Discussion Board

One year on, life in shreds for Kashmir's 'human shield'


Total 35 messages Pages | 1 | 2 | 3   Older >
Prasad Karkare
Soldiers & Civilians
by Prasad Karkare on Apr 09, 2018 04:11 PM

As Sadguru Jaggi Vasudev said, it is none of us' business about what to do on a battlefield. It has to be decided by the men on the war-field as they are the ones facing the bullets or the stones.
In rest of India, it becomes a breaking news if anyone throws ink at a useless politician or slaps a politician and the person responsible is brought to book & punished by law.
However we don't have similar justice for kashmir wherein our brave soldiers are thrown stones at & ridiculed by third-grade citizens of valley. They should be booked under IPC for "Attempt to murder" & punished accordingly for pelting stones. Then & only then we will find peace in valley.
As of now the crimes against our soldiers go unpunished, that's why stone pelting is more rampant.
Those at rediff who think that major Gogoi has not taken the right decision, should lead our soldiers when they face stone pelting xxxxxxxx.
Jai Hind.

    Forward  |  'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
Prasad Karkare
Soldier & Civilian
by Prasad Karkare on Apr 09, 2018 04:08 PM

As Sadguru Jaggi Vasudev said, it is none of us\' business about what to do on a battlefield. It has to be decided by the men on the war-field as they are the ones facing the bullets or the stones.
In rest of India, it becomes a breaking news if anyone throws ink at a useless politician or slaps a politician and the person responsible is brought to book & punished by law.
However we don\'t have similar justice for kashmir wherein our brave soldiers are thrown stones at & ridiculed by third-grade citizens of valley. They should be booked under IPC for \"Attempt to murder\" & punished accordingly for pelting stones. Then & only then we will find peace in valley.
As of now the crimes against our soldiers go unpunished, that\'s why stone pelting is more rampant.
Those at rediff who think that major Gogoi has not taken the right decision, should lead our soldiers when they face stone pelting xxxxxxxx.
Jai Hind.

    Forward  |  'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
pk kh
Rediff is Anti National Media
by pk kh on Apr 09, 2018 09:42 AM  | Hide replies

Time and again it like saparatists,Pak,and other anti-nationals want to keep the kashmir burning...shame on Rediff

    Forward  |  Report abuse
pk kh
Re: Rediff is Anti National Media
by pk kh on Apr 09, 2018 09:43 AM
Army now onwards must keep Rediff reporters as sheild and lets see how rediffs beloved behave there..

   Forward   |   Report abuse
subhash vaidya
Issues facing Kashmir
by subhash vaidya on Apr 09, 2018 08:02 AM

In general, the level of education in the muslim community is low, so it is the duty of the teachers of their religion to provide correct guidance to their followers which will help them to live as good members of the society in peace and lead a happy life.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
satya pal
kashmir problem
by satya pal on Apr 09, 2018 06:39 AM

leaders of kashmir,specially separatists are responsible for the fate of kashmiri people.who finances them.kashmiri people have all the privileges that are availed by other india states.kashmir police are biased.they are not discharging their duties honestly.when jawans face stone thrown on them,then they were under compulsion to take human as shield.because there was no other choice.let us study frommhuman angle.kashmiri get free education,free market to sell their products.indian tourists are their big income.then who stops them to earn.handful sponsored stone pelters,pakistan sponsored terrorists who want to instill economic harm to the local people.local people have no support from police.what a poor kashmiri can do against a gun trotter who threatens his life.what he should do save his life.increase the strength of police personnel.go on killing intruders who hold guns.they are not coming as tourists.they are mostly Pakistani.no love for kashmiri or indian.govt. must provide military and police protection to border villages.indian can defeat pakistani ill designs.India is a big country.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Rajan Sodankur
What this Ashan Untoo aiming for a Nobel award
by Rajan Sodankur on Apr 09, 2018 06:03 AM

doing when some Paki sponsored Kashmiri youths were pelting stones at patriotic soldiers doing their duties. How many stone pelters Kashmiri ploice arrested and convicted despite VDO records of their crimes available with media?

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Sameer Shaikh
Another argument
by Sameer Shaikh on Apr 09, 2018 12:04 AM  | Hide replies

The topic is so complex that on Indian side, people say Kashmiris are thankless, traitors, stone pelters, Pakistan supporters, muslims fundamentalist etc

Other side Kashmiris say, Indian security forces commit non stop human right violations, there is lack of freedom, army control, regular curfew, people live in fear, regular crackdown and arrest without trail, disappearance.

Who is right? Who is wrong. Lets leave that

More than political situation, 90% kashmiris feel India has failed as nation to stand up for its common men and this GDP growth, stock exchange boom is meant for crony capitalist. Since the trickle down theory has failed, the income does not reach the lowest end. Remember only 15% want to merge with Pakistan, and Pakistan image has taken a beating after 2001 where militancy, extremism,lawlessness, mafia and corruption made Pakistan a failed state. 70% want independent Kashmir.Most of them are aware of their land status and article 370 and UN resolution in their favour. Just imagine, if India was galloping like China, or have many Hong Kong, Dubai, Switzerland and many success stories within India, would they be asking for freedom? They all would have decided to vote for kashmir permanent integration with India. Very few can resist a discipline and rich country. We Indians even after so much british torture and slavery line up to work in UK. Thats the power of money.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Sameer Shaikh
Re: Another argument
by Sameer Shaikh on Apr 09, 2018 12:10 AM
The only way India can win Kashmir dispute is making India a rich and prosperous country where even poor people can only dream to live and work and make money.

Unfortunately Indian system is such that it favors corrupt politicians, bureaucrats and crony capitalist who are masters of our crook politicians. This system ensures we grow at low speed, where these crooks decide inflation and market price like petrol etc.




   Forward   |   Report abuse
Sarath Chandra
More human shield
by Sarath Chandra on Apr 08, 2018 09:52 PM

More human shield's will reduce problems in Kashmir.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 35 messages Pages: | 1 | 2 | 3   Older >
Write a message