Discussion Board

Rushdie is a 'substandard' writer: Katju


Total 13 messages Pages | 1 | 2   Older >
R SRINIVASAN
Katju on Salman Rushdie
by R SRINIVASAN on Feb 25, 2012 10:13 PM  | Hide replies

Here is a man of stature who has had the moral courage to counter the so called cultural police men of liberalism and psudo secularism.

He has quated enough luminares who were not disturbed by the jaipurites.

the Jaipur fest persons were only mischief mongerstto say the least as also were media and publicity hungry.

It seems thatthe intelligence , the threat and the authers cancelling and the reading out of banned scripts, then doubting of the threat - et all seems to be a clever manupulation of the Indian system.down play the goodness of a religion and the
middle East in particular.
our own neo-intelligensia has toed their line to get small personal favours from theBritish auther and publishersof SV.

the British Govt and media used his book to

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Indian First
Re: Katju on Salman Rushdie
by Indian First on Mar 24, 2012 11:12 PM
Yes,Another sonia slave,Kat Ju,What a Banana Republic we are!A party promises 18% reservation for a minority community, in a SECULAR COUNTRY Gets majority seats& ALL are Shouting this is Great Democracy,etc, WHAT A BANANA REPUBLIC&FARCIAL DEMOCRACY WE ARE! CAN Anna anna hzare&team& RSS,VHP&BJP leaders&cadres&patriots SHOW guts& courage& dtermination to FIGHT NOW for implementation of Uniform CiVil Code???& TO make ALL indians Equal&NOT minority super indians& majority slave indians& REPEAL article 370 forever.Our Rotten elctoral& voting systems is the MAIN REASON for ALL the Corruption&ALL ILLs of our Society too.Anna&Team Members MUST NOT Lose Momentum NOW& MUST FIGHT HARD for Immediate Electoral&Voting Reforms NOW.Following REFORMS are URGENTLY NEEDED Now! 1) Voting Must be made Compulsory& those without Voting, without special health or other reason must be fined or jailed 2) Term of Assembly Must be ONLY for 3 years&NO candicate must be allowed to compete elections for more than 2 Terms 3)If a candidate does NOT get more than 50 percent of votes polled, that election must be cancelled &another election held to elect the leader4) Electronic Voting machines Must be Banned so that crooks do not win election,rigging or hacking the voting machines& Paper balloting&Manual Counting of Votes Must be Re-introduced immediately.5)Hope RSS,VHP&BJP Cadres &ALL Patriots FIGHT Now for Abo

   Forward   |   Report abuse
R SRINIVASAN
Katju on Salman Rushdie
by R SRINIVASAN on Feb 25, 2012 10:12 PM

Here is a man of stature who has had the moral courage to counter the so called cultural police men of liberalism and psudo secularism.

He has quated enough luminares who were not disturbed by the jaipurites.

the Jaipur fest persons were only mischief mongerstto say the least as also were media and publicity hungry.

It seems thatthe intelligence , the threat and the authers cancelling and the reading out of banned scripts, then doubting of the threat - et all seems to be a clever manupulation of the Indian system.down play the goodness of a religion and the
middle East in particular.
our own neo-intelligensia has toed their line to get small personal favours from theBritish auther and publishersof SV.

the British Govt and media used his book to

    Forward  |  Report abuse
R SRINIVASAN
Katju on Salman Rushdie
by R SRINIVASAN on Feb 25, 2012 10:12 PM

Here is a man of stature who has had the moral courage to counter the so called cultural police men of liberalism and psudo secularism.

He has quated enough luminares who were not disturbed by the jaipurites.

the Jaipur fest persons were only mischief mongerstto say the least as also were media and publicity hungry.

It seems thatthe intelligence , the threat and the authers cancelling and the reading out of banned scripts, then doubting of the threat - et all seems to be a clever manupulation of the Indian system.down play the goodness of a religion and the
middle East in particular.
our own neo-intelligensia has toed their line to get small personal favours from theBritish auther and publishersof SV.

the British Govt and media used his book to

    Forward  |  Report abuse
R SRINIVASAN
Katju on Salman Rushdie
by R SRINIVASAN on Feb 25, 2012 10:12 PM

Here is a man of stature who has had the moral courage to counter the so called cultural police men of liberalism and psudo secularism.

He has quated enough luminares who were not disturbed by the jaipurites.

the Jaipur fest persons were only mischief mongerstto say the least as also were media and publicity hungry.

It seems thatthe intelligence , the threat and the authers cancelling and the reading out of banned scripts, then doubting of the threat - et all seems to be a clever manupulation of the Indian system.down play the goodness of a religion and the
middle East in particular.
our own neo-intelligensia has toed their line to get small personal favours from theBritish auther and publishersof SV.

the British Govt and media used his book to

    Forward  |  Report abuse
TT Mahalanobis
Unwarranted!
by TT Mahalanobis on Jan 26, 2012 06:42 AM

Justice Katju seems to be applying his own standards to Rushdie! Nobody has a business to make such unwarranted comments. Probably, he too would have been unsung and unheard had ne not become chairman of PCI

    Forward  |  Report abuse
ppppppppppplll
such orders given by izzlamic judges, no?
by ppppppppppplll on Jan 26, 2012 12:53 AM


they really trying their fullest powers and maximum money,
to do their best,
to put MODI into jailRIGHT?
to put india back into the darkAGES right?

all appointed by madame, no?

all hail to life giver calledS0NIA.

all hail to povertyINDIA calledCONGRESS.

all hail to mental asylum calledINDIA


    Forward  |  Report abuse
Samir Bhagwat
foreign honours
by Samir Bhagwat on Jan 25, 2012 10:36 PM

Any Asiatic or African running down his own country or its leaders are automatically awarded Nobel prizes by the Western world. Merits are hardly an issue. That is why dissidents from China,Russia, Iran etc and Sneering 'intellectuals' from India are automatically awarded prizes

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Louis Hamon
First page
by Louis Hamon on Jan 25, 2012 08:40 PM

I could not read beyond the first page of Midnights Children.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
palanki narayana
Rushdie aims at foreign readers
by palanki narayana on Jan 25, 2012 07:54 PM

I could not proceed beyond the first twenty pages of either "The midnight's children" or "Shame".My friends who had the patience to read through these novels said that the experience was exhausting,but hardly illuminating.Yet,'The midnight's children" was awarded both the Booker prize and Booker of Booker's prize.It appears that Rushdie is aiming at the foreign audience and succeded.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Incredible India
He is completely right..
by Incredible India on Jan 25, 2012 07:44 PM  | Hide replies

Today we try to teach and talk with our child in English before even the child learn our mother tongue. Why ? so that we can feel proud among our society when our child speaks english and thus we think that we have elevated our status...
I dont have any problem with English as a language.. any language in the world is worth learning. However to respect a language to the extent that we slowly started thinking our own language as inferior is not the right thing.

If you go to Europe there are countries which are just so close to England still they dont speak English and never tried to learn it also. They have maintained their culture so why not we? This really shows our slave mentality.. Mind it again I am not against English as a language...

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Decent Guy
Re: He is completely right..
by Decent Guy on Jan 25, 2012 11:06 PM
Why do you think or feel that by speaking or learning English, we begin to consider our "own" language inferior? Or is it the way you personally see or feel about it?
What makes you think that its better to immitate the practice of other European nations like say France, Germany, Italy, Spain etc. than learn the English language? By the way there are several European countries that speak German or French, or both such as Luxembourg, Switzerland, Belgium etc.
Why are we trying to make entire India learn and communicate in Hindi, which is the native tongue of only three major states - UP, Bihar and MP??? What's wrong with it? For the same reasons it is better to select a common language such as English, which is widely spoke, accpeted and learnt and stick with it. There is no other language in the world which is more spoken, understood, learnt, accepting and forgiving than the English language, not to mention that it has the world's topmost vocabulary.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Total 13 messages Pages: | 1 | 2   Older >
Write a message