Discussion Board

When the Gods Smiled on India


Total 17 messages Pages | 1
Anil Athale
Remembering Admiral Nadkarni.
by Anil Athale on Jul 04, 2018 06:22 AM

Admiral Nadkarni was one of the finest human being and a great Sailor. He was also a decisive leader, who at a crucial time during Maladiv operations took swift decision to intercept the Rebel ship and save Maladiv.
I knew him personally as co-founder of Pune based think tank. He was polite and considerate to a fault and never carried his rank on his shoulders. May his soul rest in peace.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
sachchidanand dhar
1971
by sachchidanand dhar on Jul 03, 2018 02:40 PM  | Hide replies

""Unlike 1962 he was not going to be rushed into an action half prepared. He would first get fully ready and strike at a time and place of his choosing. The prime minister and Cabinet yielded.

The services spent the next six months preparing for the inevitable. Shortfalls in equipment and personnel were made up.""
.
1971 was a great repeat of 1962- in terms of war preparedness.....Total failure of advanced planning and preparations....Face was saved by the victory.....For six months, rapes and murder continued in East Pakistan, while generals busied themselves in preparing...in 1965, Tanot Mata had come to rescue, while Pakustan was much better prepared...This stupidity was seen during Kargil war again, when Indian Infantry had no snow shoes.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
sachchidanand dhar
Re: 1971
by sachchidanand dhar on Jul 03, 2018 02:54 PM
In 1971, Admiral S M Nanda was the only visionary leader......Others lack of preparedness was hidden by the glorious victory.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
R  ponnabalam
Re: 1971
by R ponnabalam on Jul 03, 2018 09:10 PM
"not going to be rushed into an action half prepared' "Which enemy would give you time to prepare"?This question was posed ,if not critically, at least as a concerned question by a man competent enough to say so.Well that write up did concede in the words "Sitting away from -------- without all the ---'' there can be justification if at all.I read it in newspaper But being not prepared was !!!R.PONNAMBALAM

   Forward   |   Report abuse
electronic centre
71 War
by electronic centre on Jul 03, 2018 02:15 PM


Through '71 War we achieved two things, that to defeat Pakistan is a cake walk for India. Creation of Bangladesh, which finishes a great headache in our eastern sector. And finally, Indiraji wiped out the label of coward PM of India, created by Jawaharlal Nehru in '62 War.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
ASHOK UPADHYAYA
1971 War
by ASHOK UPADHYAYA on Jul 03, 2018 09:46 AM  | Hide replies

What our country has achieved? Nothing....Unnecessarily returned won area upto Lahore, 90000 sainiks..2 crore Bangla refugees which have increased n have become nuisance...we were in position to solve Kashmir problem ...Because of that defeat n interference, Pak is today doing terror activity...Shahadat n victory of Mikitary was marred.....Pak did not return our sainiks n won area....

    Forward  |  Report abuse
paul theo
Re: 1971 War
by paul theo on Jul 03, 2018 10:04 AM
THERE IS NO GREAT LEADER LIKE INDIRA GANDHI, WHO ROUTED PAKISTAN, THE 56 INCH CHEST MAN CAN ONLY GIVE EMPTY SLOGANS, GOOD FOR NOTHING, MANAGED TO FOOL INDIANS FOR 4 YEARS

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Bableesh  Kumar
Re: Re: 1971 War
by Bableesh Kumar on Jul 03, 2018 10:02 PM
What did we gain in the war? Whereas we were on very much on upper hand and rightly described by Benazir Bhutto in her book entitled "The Daughter of the East". Whatever problem we wanted to solve, we could have solved and the Pakistan was under immense pressure to agree including Kashmir problem. By creating Bangladesh, we produced another headache though this could have been an autonomous Indian State; similarly Kashmir problem would have been solved and we should not have vacated the area won on the western front. When Indira Gandhi asked General Manekshah in how many days we could Peshawar. He replied in Three days.
It is a very sad event that Military Heroes were not given their due respect and honour for the gallantry shown by them. It is in the DNA of Congress to take credit by their Leaders for anything good done and blame the others for loss.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
ASHOK UPADHYAYA
Re: Re: Re: 1971 War
by ASHOK UPADHYAYA on Jul 04, 2018 01:32 PM
True....many problems are legacy of congress...refugees of Bangladesh are creating problems in wB, Assam, Nagaland etc....they are Burden on our economy n resources....Nationalisation of Banks, Majority Minority, undue appeasement created hatred, Dalits, loan waiver of farmers, corruption etc...

   Forward   |   Report abuse
sachchidanand dhar
Re: Re: Re: Re: 1971 War
by sachchidanand dhar on Jul 04, 2018 04:45 PM
Angrez Gone, Congrez came

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Bableesh  Kumar
Re: Re: 1971 War
by Bableesh Kumar on Jul 03, 2018 10:03 PM
What did we gain in the war? Whereas we were on very much on upper hand and rightly described by Benazir Bhutto in her book entitled "The Daughter of the East". Whatever problem we wanted to solve, we could have solved and the Pakistan was under immense pressure to agree including Kashmir problem. By creating Bangladesh, we produced another headache though this could have been an autonomous Indian State; similarly Kashmir problem would have been solved and we should not have vacated the area won on the western front. When Indira Gandhi asked General Manekshah in how many days we could Peshawar. He replied in Three days.
It is a very sad event that Military Heroes were not given their due respect and honour for the gallantry shown by them. It is in the DNA of Congress to take credit by their Leaders for anything good done and blame the others for loss.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
pk kh
Re: Re: 1971 War
by pk kh on Jul 03, 2018 10:20 AM
Hndus have full faith on 56 inch chest and will drive out and get rid of all the snakes in the sleeves...

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Ashim Manna
Re: 1971 War
by Ashim Manna on Jul 03, 2018 10:51 AM
Can 56 inch do this ever??????

   Forward   |   Report abuse
ASHOK UPADHYAYA
Re: Re: 1971 War
by ASHOK UPADHYAYA on Jul 03, 2018 01:52 PM
What is the use ? It was achievement of our Military,Manekshaw... just go into history...the era of 1971 was different than today’s...Now even China can not attack any country..look US is also afraid of N Korea...Though we have won but in fact we have lost much...blunders of 1971 war we are suffering today... 56 will not do such blunders...

   Forward   |   Report abuse
ASHOK UPADHYAYA
Re: Re: 1971 War
by ASHOK UPADHYAYA on Jul 03, 2018 01:53 PM
What is the use ? It was achievement of our Military,Manekshaw... just go into history...the era of 1971 was different than today’s...Now even China can not attack any country..look US is also afraid of N Korea...Though we have won but in fact we have lost much...blunders of 1971 war we are suffering today... 56 will not do such blunders...

   Forward   |   Report abuse
as lal
Remove
by as lal on Jul 03, 2018 08:58 AM

the statue of Menon

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 17 messages Pages: | 1
Write a message