Re: Re: shoot them all
by parmanand khialani on Apr 23, 2016 12:32 PM
In Iraq, Iraq, Libya, Syria all the persons are of your caste, yet they are burning more than Kashmir.
Re: shoot them all
by a m on Aug 09, 2016 03:00 PM
Laws of secret human motivated actions are of a different form from the laws of simple mechanics of physical objects. If an outsider is controlling the observed activities then these can follow arbitrary laws because there are independent variables that are not being observed while studying the situation.
Inferences about causes and effects are valid only if all independent variables are observed. As long as we know that there are independent variables that are outside our field of observation, the observed events cannot be explained nor can the causes and effects or future trajectory of events be predicted.
Indian discussions about the situations in Kashmir happening from time to time always tend to ignore the effect of secret motivated actions of Pakistan. These discussions asre therefore unscientific and therefore do not comprise knowledge but mere speculation or imagination.
As there is no discovery in the above it follows that those who do these discussions have secret motives for avoiding discussion and observation and elimination of the effects of Pakistan on the situations in Kashmir. There should be study and discussion of these secret motives of Indians too. They seem to be intended to favour Pakistan.
Re: Is military meant only to die?
by Manohar Mann on Apr 22, 2016 11:29 AM
Yes, no soldier should ever lose his life in Kashmir. We should bring to bear the full force of our armed forces on these anti - nationals.
Re: Re: Is military meant only to die?
by syed ahmad on Apr 22, 2016 07:38 PM
By your standards we will have to kill every single human in Kashmir as from a 10 year old to an 80 year old is agitating against India
Valley has proved that they are only Islamic first, later on with PAK or with India. In last 70 years no correction is taken by any Govt. at present also Modiji wants to resolve the issues with secular democratic way-not possible, how a non secular democrat can accept non secular method and they are in majority in Kashmir. Even if we take correction today-it will take minimum 20 years.
Re: Why the army is down and out in Kashmir
by Kersi Dotiwalla on Apr 21, 2016 11:32 AM
I have regularly read Col Ajai Shukla's articles on Indian Armed Forces though I may not agree entirely with him on some issues. I do not know Mr Ajai Shukla personnaly and have never interacted with him. But based on his articles I think Col Ajai Shukla is more Indian than most of us, who are but arm-chair experts on defence, foreign affairs, strategy etc.
Re: Re: Why the army is down and out in Kashmir
by gokula patra on Apr 21, 2016 11:49 AM
Today army eliminated 3 militants in an encounter in kashmir.. So on what ground this guy shukla is claiming that army is down and out ?
Re: Re: Why the army is down and out in Kashmir
by Ramachandra N on Apr 21, 2016 12:06 PM
Col? Does he allowed to carry his rank now? Wasnt he a deserter? Give in to agressor. Thats what he is advising. TheseMuzzis will never stop. We saw it during partition. Better bootThem than give in
Re: Re: Why the army is down and out in Kashmir
by Sridhar Seetharaman on Apr 21, 2016 12:15 PM
Rediff should stay away from any demoralizing article. Any article shoud support the GOI stand & Army in Kashmir
Re: Why the army is down and out in Kashmir
by Kersi Dotiwalla on Apr 21, 2016 11:33 AM
I have regularly read Col Ajai Shukla's articles on Indian Armed Forces though I may not agree entirely with him on some issues. I do not know Mr Ajai Shukla personnaly and have never interacted with him. But based on his articles I think Col Ajai Shukla is more Indian than most of us, who are but arm-chair experts on defence, foreign affairs, strategy etc.
