Discussion Board

Arundhati Roy speaks up about sedition charges, Kashmir unrest


Total 3001 messages Pages < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >   >>
swaminathankt kt
CALL FOR JUSTICE ? AND YOU CALL IT JUSTICE ?
by swaminathankt kt on Oct 31, 2010 08:33 AM  | Hide replies

1.THE ISOLATION OF ORIGINAL KASHMIRI PUNDITS FROM
THEIR LIFELINE AND STATE IS DUE TO INDIAN
GOVERNMENT?
2.NO REFERENCE TO LADAKKI,AND JUMMU WHILE
TALKING ABOUT KASHMIR PROBLEM ?
3. JUMMU AND LADAK REGIONS ARE SUPPRESSED BY
THE MUSLIM MAJORITY FOR YEARS. IS IT RIGHT ?
4. POLICE STATE IS INDIAN GOVERNMENT OR KASHMIR
STATE GOVERNMENT FOR YEARS ?
5. ARUNDATI CANT ESCAPE BY PASSING REFERENCE TO
PUNDITS,AND SOLDIERS' GRAVEYARDS,AND SAY
THAT IT IS NOT HUMAN.
6. KASHMIRI MUSLIMS DESERVED AND GOT WHAT IS
REALLY DUE TO THEM.
7. IT WAS FREE FOR ALL TO CHOOSE ,AT THE TIME
OF INDEPENDENCE TO BELONG TO A NATION AND
MILLIONS ,RIGHT OR WRONG HAVE DONE IT
KNOWINGLY.
8. WHILE ANNIHILATING PUNDITS, THE MUSLIMS SAY
THAT JUMMU AND LADAK BELONG TO KASHMIR.HOW?
9. KASHMIRIS HAD BEEN EVERYTHING IN INDIAN
STATE AND HAD THE MAXIMUM BENEFIT OF ALL
STATES AND NOW THINK OF A SEPERATE STATE ?
10.HISTORY KEEPS ON CHANGING,AND THE PROMISE
GIVEN BY NEHRU,IF GIVEN, NEED NOT HOLD NOW.
11.WHY NOT THEY FIGHT FOR RETENTION OF "POK"?
12. IS IT BECAUSE THEY ARE PAID SERVANTS OF A
TERROR COUNTRY ?

THE SOLUTION IS SIMPLY THIS :
1.THE PRESENT KASHMIRI PROBLEM IS ONLY DUE TO THE TERROR COUNTRY,WHICH SIMPLY CANT WITHSTAND THE DEVELOPMENT PATH INDIA SPEEDING AT.
2.THERE ARE NO HARD CORE,SOFT CORE LEADERS ONLY PAID SERVANTS OF PAKISTAN.
3.WITHOUT RESETTLEMENT OF PUNDITS,TALK OF HUMAN VALUES AND POLICE STATE BY ARUNDATI DOESNT HOLD WATER.


    Forward  |  Report abuse
Indian Rishi
Re: CALL FOR JUSTICE ? AND YOU CALL IT JUSTICE ?
by Indian Rishi on Oct 31, 2010 02:18 PM
Kashmir is just manifestation of Global JIHADI problem.

It exsists every where starting from Palstine to Bali.

ARU ANDI can not see this. She is pseudo intellectual who lives posh area and enjoys the freedome given by the state.

Let the dust settle. She has to go behind bars... and live with the naxals whom she supports.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
swaminathankt kt
CALL FOR JUSTICE ? AND YOU CALL IT JUSTICE ?
by swaminathankt kt on Oct 31, 2010 08:32 AM

1.THE ISOLATION OF ORIGINAL KASHMIRI PUNDITS FROM
THEIR LIFELINE AND STATE IS DUE TO INDIAN
GOVERNMENT?
2.NO REFERENCE TO LADAKKI,AND JUMMU WHILE
TALKING ABOUT KASHMIR PROBLEM ?
3. JUMMU AND LADAK REGIONS ARE SUPPRESSED BY
THE MUSLIM MAJORITY FOR YEARS. IS IT RIGHT ?
4. POLICE STATE IS INDIAN GOVERNMENT OR KASHMIR
STATE GOVERNMENT FOR YEARS ?
5. ARUNDATI CANT ESCAPE BY PASSING REFERENCE TO
PUNDITS,AND SOLDIERS' GRAVEYARDS,AND SAY
THAT IT IS NOT HUMAN.
6. KASHMIRI MUSLIMS DESERVED AND GOT WHAT IS
REALLY DUE TO THEM.
7. IT WAS FREE FOR ALL TO CHOOSE ,AT THE TIME
OF INDEPENDENCE TO BELONG TO A NATION AND
MILLIONS ,RIGHT OR WRONG HAVE DONE IT
KNOWINGLY.
8. WHILE ANNIHILATING PUNDITS, THE MUSLIMS SAY
THAT JUMMU AND LADAK BELONG TO KASHMIR.HOW?
9. KASHMIRIS HAD BEEN EVERYTHING IN INDIAN
STATE AND HAD THE MAXIMUM BENEFIT OF ALL
STATES AND NOW THINK OF A SEPERATE STATE ?
10.HISTORY KEEPS ON CHANGING,AND THE PROMISE
GIVEN BY NEHRU,IF GIVEN, NEED NOT HOLD NOW.
11.WHY NOT THEY FIGHT FOR RETENTION OF "POK"?
12. IS IT BECAUSE THEY ARE PAID SERVANTS OF A
TERROR COUNTRY ?

THE SOLUTION IS SIMPLY THIS :
1.THE PRESENT KASHMIRI PROBLEM IS ONLY DUE TO THE TERROR COUNTRY,WHICH SIMPLY CANT WITHSTAND THE DEVELOPMENT PATH INDIA SPEEDING AT.
2.THERE ARE NO HARD CORE,SOFT CORE LEADERS ONLY PAID SERVANTS OF PAKISTAN.
3.WITHOUT RESETTLEMENT OF PUNDITS,TALK OF HUMAN VALUES AND POLICE STATE BY ARUNDATI DOESNT HOLD WATER.


    Forward  |  Report abuse
swaminathankt kt
CALL FOR JUSTICE ? AND YOU CALL IT JUSTICE ?
by swaminathankt kt on Oct 31, 2010 08:32 AM

1.THE ISOLATION OF ORIGINAL KASHMIRI PUNDITS FROM
THEIR LIFELINE AND STATE IS DUE TO INDIAN
GOVERNMENT?
2.NO REFERENCE TO LADAKKI,AND JUMMU WHILE
TALKING ABOUT KASHMIR PROBLEM ?
3. JUMMU AND LADAK REGIONS ARE SUPPRESSED BY
THE MUSLIM MAJORITY FOR YEARS. IS IT RIGHT ?
4. POLICE STATE IS INDIAN GOVERNMENT OR KASHMIR
STATE GOVERNMENT FOR YEARS ?
5. ARUNDATI CANT ESCAPE BY PASSING REFERENCE TO
PUNDITS,AND SOLDIERS' GRAVEYARDS,AND SAY
THAT IT IS NOT HUMAN.
6. KASHMIRI MUSLIMS DESERVED AND GOT WHAT IS
REALLY DUE TO THEM.
7. IT WAS FREE FOR ALL TO CHOOSE ,AT THE TIME
OF INDEPENDENCE TO BELONG TO A NATION AND
MILLIONS ,RIGHT OR WRONG HAVE DONE IT
KNOWINGLY.
8. WHILE ANNIHILATING PUNDITS, THE MUSLIMS SAY
THAT JUMMU AND LADAK BELONG TO KASHMIR.HOW?
9. KASHMIRIS HAD BEEN EVERYTHING IN INDIAN
STATE AND HAD THE MAXIMUM BENEFIT OF ALL
STATES AND NOW THINK OF A SEPERATE STATE ?
10.HISTORY KEEPS ON CHANGING,AND THE PROMISE
GIVEN BY NEHRU,IF GIVEN, NEED NOT HOLD NOW.
11.WHY NOT THEY FIGHT FOR RETENTION OF "POK"?
12. IS IT BECAUSE THEY ARE PAID SERVANTS OF A
TERROR COUNTRY ?

THE SOLUTION IS SIMPLY THIS :
1.THE PRESENT KASHMIRI PROBLEM IS ONLY DUE TO THE TERROR COUNTRY,WHICH SIMPLY CANT WITHSTAND THE DEVELOPMENT PATH INDIA SPEEDING AT.
2.THERE ARE NO HARD CORE,SOFT CORE LEADERS ONLY PAID SERVANTS OF PAKISTAN.
3.WITHOUT RESETTLEMENT OF PUNDITS,TALK OF HUMAN VALUES AND POLICE STATE BY ARUNDATI DOESNT HOLD WATER.


    Forward  |  Report abuse
swaminathankt kt
CALL FOR JUSTICE ? AND YOU CALL IT JUSTICE ?
by swaminathankt kt on Oct 31, 2010 08:32 AM

1.THE ISOLATION OF ORIGINAL KASHMIRI PUNDITS FROM
THEIR LIFELINE AND STATE IS DUE TO INDIAN
GOVERNMENT?
2.NO REFERENCE TO LADAKKI,AND JUMMU WHILE
TALKING ABOUT KASHMIR PROBLEM ?
3. JUMMU AND LADAK REGIONS ARE SUPPRESSED BY
THE MUSLIM MAJORITY FOR YEARS. IS IT RIGHT ?
4. POLICE STATE IS INDIAN GOVERNMENT OR KASHMIR
STATE GOVERNMENT FOR YEARS ?
5. ARUNDATI CANT ESCAPE BY PASSING REFERENCE TO
PUNDITS,AND SOLDIERS' GRAVEYARDS,AND SAY
THAT IT IS NOT HUMAN.
6. KASHMIRI MUSLIMS DESERVED AND GOT WHAT IS
REALLY DUE TO THEM.
7. IT WAS FREE FOR ALL TO CHOOSE ,AT THE TIME
OF INDEPENDENCE TO BELONG TO A NATION AND
MILLIONS ,RIGHT OR WRONG HAVE DONE IT
KNOWINGLY.
8. WHILE ANNIHILATING PUNDITS, THE MUSLIMS SAY
THAT JUMMU AND LADAK BELONG TO KASHMIR.HOW?
9. KASHMIRIS HAD BEEN EVERYTHING IN INDIAN
STATE AND HAD THE MAXIMUM BENEFIT OF ALL
STATES AND NOW THINK OF A SEPERATE STATE ?
10.HISTORY KEEPS ON CHANGING,AND THE PROMISE
GIVEN BY NEHRU,IF GIVEN, NEED NOT HOLD NOW.
11.WHY NOT THEY FIGHT FOR RETENTION OF "POK"?
12. IS IT BECAUSE THEY ARE PAID SERVANTS OF A
TERROR COUNTRY ?

THE SOLUTION IS SIMPLY THIS :
1.THE PRESENT KASHMIRI PROBLEM IS ONLY DUE TO THE TERROR COUNTRY,WHICH SIMPLY CANT WITHSTAND THE DEVELOPMENT PATH INDIA SPEEDING AT.
2.THERE ARE NO HARD CORE,SOFT CORE LEADERS ONLY PAID SERVANTS OF PAKISTAN.
3.WITHOUT RESETTLEMENT OF PUNDITS,TALK OF HUMAN VALUES AND POLICE STATE BY ARUNDATI DOESNT HOLD WATER.


    Forward  |  Report abuse
gargikekre@rediffmail.com
Arundhati Roy and Kashmiris
by gargikekre@rediffmail.com on Oct 31, 2010 12:27 AM

Only solution is to establish peace in Kashmir, so that in people's life in Kashmir with which they don’t stay any longer in terror and leave life of sedition is:
- When government is already spending so much of amount to fight for bad circumstances aroused then they can plan to spend same or some more amount to create a plan to help them live life.
- Plan which will provide them enough of opportunities to grow. Again plan can be on place but people should be awake to avail that which is next point.
- Those who don't want to let good happen, they could be either not affected or so much affected then make them understand, which can be done by doing right campaign. Campaign? Yes when to win election different parties involved in election can do promotions for themselves, then why can't something be planned to make them aware of better life and making them aware with leading life with peace rather than living life in agony by doing violent acts. It is just that they are not aware of it because they have not been able to realize better life which is in their hand only and not in violence.
After all anything which is known as good is good and which is known as bad is bad only, that we all know.
I am not very much Gandhi vadi, but I like good saying and practice as well - Bura Mat Dekho, Bura Mat Suno Aur Bura Mat Bolo :)

    Forward  |  Report abuse
gargikekre@rediffmail.com
Arundhati Roy and Kashmiris
by gargikekre@rediffmail.com on Oct 31, 2010 12:24 AM

What she is doing is for publicity, having some big dream in her eyes and people whom she is leading are in need of powerful leadership, which is two way between them. Now it comes to other side (in opposition), which are having their own interests and are not matched with her intentions of supporting to Kashmir people. Don’t get me wrong here, people in opposition could be with good as well as bad intentions, I am completely agree that Kashmir is part of India only. This whole is forming a controversy, which is getting heated up and not going to make any sense other than creating more chaos in public. Who is getting affected are public in Kashmir, who have already been living challenging life for long, and now when they have seen some light which they think could get them to normal life then quite obvious to avail the same by them.
She will keep shouting, people will keep reacting but who will get affected local public in Kashmir.
Solution is not so ease, because it is of number of individuals with their different interests involved in whole.
Further to this is in second part.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
indianman
Arundhati Roy
by indianman on Oct 31, 2010 12:04 AM  | Hide replies

Watch this: v0-_HaIC1so
"We need to be careful against them" - "we" being Kashmiris and "them" being India.
How can she get away with it? Watch it, there are numerous references. Towards the middle of the video, she forgets the distinction between Indian rulers and Indian people.

Also, watch how she initially starts repudiating the Kashmiri Pandits' stories, and when a melee breaks out, gets time to recollect her thoughts, and does a volte face after the break!

It is clear that her solution is to break India up into small pieces.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
raghu reddy
This is to the media; you people want easy news with no difficult
by raghu reddy on Oct 30, 2010 11:53 PM

This is to the media personal; you people want easy news, which you will get when you follow one person and you don’t want to do any hard work and no need to scratch head (utterly lasy media people). Please do not give attention to the barking dog. Such a people are there in our country, who eats our own salt and they act against the principle of home land. She wants only publicity nothing else so my request to the media is don’t cover any thing related to her. There is a place in India for these types of people if it would have been any other country they could have hanged in the public mind it.
Reddy
Mysore

    Forward  |  Report abuse
PAREEN PATEL
arundhati roy - the rakhi sawant of indian politics!!!
by PAREEN PATEL on Oct 30, 2010 11:38 PM  | Hide replies

you say pity a nation....that has to silence its writers. pathetic ugly stupid woman!!!

you just said something anti national by supporting those rascal stone pelters living in kashmir who support PAKIS (mind well i do not call them kashmiris because KASHMIR IS AN INTEGRAL PART OF INDIA).
1. If you were a pakistani national? your words would then make sense.
2. As for kashmir - or any other state. You are and will be and Indian first and then a representative of that state.

LONG LIVE INDIAN ARMY - A commendable job


    Forward  |  Report abuse
vasudeva rao
Re: arundhati roy - the rakhi sawant of indian politics!!!
by vasudeva rao on Oct 30, 2010 11:57 PM
let Ms. roy visit talaban leaders and enjoy their company, after all they want to enjoy with such ladies.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
indianman
Arundhati's recipe for success
by indianman on Oct 30, 2010 11:13 PM  | Hide replies

A) Recipe for Booker prize:

1) In your book, write about your brother being sexually abused by a man.
2) Write about your mother's escapades (indirect revenge as well, for whatever she did to you) and describe the copulating scenes as much as you can without the book being labeled obscene.
3) You must be a "Westernized" lady from a developing country, and your values must contradict the women of that country

B) How to be in the news always

1) Find out what made other notorious people notorious and make a list (offend the majority, talk against the government, etc)
2) Find soft targets from list 1 (e.g.: Must not talk about Muslims, ha ha they will mess you royally around. Hindus are alright, because they won't issue Fatwahs)
and start opposing them with venomous arguments. Do this consistently.
3) Make sure your private luxurious life (bank accounts, properties) doesn't get caught by the media
4) Make sure your public "simple" life (which is a facade) is seen by the media and written about
5) See what controversy is getting attention, and rush over and cry "ME TOO!!" - make sure the media laps it up


    Forward  |  Report abuse
R Mit
Re: Arundhati's recipe for success
by R Mit on Oct 30, 2010 11:28 PM
well said

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Total 3001 messages Pages: < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >   >>
Write a message