Re: Is Karni Sena and other Senas equal to Bhartiya Sena?
by Kundapur Kumar on Jan 18, 2018 09:19 PM | Hide message
Why satinic Verses were banned? Who gave authority to whom?
Finially the law of India has been established. Let those pseudo nationalists and so called custodians of Indian culture not watch the film if they dont want. SHame on these self professed upholders of religion and culture, who in this debate have fallen to the extremes of abusing the families of those or heap swear words on those who wish to voice their opinion. IF they are so concerned about loss of their culture, let them walk around half naked, and give up all the modern amenities they are so shamelessly using. Such hypocrisy will not work. Even most right wing fanatics have realised that you can fool people only some of the time, not all the time.
Re: custodians of Indian morality
by sanjeev shrivastava on Jan 18, 2018 04:42 PM
Rajputs are 3% of the Indian population and If I remember correctly they were unable to stop any of the invaders. Their track record has been pathetic.
We are being treated like aliens in our own country. Supreme Court have sadly overlooked that their is a very very large section of people who are getting offended by this movie, which is hittng to their core values and beliefs. They are NO criminals as being projected by various English media, they are fighting for their dignity and pride. When you hit and shake people's core values and beliefs, no courts of the world can stop them.
I appeal to all Indias , pls do NOT go and watch this movie. Let us continue to remember the great Rani Padmavati as mentioned in great song "Aao Bachchon Tumhe Dikhaen Jhanki Hinduatan Ki.......Kud Padi this Yahan Hazaron Padminiyan Angaron Mein" .
Re: We are being treated like aliens in our own country
by mihir mehta on Jan 18, 2018 03:53 PM
then u dont watch the movie ,go to work.why will others not watch the movie bsce u r so silly ?
Re: Re: We are being treated like aliens in our own country
by manu monnappa on Jan 18, 2018 04:02 PM
You people don’t have ethics. What you get from this movie? 3 hours of time pass with popcorn. But you are leaving a permanent dent on our history. You are hurting sentiments of people who believe that queen as their God. You are showing that king as villain and invader as Hero. I appreciate Muslims who fight for their religion and belief. But Hindus think them self as modern and don’t care anyone. Someone produce a movie for money by distorting history and 100 people support him. Will same people will support same producer, if he make a movie on your family showing them as characterless ?
Re: Re: Re: We are being treated like aliens in our own country
by Satyajeet Yadava on Jan 18, 2018 04:10 PM
Padmavat is not history but fiction,like the victory of MRP at Haldighati in 1561!!!
Re: Re: Re: We are being treated like aliens in our own country
by P S SHAH on Jan 18, 2018 04:29 PM
Monnappa, you just keep your ethics with you and let other watch the movie they like.
Re: Re: Re: We are being treated like aliens in our own country
by Nitesh on Jan 19, 2018 01:36 PM
one one hand you say its timepass and on the other you says its denting history. how can a timepass thing dent history? this movie has a disclaimer that its not presenting history and that's enough. A movie should not be taken as a history lesson. If you want to learn history, go to school/university and not a theatre.
Re: We are being treated like aliens in our own country
by Aditya Venkat on Jan 18, 2018 04:06 PM
please tell us, how many of your family members are in our national defence forces, or in any charitable or social organisation doing some good to society. Please dont use your pseudo nationalism here ..there are more sanely educated people in this forum who understand what true culture and tradition is. Keep your warped idea of indian culture to yourself and apply it to your family.
We are being treated like aliens in our own country. Supreme Court have sadly overlooked that their is a very very large section of people who are getting offended by this movie, which is hittng to their core values and beliefs. They are NO criminals as being projected by various English media, they are fighting for their dignity and pride. When you hit and shake people's core values and beliefs, no courts of the world can stop them.
I appeal to all Indias , pls do NOT go and watch this movie. Let us continue to remember the great Rani Padmavati as mentioned in great song "Aao Bachchon Tumhe Dikhaen Jhanki Hinduatan Ki.......Kud Padi this Yahan Hazaron Padminiyan Angaron Mein" .
Re: We are being treated like aliens in our own country
by Homi Irani on Jan 19, 2018 10:22 AM
please dont spread falsehood. Supreme court looks at the larger section and not less than 1% of the population. I am sure there will only a few hundres who will oppose after seeing the film. Grow up, we are not in 13th century. Sati pratha was done then, its a crime today.
Besdes this story is about the valour of the Rajput Queen, and the valour of the Rajputs how they fought wars. which is aptly shown in the movie . you should feel proud as to how our ancenstors were brave in fighting the moguls, and that is what is hown in the movie.
The decision of the SC has added another feather in the cap of the Apex court. A task accomplished that will go a long way to give strength to the rationalists.
Re: Relief for people who prefer integration.
by manu monnappa on Jan 18, 2018 03:39 PM
Why don't you watch your family dance half Nkd in front of you. You just want 3 hours entertainment. Don't bother your culture, sentiments of others
Re: Re: Relief for people who prefer integration.
by vaskas das on Jan 18, 2018 03:53 PM
I WOULD WATCVH UR FAMILY DANCE..BUT DEN U MUST BE BLACK...YUCK
Re: Re: Re: Relief for people who prefer integration.
by manu monnappa on Jan 18, 2018 04:05 PM
Definitely, You are characterless. May be you and your family earning by this only
Re: Re: Re: Re: Relief for people who prefer integration.
by vaskas das on Jan 18, 2018 04:44 PM
mannu the flim shows rajput valour..but u prove that rajputs were valourless..coz that is the only thing the film is abt..so basically yes bansali is wrong by showing that rajputs were brave as per ur belive..
Re: Re: Re: Re: Relief for people who prefer integration.
by vaskas das on Jan 18, 2018 04:45 PM
YE I EARNED MONEY BY SELLING UR MON AND FEEDING ON UR SIS
Re: Re: Re: Re: Relief for people who prefer integration.
by vaskas das on Jan 18, 2018 04:46 PM
YEAH SURE..EARNED A LOT BY SELLING UR MOMMY..AND FEEDING ON UR SISTER
Re: Re: Relief for people who prefer integration.
by P S SHAH on Jan 18, 2018 04:31 PM
Manu Mohappa, have you seen ever trailor of the film before writing nonsense ?
The decision of the SC has added another feather in the cap of the Apex court. A task accomplished that will go a long way to give strength to the rationalists.
The continuously increasing tussle between the judiciary and the legislative since BJP came to the Centre had almost lost completely any hopes of a decision like this today. The four States who had ganged up against this movie for selfish intent of electoral gains need to submit themselves to our Constitution and snap out of the arrogance of power. It is to be hoped that similar attempts in other allied areas will now be abandoned i.e. history falsification and re-writing, creating a new India by destroying the old values and glory of our great nation, and misleading people towards the mirage of imaginary golden ages painted by literature, and that too in a jiffy, forgetting the basic inescapable stark realities of our present.
From now onwards, the SC shall assume the role of maintaining Law and order with India. Henceforth, if there are any pick pocket, rape, theft, murder, its the responsibility of the SC to take care and not the respective state Governments. A big relief for Governments.
Re: SC Order on Padmavat
by daniel thorat on Jan 18, 2018 03:22 PM
There appears to be a good and valid reason to terminate the 4 State govts. for ganging up in an un-Constitutional and diabolical scheme. These govts. could certainly be emboldened to stop anything by believing that they rule supreme in States as we can see in UP and Haryana. But, the PM who is totally silent and tacitly supporting them, needs to be our hon`ble Prime Minister for the entire people and not only for the 31`% voters who chose him in 2014.
Re: SC Order on Padmavat
by daniel thorat on Jan 18, 2018 03:23 PM
There appears to be a good and valid reason to terminate the 4 State govts. for ganging up in an un-Constitutional and diabolical scheme. These govts. could certainly be emboldened to stop anything by believing that they rule supreme in States as we can see in UP and Haryana. But, the PM who is totally silent and tacitly supporting them, needs to be our hon`ble Prime Minister for the entire people and not only for the 31`% voters who chose him in 2014.
Re: SC Order on Padmavat
by daniel thorat on Jan 18, 2018 03:23 PM
There appears to be a good and valid reason to terminate the 4 State govts. for ganging up in an un-Constitutional and diabolical scheme. These govts. could certainly be emboldened to stop anything by believing that they rule supreme in States as we can see in UP and Haryana. But, the PM who is totally silent and tacitly supporting them, needs to be our hon`ble Prime Minister for the entire people and not only for the 31`% voters who chose him in 2014.
Re: SC Order on Padmavat
by daniel thorat on Jan 18, 2018 03:24 PM
There appears to be a good and valid reason to terminate the 4 State govts. for ganging up in an un-Constitutional and diabolical scheme. These govts. could certainly be emboldened to stop anything by believing that they rule supreme in States as we can see in UP and Haryana. But, the PM who is totally silent and tacitly supporting them, needs to be our hon`ble Prime Minister for the entire people and not only for the 31`% voters who chose him in 2014.
Re: Re: SC Order on Padmavat
by manu monnappa on Jan 18, 2018 03:35 PM
When require, people will revolt like Jellikattu. No SC can stop if public does not allow distortion of history
Re: Re: Re: Re: SC Order on Padmavat
by manu monnappa on Jan 18, 2018 04:09 PM
For example all think X born to Y & Z. But Mr. SLB show X born to Y&Q. And want Z should not object for his movie. If he is really genius, let him write and produce movies like bahubali
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: SC Order on Padmavat
by P S SHAH on Jan 18, 2018 04:35 PM
Monnappa, you dont mind people speaking nonsense in the name of freedom of expression and having anti Inda slogan and activities but have only film like Padmavat for protest ? Are you a member of Khap panchayat or karni Sena ?
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: SC Order on Padmavat
by P S SHAH on Jan 18, 2018 04:35 PM
Monnappa, you dont mind people speaking nonsense in the name of freedom of expression and having anti Inda slogan and activities but have only film like Padmavat for protest ? Are you a member of Khap panchayat or karni Sena ?
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: SC Order on Padmavat
by P S SHAH on Jan 18, 2018 04:38 PM
Monnappa, you dont mind people speaking nonsense in the name of freedom of expression and having anti Inda slogan and activities but have only film like Padmavat for protest ? Are you a member of Khap panchayat or karni Sena ?
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: SC Order on Padmavat
by P S SHAH on Jan 20, 2018 09:32 PM
Homi Irani, I dont have to the same words for you as the fact will remain the same in your case.
Judiciary should be reminded of its limits. This is purely administrative aspect. Someday will come when Judiciary will sit in Parliament and conduct the sessions.
