Discussion Board

Decoding Rafale deal: From charges to counter-charges


Total 35 messages Pages < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3   Older >
Unnikrishnan Nayar
Rafale deal
by Unnikrishnan Nayar on Aug 30, 2018 11:30 AM  | Hide replies

The deal appears to be not in good spirits as there is a clause of secrecy in the case of cost. Usually secrecy is only on the details of of the aircraft. Moreover RDL,s case against the Congress party brings suspicion.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
B  B Sharma
JPC fo Rafale Deal
by B B Sharma on Aug 30, 2018 11:02 AM

PM Modi has championed the belief that rule based frame work is superfluous when the tiller of security is in the hands of self - accredited desh bhakts. Any way following points need due consideration :
1. How it is claimed that under NDA deal per plane is cheaper by 20 % when two prices are not publically known?
2 . When deal along with prices are not revealed to CAG , how to audit the whole process & how to release payments ?
3.Any way France Govt. is under obligation to declare prices in their parliament so why hide hear ?
4.Mr MACRON has indicated that his Govt has no objection if Indian Govt intend to reveal prices.
5 . In stead of another defence deal sinking in quagmire of misgivings , Govt. should discuss the whole deal in JPC & clear the cloud, if any.
6.If we can make Satellites & missiles like BROMOS in India why HAL can not manufacture Raffle under collaboration with French company .


    Forward  |  Report abuse
Jayant sharma
Decoding Rafael deal : From charges to counter charges
by Jayant sharma on Aug 30, 2018 10:44 AM

Your article is highly misleading to the general public. There is a subtle attempt to mislead the unsuspecting/uninformed reader by feeding him half the information which paints the NDA govt. in poor light and is suggestive of a major scam by NDA.
The author of this article(Name deliberately suppressed)has stopped short of Finance Minister Jaitley elaborate explanation of the apparent differential price per piece of the aircraft , making the article HALF TRUTH!!!.
Obviously the writer wants to put the NDA govt. in the dock by writing half truth.
Per piece price of Airframe(Bare aircraft without engine and the special Avionics/armaments suit) is roughly one-third the cost, Engine accounts for another one-third of the cost and Modern Avionics with armament suit is the balance cost of the fully loaded aircraft in the Fly-away condition.These days the cost of the Advanced avionics/armaments can far exceed the cost of the airframe!!!
Congress & it's cronies who are backing their allegations on the Rafael dealare perhaps deliberately trying to mislead the Nation for their political needs/compulsions or are woefully ignorant of the fighter aircraft pricing mechanisms.
In either case it is a very shameful and blatant attempt to spread vicious propaganda for political gains!

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Jayant sharma
Decoding Rafael deal : From charges to counter charges
by Jayant sharma on Aug 30, 2018 10:44 AM

Your article is highly misleading to the general public. There is a subtle attempt to mislead the unsuspecting/uninformed reader by feeding him half the information which paints the NDA govt. in poor light and is suggestive of a major scam by NDA.
The author of this article(Name deliberately suppressed)has stopped short of Finance Minister Jaitley elaborate explanation of the apparent differential price per piece of the aircraft , making the article HALF TRUTH!!!.
Obviously the writer wants to put the NDA govt. in the dock by writing half truth.
Per piece price of Airframe(Bare aircraft without engine and the special Avionics/armaments suit) is roughly one-third the cost, Engine accounts for another one-third of the cost and Modern Avionics with armament suit is the balance cost of the fully loaded aircraft in the Fly-away condition.These days the cost of the Advanced avionics/armaments can far exceed the cost of the airframe!!!
Congress & it's cronies who are backing their allegations on the Rafael dealare perhaps deliberately trying to mislead the Nation for their political needs/compulsions or are woefully ignorant of the fighter aircraft pricing mechanisms.
In either case it is a very shameful and blatant attempt to spread vicious propaganda for political gains!

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 35 messages Pages: < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3   Older >
Write a message