take support of cong and some independents then she can run the govt. Governor's rule was imposed bcoz Mufti resigned. There is a difference between forceful removal and withdrawal.
Re: DELHI INFLICTED ANARCHY
by Dipankar Mukherji on Jul 17, 2018 10:48 AM
Nobody dismissed the Mehooba Govt nor imposed Governor's rule forcefully. BJP just withdrew the support. If she can take support of cong and some independents then she can run the govt. Governor's rule was imposed bcoz Mufti resigned. There is a difference between forceful removal and withdrawal.
Re: DELHI INFLICTED ANARCHY
by Dipankar Mukherji on Jul 17, 2018 10:48 AM
Nobody dismissed the Mehooba Govt nor imposed Governor's rule forcefully. BJP just withdrew the support. If she can take support of cong and some independents then she can run the govt. Governor's rule was imposed bcoz Mufti resigned. There is a difference between forceful removal and withdrawal.
Re: DELHI INFLICTED ANARCHY
by sharad agarwal on Jul 18, 2018 09:54 AM
Rajiv Gandhi became PM for 5 years term . and migration started in 1987 . why ? was he not responsible ?
Do not agree with the writer, prejudiced article. In Kashmir no one can settle, every thing including judicial system and Police is governed by locals only. As such role of Center is limited. Separatists and few who write such article feel Kashmir is separate entity, yes it is but for limited purpose.These people will have to come in election process to win not with the help of creating anti India feeling or a separate State. Time has gone long back when any evader ruled over others, now democratic process is the only way. Such writers are forcing youths to die just for nothing. 40 lakhs valley Kashmiri have no right to insult and disrespect the feelings of 130 crore people of main land. To feel Indian and be part of India is the only answer Kashmiris are to understand, better to know it early. Do not create any confusion with the past, accept present.
Re: Politics of Kashmir
by Vidyut Shenoy on Jul 17, 2018 10:37 AM
Absolutely. Who wants a torrid PAKI state peering over us? Perhaps, the Hurriyat and Paki Military for their own nefarious goals.
Is created and exaggerated by congi PMs by giving all undue advantages. Mehbuba at the same time wanted to rip benefits from the bjp government which is in power and at the same time get favour from separatist forces by sympathizing for them. Namo is "baap" of politics who punctured that tricks. Instead of so many unpopular economic decisions still people of India favour namo for the same reason. Rediff like propaganda machine will fail and people of India remain behind namo most of the time I hope.
Re: Kashmir
by Inzzy on Jul 17, 2018 09:58 AM
The only way is to involve Pakistan in the dialogue on Kashmir as it has a major stake & say. Leaving out Pakistan is like removing one eye & trying to balance with limited vision. Pakistan is a major stakeholder & must be taken into confidence without which no settlement is possible or can be effected.
Re: Re: Kashmir
by Vidyut Shenoy on Jul 17, 2018 10:41 AM
The only thing Pakis understand is the barrel of a gun. Time to make them face it with its mouth pointing at their head.
Re: Re: Kashmir
by Vidyut Shenoy on Jul 17, 2018 10:41 AM
The only thing Pakis understand is the barrel of a gun. Time to make them face it with its mouth pointing at their head.
Re: Kashmir
by ASHOK UPADHYAYA on Jul 17, 2018 10:14 AM
Indira Gandhi could have solved the problem during 1971 war...Unnecessarily returned 90000 sainiks, won area upto Lahore....Pak did not returned area and sainiks captured by Pak....she could have captured Kashmir n negotiations would have kept Pak aloof of Kashmir....there was no need to be lenient.......
Re: Re: Kashmir
by Inzzy on Jul 17, 2018 10:24 AM
I agree. This problem could easily have been solved with the enemy on the ropes & having no bargaining power. Today Pakistan is a nuclear power & one is not clear about who really controls the nuclear button. It is most likely in the hands of the military than under civilian control. Terrorists are pampered there which exacerbates the problem of nuclear arms being misused. And of course how can anyone ignore the China factor which earlier was offering covert support but with CPEC their strategic interests could be hurt hence Kashmir which was earlier an issue between India & Pakistan has now become a tripartite issue with China as well.
Re: Re: Re: Kashmir
by Vidyut Shenoy on Jul 17, 2018 10:45 AM
If the Pakis governments or terrorists even look at the nuclear button, their end is certain. It will blow up in the collective faces.
Re: Re: Re: Kashmir
by Vidyut Shenoy on Jul 17, 2018 10:45 AM
If the Pakis governments or terrorists even look at the nuclear button, their end is certain. It will blow up in the collective faces.
Re: Re: Kashmir
by Vidyut Shenoy on Jul 17, 2018 10:42 AM
That way, if Mir Jaffer had not succumbed to a bribe, we would still be a united country. Lets face the problem head on and solve it once and for all ...
