Discussion Board

What you should know about Donetsk, the crash site of MH17


Total 4 messages Pages | 1
Nilesh Panda
Ukraine is responsible for whatever has happened in Donetsk
by Nilesh Panda on Jul 19, 2014 08:19 PM

Its as simple as it is.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
sameer pandita
Russians are not rogues
by sameer pandita on Jul 18, 2014 05:17 PM  | Hide replies

The Russian Establishment would not have done this knowingly .This is a mishap . Even the militia would not have done this knowingly as something this dastardly was not going to help their agenda anyways . US has no moral standing on this as they themselves downed an Iran Airlines in persian gulf killing innocents iranians . People who have lost their dear ones will never get justice much like the relatives of those who lost their lives before .

Russia cannot be blamed for this as putin didnt order this .This is a case of mistaken identity .If at all this jet was shot which has not yet been proved by any international agency it was unfortunate . It could pretty well have been a Air India in place of Malasiyan Airlines.

The best way Russians and Ukarain can honour the lives lost is to declare the area of crash as a no mans land and allow the humanitarian agencies to investigate the scene of crash . This is not going to affect international standing of Russia at all as they didn't order this genocide . Indian Government must refrain from falling into trap of taking sides as Russia has been a close Allie and US has its interest in Ukarain and would leave no stone unturned to malign the image of Russia .One this is for sure even the humanitarian agencies will be biased towards US which has no business in all this . One thing that surprises me still is the precision with which the jet was brought down from more than 10 KMs . Is Militia in Russia so well equipped ?

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Cedric Lynch
Re: Russians are not rogues
by Cedric Lynch on Jul 19, 2014 05:06 AM
Many of the rebels in eastern Ukraine are members of the Ukraine armed forces who have turned against the government after the coup. Any type of weapon that Ukraine possesses could be in rebel hands. Airline flights have recently been passing over not only troubled parts of Ukraine but also over Afghanistan and troubled parts of Iraq. Eye-witness accounts of the crash of MH17 indicate that the weather was cloudy, so the people who launched the missile would not have seen the aircraft but probably detected it by radar, lacked the technical means to identify it and recklessly and wrongly assumed that it was a Ukrainian military aircraft like several others that they have recently shot down.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
sameer pandita
Russians are not rogues
by sameer pandita on Jul 18, 2014 05:16 PM

The Russian Establishment would not have done this knowingly .This is a mishap . Even the militia would not have done this knowingly as something this dastardly was not going to help their agenda anyways . US has no moral standing on this as they themselves downed an Iran Airlines in persian gulf killing innocents iranians . People who have lost their dear ones will never get justice much like the relatives of those who lost their lives before .

Russia cannot be blamed for this as putin didnt order this .This is a case of mistaken identity .If at all this jet was shot which has not yet been proved by any international agency it was unfortunate . It could pretty well have been a Air India in place of Malasiyan Airlines.

The best way Russians and Ukarain can honour the lives lost is to declare the area of crash as a no mans land and allow the humanitarian agencies to investigate the scene of crash . This is not going to affect international standing of Russia at all as they didn't order this genocide . Indian Government must refrain from falling into trap of taking sides as Russia has been a close Allie and US has its interest in Ukarain and would leave no stone unturned to malign the image of Russia .One this is for sure even the humanitarian agencies will be biased towards US which has no business in all this . One thing that surprises me still is the precision with which the jet was brought down from more than 10 KMs . Is Militia in Russia so well equipped ?

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 4 messages Pages: | 1
Write a message